Quantcast
Channel: The Arctic Institute - Center for Circumpolar Security Studies
Viewing all 366 articles
Browse latest View live

Arctic News: The Arctic This Week December 10

$
0
0


The Arctic This Week December 1 - 7, 2014
 

15270039179_48eedec13e_o.jpg
courtesy: Kunuk Abelsen



Welcome and thanks for joining us this week!
With January looming even closer, there are only a few weeks left in our TATW 2015fundraising campaign!
Over the past several weeks, we’ve asked our readers to consider making adonation to the campaign to secure funding for 40 issues of TATW in 2015. We can only continue the newsletter with the help and encouragement of our readership. If everyone reading the newsletter today donated just $10 the fundraiser would be done today.
We thank you for your support so far, and as always, thank you for reading. Please clickhere to donate.
As always, all editorial choices, opinions and any mistakes are the authors’ own. To comment, to point out an error or to request a back issue, feel free to contact us directly. Anything that we missed? Please feel free to share material with us if you think it deserves inclusion in TATW. If you’re not a subscriber yet, you cansign up here. You can find the PDF versionhere.

ARCTIC CONFERENCE AND EVENTS LIST
The Arctic Institute maintains and provides access to a list of Arctic-themed conferences, workshops, and events. You can access the list by clicking on the following link:
Please help us keep this list up to date! If you would like to add an event to the list, please submit the required information including the event’s name, dates, location, description, website address and contact information usingthis submission form. The list will be updated weekly and a link to the list will be provided each week in TATW.

Registration for the 2015 High North Dialogue is now open. Click here for more information.
Screen Shot 2014-10-21 at 9.44.51 PM.png

Screen Shot 2014-12-03 at 7.19.16 PM.png
 Donate via PayPal or Fundly
paypal_logo.jpg     Screen Shot 2014-10-14 at 11.07.58 PM.png

THIS WEEK’S TOP STORIES
Finnish parliament approves new nuclear plant, though regional environmental groups express concern

The Finnish parliament voted to approve Fennovoima’s plan to construct a nuclear power plant in Pyhäjoki in Finland’s Barents region. The controversial project will lead to the construction of the third nuclear plant in the Barents region. The fact that Russian state nuclear energy interest, Rosatom, holds a 34 percent stake in the project has also created controversy in the context of deteriorating relations between Russia and the West (BO). Regional environmental groups have expressed their opposition to the project. The Swedish NGO, Nuclear-free Gulf of Bothnia, presented a petition signed by over 20,000 individuals to the Finnish parliament protesting the new plant (EOTA). Meanwhile, critics of the project in Finland point with concern to the deepening relationship with Russia in Finland’s energy sector (AJ).

Walker Sworn In As New Alaskan Governor
Republican-turned-Independent Bill Walker has been formally sworn in as Alaska’s 11th governor. Walker, who ran on a unity ticket with former Democratic candidate Byron Mallott, used the event to urge continued cooperation and bipartisanship (FNM). Among his first formal acts as governor was the submission of a USD 5.3 billion placeholder budget – a budget actually drawn up and proposed by outgoing Governor Sean Parnell – for the next fiscal year in order to meet the state’s 15 December deadline, but endorsing the budget as a “work-in-progress.” Parnell’s budget would reduce state spending by some USD 600 million, and Walker is expected to make further cuts to rein in spending (AD,FNM). Walker is also preparing to issue a formal disaster declaration over energy costs in Interior Alaska, though it remains unclear what practical effects the declaration will have (FNM). In Arctic-related news, Walker named Craig Fleener – his former running mate prior to the emergence of the unity ticket, and a former deputy commissioner of the Alaska Department of Fish and Game – as a special assistant on Arctic policy. Fleener has worked with the Arctic Council in the past as chair of the Gwich’in Council International, and “had made Arctic issues a key plank in his abandoned campaign for lieutenant governor” (AD).

Invasive species as indicator for anthropogenic changes in the environment
Professor Thompson, a senior research fellow at the University of Sheffield, UK, argues that invasive species rarely threaten ecosystems, contrary to the panic they induce. Our vigorous battle against them might therefore cause more harm than the invaders themselves. Often, invasive species actually respond to human-induced changes in the environment and do not displace indigenous species, as is often assumed. In view of the warming of the Arctic and the fear of invasive species taking a hold, this is an intriguing argument (CBC).


THE POLITICAL SCENE
United States
In preparation for U.S. Chairmanship of the Arctic Council, check out the PowerPoint outlining its goals and organizational thematic areas from its 2 DecemberVirtual Stakeholder Outreach Forum.
Canada
Europe

ENERGY
Falling oil prices spell trouble for states

Plummeting oil prices are beginning to spell trouble for companies and states. Alaska’s Department of Revenue projects that prices could continue to fall to USD 65 a barrel, which will translate into a USD 1 billion deficit in the coming year which will have to be covered by the state’s savings (ADN).Alaska, which recently overhauled its state oil taxes in the hopes of encouraging development to reverse production declines and associated drops in state revenue, is also considering a proposal to grant royalty relief to Caelus Energy Alaska to encourage the company to develop a challenging field on the North Slope. Supporters of the royalty relief say it will be a net gain over the projected 30-year production life of the field, while critics say it gives away too much revenue which the state desperately needs (ADN). While the royalty relief program has been active for nearly 20 years in the state, it has only been used on rare occasions (PN). On the other side of the Arctic, Russia is facing a dire fiscal situation due to the collapse of oil prices. The Arctic Journal provides a helpful overview of Russia’s woes with some links to recent media articles to provide different perspectives on the topic. The drastic drop in oil prices has led some to ask: is the Arctic dream dead (OilPrice)?

Russia

Alaska

Finland

Canada

Norway

Odfjell dropper oppsigelser (AB).

SCIENCE, ENVIRONMENT AND WILDLIFE

Climate
Flora, fauna, ecology
Caribou and game
Science
Environmental management
Miscellaneous


MILITARY / SEARCH & RESCUE
Many feared dead after South Korean fishing boat sinks in Bering Sea
A 326-foot fishing vessel carrying 60 crew – the 501 Oryong– sank 30 November in Russian waters, 15 miles from U.S. waters, with rough seas, bad weather, and poor visibility hampering rescue efforts. Seven survivors were picked up – all suffering from hypothermia – and rescuers have recovered 27 bodies thus far. The search remains underway, with the Russian crews and the U.S. Coast Guard working together on the rescue and recovery efforts (AD,KTUU,AD,AD).
Europe
United States
MINING
Historic extraction licenses granted in Russia

In Novaya Zemlya, a former Soviet nuclear test site in the Russian Arctic, no military or civilian bodies have been allowed to operate or develop any types of business, including the mining sector, until now.  A Rosatom-owned mining company has been granted the license to develop the Pvlovsk deposit for lead and zinc ores, with production planned for 2019 (EOTA).

Minor victory for Pebble Partnership
The judge for the Alaska federal district court granted the request for a preliminary injunction made by Pebble Partnership, the group planning to develop a mine in Bristol Bay, Alaska, which requires the Environmental Protection Agency to temporarily stop using the U.S. Clean Water Act to preemptively restrict and ban permits for developing the mine project, the final fate of which is still to be determined (PN).

Greenland project may be making a comeback

PricewaterhouseCoopers has indicated there may be a new buyer to take over London Mining’s Greenland activities following the firm’s declaration of insolvency, which has left the Greenland uranium mining project in limbo.  The Greenlandic government must approve any license transfer, so the uranium project isn’t completely out of hot water yet, though this promise of a new investor has breathed new hope into the dying project (The Arctic Journal).
A new research report discusses the implications the changing Arctic environment has on the extractive industry, calling for a long-term, supply-and-demand-centered perspective on the issue. (Adjacent Government).
A report by Visser Deloitte indicates new methodologies that could be used to improve worker safety at oil sands, calling for the use of data analysis techniques and cultural shifts (CMJ).
Cree youth protested the development of uranium mining in their hometown by walking 600 km from Misstissini, Quebec to Quebec City (CBC).
FISHERIES, SHIPPING AND OTHER BUSINESS NEWS

The “Barents farm” as example for cross-border cooperation

Running a dairy farm in the Arctic is not easy, but Birger Bull, a young farmer from Troms county, located on 69 degree northern latitude in Norway, and his family made it possible. Their unusual “Barents Farm” was designed by Nedzad Zdralovicha, a professional engineer and adviser on agricultural issues to the Governor of Finnmark. The building combines the family’s apartment and a big room for 140 cows. According to Birger and Nedzad, the farm is an excellent example of the benefits that can be derived from sharing experiences and expertise across the border (BO).

The Sakha Republic as Arctic Trading Zone

In her article, Mia Bennett examines the Sakha Republic in the Russian Far East (RFE) as an important Arctic Trading Zone. Historically, there have been strong ties between certain indigenous peoples in the RFE and Alaska. From an economic and infrastructure perspective, the region forms the eastern part of the Northern Sea Route. Bennett furthermore analyzes the ties between different geographic regions in relation to the Sakha Republic (World Policy).

Wood cutting on social media - Wayne Hunter the Wood Cutter
Using social media is probably an unconventional marketing strategy for a wood cutter. Roughly ten years ago, Hunter started cutting wood on the weekends to pay for his 12 children’s food after his retirement from the military. Hunter’s business has a website, is present on social media and went from selling a few cords a month to 1000 cords a year. The marketing campaign, Free Firewood Fridays, helps to further raise his popularity (NM).

Fisheries
Shipping
Other business and economic news
HEALTH, YOUTH, SOCIETY AND CULTURE
High rates of Alaskan children in foster care
A new report has indicated the continuing high numbers of Alaskan children in foster care, with 1 out of every 100 children in the state in foster care, almost double the national rate. 3 out of every 100 Native children are in foster care. This trend remains despite a push to reduce these numbers, and often the children come from dangerous and neglectful homes, frequently as a result of excessive drinking and drug use by their parents  (AD).

Funding for women discriminates against Inuit

According to Pauktuutit Inuit Women of Canada, an organization that helps female victims of violence, the Canadian Government is discriminating against Inuit women by not adequately funding the organization and by excluding Inuit women from funding designated for shelters (NN).    

Men join fight against female violence

A group of men in Yukon organized a “12 Days to End Violence Against Women” campaign, who want to change the way men express themselves and see a decrease in women who suffer from sexual assault, an issue which is particularly relevant in Yukon, where women are three times as likely to suffer from violent and sexual assault that the rest of Canada (YN).

Anniversary of Polytechnique shooting

This week was the 25th anniversary of the 1989 shooting of 14 women in the Montreal Massacre at École Polytechnique, and it prompted some reflection and tributes to those who were killed (CBC). One artist took to Twitter, using #Dec6, to honor these women by drawing them, which was well-received and re-Tweeted by many others commemorating the anniversary (CBC).
Health
The University of Alaska has proposed a new policy that would ban all forms of tobacco from all school property, a measure that is highly divisive, as indicated by the deadlock vote by employees at UAF last year (FNM).

Youth and Education
Youth in Nunavik got to show off their diverse talents at a talent show this week, which featured a number of both modern and traditional acts as well as performances from local adult musicians, all with the goal of raising youth self-esteem and pride (CBC).
The Juneau school superintendent has announced his intention to remove four contentious books from the district’s school curriculum, as many have called into question the historical and cultural accuracy of these books, which deal with Native American history (AD).
New anti-smoking campaigns targeting youth feature personal stories from long-term smokers who often started smoking as kids, in hopes that these messages will be more relatable and deter young people from taking up the destructive habit (AD).

Society
A pilot project, headed by Boyle Street Community Service, is aiming to help Aboriginals in Edmonton in Alberta, Canada to navigate red tape surrounding lost treaty cards (CBC).
In Cambridge Bay, residents raised over CAN 3,000 for a local food bank by organizing a fundraiser at a coffeehouse after the annual Santa Claus parade (NN).
This opinion piece on the development of the 2-year-old “Idle No More” movement for Indigenous rights is an interesting read, as it provides an insight into the purpose, direction and struggles of the movement (CBC).
Statistics Canada reported December 1st that Nunavut, the smallest jurisdiction in Canada, continues to have the highest homicide rate in the country, despite national rates falling to the lowest rates since 1966 (NN).
The “Black Lives Matter” protests, which have continued throughout most major US cities in recent weeks following the outcomes of two separate trials where white police officers killed unarmed black men, have made their way to Anchorage, where the NAACP Youth Council led demonstrations, despite the generally positive relationship between citizens and police officers in Anchorage (AD).
This reflection on culinary traditions in Denmark is worth reading in light of the “national dish” of Denmark being newly named (The Arctic Journal).
A loose dog, dubbed “George the Adventure Dog,” who has been roaming near the Denali highway for the past few months is the subject of discussion for those who are trying to find a safe and humane way to capture him so he can be moved to a safer area away from speeding cars (FNM).

Culture
Filmmakers from all over the Barents region gathered at the 2014 Northern Character film festival in Murmansk, which allows artists to share their work and discuss important issues, such as reporting on international events accurately (BO).
A Montreal filmmaker, Wiebke von Carolsfeld, is looking for a new young Aboriginal actress to star in her upcoming film, The Saver, which tells the story of a young girl who lost her mother in a particularly harsh winter storm (CBC).
The story of Chris McCandles, the man who died in a school bus he was using for shelter in Alaska, and whose story has been told in the recent film Into the Wild, is now featured in a new documentary on PBS in the U.S. (CBC).
When most undergraduates study abroad, they visit places like Spain or England.  Andrew Wong, an Ontario native, however, chose to spend his time in Igloolik, Nunavut, completing a project on food security and the environment, and his story is worth a read (The Arctic Journal).

INFRASTRUCTURE
United States
Europe

Abbreviation Key
Aboriginal Peoples Television Network (APTN)
Aftenbladet (AB)
Alaska Business Monthly (ABM)
Alaska Dispatch (AD)
Alaska Journal of Commerce (AJC)
Alaska Native News (ANN)
Alaska Public Media (APM)
Anchorage Daily News (ADN)
Arctic Info (Russian) (AIR)
Arctic Institute (TAI)
Barents Nova (BN)
Barents Observer (BO)
Bristol Bay Times (BBT)
BusinessWeek (BW)
Canadian Mining Journal (CMJ)
Christian Science Monitor (CSM)
Eye on the Arctic (EOTA)
Fairbanks Daily News-Miner (FNM)
Financial Times (FT)
Globe and Mail (G&M)
Government of Canada (GOC)
Government of the Northwest Territories (GNWT)
Huffington Post (HP)
Indian Country Today Media Network (ICTMN)
Johnson’s Russia List (JRL)
Kalaallit Nunaata Radioa (KNR)
Lapin Kansa (LK)
Moscow Times (MT)
National Geographic (NG)
Natural Gas Europe (NGE)
Naval Today (NT)
New York Times (NYT)
Northern Journal (NJ)
Northern News Service Online (NNSO)
Northern Public Affairs (NPA)
Norwegian Polar Institute (NPI)
Nunatsiaq News (NN)
Oil & Gas Journal (OGJ)
Ottawa Citizen (OC)
Petroleum News (PN)
RIA Novosti (RIAN)
Russia Beyond the Headlines (RBTH)
Russia Today (RT)
Voice of Russia (VOR)
Wall Street Journal (WSJ)
Washington Post (WP)
Whitehorse Star (WS)
Winnipeg Free Press (WFP)
Yukon News (YN)



























America is Not (Yet) an Arctic Nation

$
0
0



A response to Admiral Robert J Papp, Jr.: America is Not (Yet) an Arctic Nation
Victoria Herrmann, December 15, 2014


USCGC_Healy_(WAGB-021.jpg
Photo: USCG

A lot has changed since the United States has last held the Chairmanship of the Arctic Council in 1998. What was once seen as a closed theater of the Cold War has been transformed into a global hot spot for scientific research, resource development, and economic potential. The effects of climate change have unearthed opportunities and challenges for not only the eight Arctic nations, but also countries and activist groups across the globe that are concerned and enticed by the melting pole.   

One thing, however, has remained relatively constant: the American public still sees its northern territory as remote, and the Arctic region in general as an uninhabited wilderness of glaciers, snow, and polar bears on icebergs.

Four million people live in the Arctic – a far cry from the barren white landscape photographs that accompany news reports and policy memos. The history of humans in the Arctic, dating back over twenty thousand years, is woven not just from the development of unique languages, values, and traditions of its residents but also of legal battles, economic growth, and trials of varying public governance structures. It is a history of anything but a tabula rasa.  

In April, the United States will again take over the Arctic Council chairmanship. In a recent article, Admiral Robert J Papp, Jr., the first U.S. Special Representative of the Arctic, outlined his priorities for the next two years: Arctic Ocean safety, security, and stewardship; economic and living conditions of Arctic communities; and climate change mitigation and adaptation.

Addressing human safety, community development, and climate concerns are all profound and urgent issues that must be addressed. But as an Arctic nation, America’s obligation goes beyond using its human, financial, and scientific resources to help the region adapt to and mitigate environmental shifts. It must also educate its residents in the lower 49 on what being an “Arctic Nation” means.
Moving beyond a tradition heavy in science, security, and economy, the U.S. should use its chairmanship as an opportunity to invest in education of the Arctic and cultural exchange between its northern and southern citizenry.
Today, the Arctic largely exists within the education curriculum as a science, focusing on the geophysical and climate change. But there too exists a human story of the Arctic – as Papp defines it, “a story of adaptation and survival” in some of the harshest conditions on earth. While this human story has been largely overlooked, the next two years provide a chance for education policymakers to provide recourses for teachers to bring an awareness and understanding of an inhabited Arctic to their students. Lesson plans could include art, music, and literature; the value of traditional knowledge; the history of development and native rights; and current issues like public health facing Alaskan communities.    

Educational opportunities have the potential to also thrive outside the classroom through cultural exchange programs. The Fulbright Arctic Initiative is a new program that will bring together scholars, professionals, and applied researchers from Arctic nations to work on collaborative projects. Through exchanges to the Arctic, grantees will engage in research on energy, water, health, and infrastructure issues. Admiral Papp should encourage the creation of more opportunities like Fulbright for exchanges between youth and professionals in the Arctic and contiguous U.S. Programs that foster understanding and collaboration between Arctic and non-Arctic residents can help to close the gap between America’s north and south while dismantling the perception of the Arctic as a remote part of American territory and identity.
Museum exhibits and festivals provide an alternative way to reach a broader audience. While the Arctic Council’s responsibilities reside within the Department of State, Admiral Papp could support the Smithsonian Institution in producing Arctic traveling exhibitions and community programming across the country. Exhibits could use resources from museums within the Institute, like the National Museum of the American Indian and the Smithsonian American Art Museum. The Smithsonian Folklife Festival, an annual event held for two weeks each July on the National Mall, is a great opportunity to bring the Arctic to the rest of the country. The festival chooses a particular nation or region for an educational presentation through art, dance, storytelling, music, and food, and draws over a million visitors every year.

By reinforcing the inclusion of the Arctic in national education curricula, buttressing exchanges that foster lasting relationships between the north and south, and supporting Arctic festivals and exhibits, the U.S. could use its chairmanship to offer the average American a better understanding of their 49th state.  

After attending the Arctic Circle Assembly in Reykjavik, Iceland, Admiral Papp realized “that we are all connected through the Arctic, whether environmentally, through the global impacts of climate change; economically through international trade; or scientifically through multi-national research initiatives.” But if America is to truly become the “Arctic Nation” it boasts to be, we must also be humanly connected through the culture and identity of our fellow citizens that call the Arctic home.   


Ms. Herrmann is a Gates Cambridge Scholar at the Scott Polar Research Institute at Cambridge University. Previously, she was a Fulbright grantee in Canada researching indigenous participation at climate negotiations and a Junior Fellow at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace in Washington, DC.



















Arctic News: The Arctic This Week December 17

$
0
0


The Arctic This Week December 8 - 14, 2014
 

15270231797_52e30b3387_o-001.jpg
courtesy: Mads Pihl



Welcome and thanks for joining us this week for our last issue of TATW in 2014!

It’s our final issue of 2014, which means we’ll ask you one last time to make a donation to our TATW 2015 fundraising campaign. Please consider supporting us this year so our authors can keep working on the newsletter next year and put out another 40 stellar issues in 2015!  Click here to donate.

We hope that you find TATW interesting and entertaining to read. If you’re not a subscriber yet, you can sign up here. You can find the PDF version here.

As always, all editorial choices, opinions and any mistakes are the authors’ own. Anything that we missed? Please feel free to share material with us if you think it deserves inclusion in TATW.

ARCTIC CONFERENCE AND EVENTS LIST
The Arctic Institute maintains and provides access to a list of Arctic-themed conferences, workshops, and events. You can access the list by clicking on the following link:
Please help us keep this list up to date! If you would like to add an event to the list, please submit the required information including the event’s name, dates, location, description, website address and contact information usingthis submission form. The list will be updated weekly and a link to the list will be provided each week in TATW.

Registration for the 2015 High North Dialogue is now open. Click here for more information.
Screen Shot 2014-10-21 at 9.44.51 PM.png

Screen Shot 2014-12-17 at 9.44.43 AM.png
 Donate via PayPal or Fundly
paypal_logo.jpg     Screen Shot 2014-10-14 at 11.07.58 PM.png

THIS WEEK’S TOP STORIES
Denmark submits North Pole claim
Denmark has formally submitted a claim to the UN for the area around the North Pole, challenging similar claims by Canada and Russia. The Danish claim is based off of data Denmark argues shows the Lomonosov Ridge is an extension of Greenland’s continental shelf, and covers some 895,000 square kilometers –  an area approximately 20 times the size of Denmark. The claim, according to Danish academics, is meant to signal “that Denmark could not be pushed about, but also prove a political point to the people of Greenland” that Danish policy represents their interests, as any natural resources under the claim will fall under the jurisdiction of Nuuk rather than Copenhagen (BBC). According toArctic Journal, the claim is far larger than expected, and actually extends past the North Pole all the way to Russia’s maritime border, though Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov has expressed confidence that Russia’s claims have a greater chance of success than competing ones (Arctic-Info.com).

Dropping oil prices imperil Alaska’s state budgets

With oil prices hovering around USD 60 a barrel, the state of Alaska is beginning to assess the damage prolonged depressed oil prices will have on its budget. The state is projecting a one-year decline in oil revenues this year of USD 2.7 billion, leaving the state with a whopping USD 3.5 billion dollar deficit (The Hill). Legislators are mulling over tweaking the state’s recently revised hydrocarbons law to squeeze out more revenue, but that is unlikely to provide much relief with prices so low (EOTA). The state does have some cushioning from the impact with USD 12 billion in savings that the legislature can draw on to balance the budget. The state’s Permanent Fund made record profits last year, though skimming off of these profits, which feed yearly dividends to the state’s residents, is probably politically impossible (ADN). To add to the challenges, Alaska’s oil production will continue to decline over the next decade according to new projections from the state’s revenue department (ADN). And Alaska isn’t alone. Oil producing states from Texas to North Dakota are tightening belts and preparing for a lean year ahead (FNM).

The extinction of the Arctic penguins
It is rather well known that there are no penguins in the Arctic. What is not so well known is the cause of the extinction of the Arctic species known as the Great auk, the Pinguinus impennis. Carlos Duarte links its extinction, only a short 170 years ago, to human stupidity. The birds were hunted, their eggs poached and, most tragically, their last specimens sought after by collectors and museums. The exact same thing still happens today, resulting in the same tragic phenomenon: the unnecessary extinction of species due to human ignorance (The Conversation).
Youth sex-education project wins the million-dollar prize
FOXY, or Fostering Open eXpression among Youth, is a novel sexual health and leadership education program for young women in the Northwest Territories, which uses a network of peers and innovative forms of expression, such as art, theater and music, to teach young women about sexual health (The Arctic Journal). The group, which was founded in 2012, was awarded the Arctic Inspiration Prize for their work this week, which comes with a CAN 1 million check and strives to recognize people who have made a significant contribution to improving Northern Canadian peoples’ lives (NN). The group, based in Yellowknife, hopes to use the money to expand the program to include young men, and span all three northern territories (CBC).

ArcticNet conference held in Ottawa, 8 – 12 December
From December 8 to 12, Ottawa, Canada, hostedArctic Change 2014, a scientific conference organized by ArcticNet Network of Centres of Excellence. Some of the key messages include the importance of traditional Inuit knowledge – “The stories is the data” (NN) and of taking the time to invest in the communities sharing their knowledge (NN). By contrast, expectations of an economic boom or “gold rush” due to the warming Arctic seem to have been “put on ice”. According to Malte Humpert, Executive Director of The Arctic Institute, commercial interest in the region has cooled off and has to be put into global context (DW). For more interviews with other attendees of the conference, read Irene Quaile’s article onEye on the Arctic (EOTA).


THE POLITICAL SCENE

United States
Canada
Voters in Nunavut headed to the polls on 8 December to vote for NTI, regional Inuit organizations, and hamlet councils (NN). Only 1 in 3 eligible voters participated, and there were some concerns about eligibility and election rules (NN,NN).
Russia
Europe

ENERGY
Alaskan NANA Oilfield Services in violation of oil spill prevention & response rules
In asettlement with the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, the Alaska Native-owned NANA Oilfield Services, Inc. has agreed to pay a fine after violating federal oil spill prevention and response rules at its Deadhorse, Alaska fuel storage and distribution facility. In addition to not having submitted the required Facility Response Plan to the EPA, on-site personnel of the oil field support company were not properly trained in spill response (Alaska Native News,AD).

Noble Drilling LLC pleads guilty, fined USD 12.2 million for violations in 2012

Noble Drilling LLC, the company that ran the drillship Noble Discoverer during Shell’s ill-fated 2012 Alaska drilling season plead guilty to eight felony environmental and safety offenses and will pay USD 12.2 million in fines (ADN). Offenses included faulty wastewater management and reporting and failing to report hazardous conditions to the Coast Guard (Click Green). The plea deal also included four years of corporate probation during which further charges may be levied based on additional investigations (FNM). Noble must also implement a comprehensive environmental compliance plan (ME).

Facing sanctions and plunging oil prices, Moscow pledges to continue Arctic development

Despite the dual headwinds of sanctions and plunging oil prices, Russia’s Minister of Natural Resources and Ecology, Sergey Donskoy, said this week that Moscow will continue to move ahead with Arctic exploration and development (PortNews). Development will likely continue as the Arctic has been identified as a priority, indeed a “fundamental national interest,” by the Kremlin, even as the costs of development increase (Bellona). As western companies such as ExxonMobil have backed out of partnerships with Russian companies in the Arctic, near partners are being sought elsewhere. The Indian state oil and gas company ONGC, for instance, has announced it will be partnering with Gazprom and Rosneft in the Arctic, (AI) while Rosneft and Gazprom are seeking to team up to advance stalled Arctic projects (NGE). Rosneft will also push ahead with seismic mapping in the Pechora Sea, another indication that the company plans to push ahead with Arctic exploration despite the challenges (EOTA).

Norway

Canada

Alaska

Russia

Finland

SCIENCE, ENVIRONMENT AND WILDLIFE
Climate
Flora and fauna
Mastodons long gone from the north (Geophysical Institute).
Expeditions & research blogs
Environmental management
Science, conferences and publications

 
MILITARY / SEARCH & RESCUE
Russia
Russia has completed a third military base in the Arctic, this one on Alexandra Land island (Moscow Times). Meanwhile, Russia has announced that the transfer of forces to the newly-established Arctic command will be completed by mid-December (Tass).
Europe
United States
The U.S. Navy and the Arctic (Maritime Executive).
MINING
Troymet Exploration Corp to end project
A smaller uranium exploration project in Nunavut is calling it quits, as the firm, Troymet Exploration Corp., determined the project at Thelon Basin, northwest of Baker Lake, is not central to the company’s business as it seeks to control costs (NN).

Another one bites the iron - Northland Resources bankrupt

ThisArctic Journal Editor’s Briefing explains the recent decline in Arctic iron mining, chronicling the closures and financial woes of many firms in this space, most recently Northland Resources, a Swedish-based company that filed for bankruptcy this week, leaving hundreds of workers unemployed (BO).

The Yukon government is seizing CAN 3 million from Veris Gold to pay for repairs that are urgently needed and that the company has neglected to address at the former Ketza River mine facility, citing legal statutes requiring mining companies to pay for closure and reclamation costs (YN).
Newly elected Siumut-pawn will fight for my neighbor (In Danish, Kalaallit Nunaata Radioa).
Nunavik in Canada says no to uranium (In Danish, Kalaallit Nunaata Radioa).
FISHERIES, SHIPPING AND OTHER BUSINESS NEWS

Fisheries
The coalition will change fishing (Greenland) (KNR, in Danish).
Shipping
Aviation
Tourism
Foodstuffs
Other business and economic news
The coalition plans to breed minks and foxes (Greenland) (KNR, in Danish).

HEALTH, YOUTH, SOCIETY AND CULTURE
New art exhibit now open in Ottawa
The new Arctic Voices exhibit at the Canadian Museum of Nature is now open, and its developers hope to bring the Arctic to the world, fostering a better, more realistic understanding of the region beyond the typical perception of barren ice-covered terrain. It features scientific developments and research, traditional cultural elements such as throat singing, and images of the diverse environment the Arctic affords (Ottawa Citizen).
Critical bill for Alaskan women clears the Senate
A bill, brought by outgoing Alaskan Senator Mark Begich, seeking to remove an existing exception for Alaskan tribal courts in the Violence Against Women Act, has passed the Senate this week, hopefully empowering more women to report and combat domestic violence (EOTA).
Boil water advisory in effect most of this week
In Dawson City, Yukon, a boil water advisory was in effect from the 8December through 12 December following a positive result of an E. coli test in one of the town’s wells (CBC; see alsoCBC). The source of the issue was determined to be a faulty valve in the wastewater system, which caused a sewage main break at the wastewater treatment plant (CBC).
Move over Rudolph, Addjub is taking center stage
Addjub, a young reindeer in NWT, was trained to be around people in order to make his debut as a member of the Santa Claus parade this Sunday, stealing all the attention from the man in the big red suit (CBC).  Despite concerns over his readiness to handle all the attention and noises, trainers decided to give Addjub a shot at stardom and let him try to participate in the parade.  To learn more about Addjub, and for some adorable pictures of him, check out thisCBC article.
Health
Inuit Tapiriit Kanatami, a national Inuit organization, is making Inuit-specific handouts available that encourage and explain proper dental health, which is an important effort given the high numbers of Inuit children undergoing dental surgery due to rotten baby teeth (NN).
As Nunavut’s Kamatsiaqtut crisis-prevention helpline celebrates its 25th anniversary, the organization will begin operating 24 hours a day starting December 15 (NN).
Youth
Sweetest Kulu is an award winning illustrated children’s book written by a Nunavut throat singer that features Arctic nature and animals and is now available for purchase – just in time for the Holidays (NN).
A group of young Inuit students in Ottawa have made a brief video in the Inuit language which aims to help foster a positive body image among fellow young girls (CBC).
Nunavut’s education minister, speaking on a panel of experts, passionately advocated for a Canadian Arctic university for Inuit Nunangat (NN).
According to a recent study in Canada, the rate of young people intentionally hurting themselves, often to cope with emotional or mental issues, has been steadily increasing over the last five years, and teachers in Yellowknife in particular are concerned with the rise of self-harm among youth (CBC).
A really interesting read, this University of Alaska Anchorage professor teaches students to program their own Android apps in his innovative course, and is collaborating with students to develop educational technology to help younger students learn (AD).
Society
Check out these photos of Santa getting a lift from the Alaskan National Guard as he delivers gifts and school supplies to children in the Inupiat Eskimo community in Shishmaref, Alaska as part of the good Samaritan program’s Operation Santa (Tucson.com).
An Alaska assistant district attorney, Brian Sullivan, was shot and killed in Barrow, AK this week, and the investigation is being treated as a homicide, with one suspect in custody (EOTA).
Provincial and municipal government money will allow a Montreal women’s shelter, which serves primarily homeless Inuit women, to remain open on weekends once again, with hopes that this will allow them to connect with more women in need (NN).
Santa Claus for sale (In Danish; Kalaallit Nunaata Radioa).
Binzer’s way (The Arctic Journal).
Culture
The Dakhka Khwaan Dancers, a young Yukon Tlingit dance group formed in 2007, has earned international acclaim through perseverance and hard work, and has grown from 6 members to around 90, dancing at the Olympic Games in 2010 and earning awards for authentic and innovative cultural experiences (YN).
The final portion of the Greenland Eyes International Film Festival began this week in Oslo as the culmination of an almost 4 month travelling festival through the Nordic countries featuring Greenlandic films in a format that allows discussion and interaction (The Arctic Journal).
Through a new downloadable app for iOS and Android, a Sami language mobile keyboard is now available to users, making typing on smartphones much more streamlined and convenient (EOTA; see alsoBO).
Walt Disney’s first Christmas animation film, previously lost, was found at Norway’s National Library during a review of films stored there, and it features Oswald, a character which supposedly was commissioned to compete with Felix the Cat and other popular cartoons of the 1920s (The Star).
The upcoming film, “Hunter Killer,” will be filmed in Whittier, a small south-central Alaskan town, beginning this January, and is set to be the largest production in Alaskan history (AD; see alsoFNM).

 
INFRASTRUCTURE

United States

Abbreviation Key
Aboriginal Peoples Television Network (APTN)
Aftenbladet (AB)
Alaska Business Monthly (ABM)
Alaska Dispatch (AD)
Alaska Journal of Commerce (AJC)
Alaska Native News (ANN)
Alaska Public Media (APM)
Anchorage Daily News (ADN)
Arctic Info (Russian) (AIR)
Arctic Institute (TAI)
Barents Nova (BN)
Barents Observer (BO)
Bristol Bay Times (BBT)
BusinessWeek (BW)
Canadian Mining Journal (CMJ)
Christian Science Monitor (CSM)
Eye on the Arctic (EOTA)
Fairbanks Daily News-Miner (FNM)
Financial Times (FT)
Globe and Mail (G&M)
Government of Canada (GOC)
Government of the Northwest Territories (GNWT)
Huffington Post (HP)
Indian Country Today Media Network (ICTMN)
Johnson’s Russia List (JRL)
Kalaallit Nunaata Radioa (KNR)
Lapin Kansa (LK)
Moscow Times (MT)
National Geographic (NG)
Natural Gas Europe (NGE)
Naval Today (NT)
New York Times (NYT)
Northern Journal (NJ)
Northern News Service Online (NNSO)
Northern Public Affairs (NPA)
Norwegian Polar Institute (NPI)
Nunatsiaq News (NN)
Oil & Gas Journal (OGJ)
Ottawa Citizen (OC)
Petroleum News (PN)
RIA Novosti (RIAN)
Russia Beyond the Headlines (RBTH)
Russia Today (RT)
Voice of Russia (VOR)
Wall Street Journal (WSJ)
Washington Post (WP)
Whitehorse Star (WS)
Winnipeg Free Press (WFP)
Yukon News (YN)


























Arctic In Review: The Top Stories of 2014

$
0
0


2014 in Review: The Most Popular Links, Stories and Tweets

Malte Humpert Tromsø-001.jpg
photo: TAI/Malte Humpert


Happy New Year! From all of us here at The Arctic This Week and the entire staff of The Arctic Institute (TAI), we would like to wish you a Happy New Year and thank each of you for your support and interest throughout 2014. It’s been an exciting year for us. The TATW subscriber list has grown to over 1900 subscribers in 69 countries spanning all continents, including Antarctica. The TAI website received over 400,000 unique visits, and TATW received nearly 87,000 hits in 2014! The Arctic Institute’s research and analysis has continued to reach a broader audience and garner increased recognition from the media, think tanks and government. Thanks for helping us along the way!

To express our gratitude, we’d like to provide you with not one, but THREE different top-ten lists that sum up what has been a great year for The Arctic Institute. The first is the top ten most popular links from this year’s editions of TATW, measured by the number of times a link was opened from our newsletter. The list provides an interesting snapshot of the top stories from the Arctic this year, and the writing and analysis that we all found the most interesting and compelling.

Our second top ten list is the most popular research and analysis reports published by TAI staff this year, ranging from TAI Executive Director Malte Humpert’s assessment of the Northern Sea Route, to Norway Director Andreas Østhagen’s analysis of the implications of the Ukraine crisis on Arctic cooperation.

Finally, our third top ten list contains the most retweeted tweets from our Twitter account, @ArcticInstitute, highlighting what has been popular on social media. If you don’t follow us yet onTwitter, this is a great introduction to TAI’s social media presence!

Thank you for all of your support through 2014 and we sincerely hope that you continue to follow us throughout the coming year. We always love to hear from our readers, so please feel free to contact us at any time. We’ll resume with full publication of TATW beginning January 14th, 2015.

If you haven’t yet donated to TATW please consider supporting us this year so our authors can keep working on the newsletter throughout 2015 and put out another 40 stellar issues this year!

Donate-Button.png

TOP 10 STORIES FROM THE ARCTIC THIS WEEK IN 2014
  1. Asia in the Arctic, WWF Global Arctic Programme - Our most-clicked link was the October issue of the WWF “The Circle” Magazine, which featured the role of Asia in the Arctic, focusing on rising interest and polar activity in China, Singapore, Korea and India.  
  2. Demystifying the Arctic, World Economic Forum - This report seeking to debunk myths surrounding the Arctic and its needs argues that the critical areas to focus on in the Arctic are sustainability, science, investment, and both human and environmental safety.
  3. Arctic Summer: Who Should Benefit From Global Warming?, Joseph Chinyong Liow (Foreign Affairs) - In this popular article, the author reminds his readers that although the Arctic opening poses new opportunities that Asian countries in particular are understandably eager to exploit, Arctic Council dynamics and competing interests are among many challenges to unlocking this potential.   
  4. Russia ships nuclear subs across Arctic for repair, Thomas Nilsen (Barents Observer) - Short and concise, this piece reporting on the transfer of Russian nuclear submarines for the first time in the Post-Soviet era, proved popular among our readers.
  5. The Emerging Arctic, Council on Foreign Relations - CFR’s beautiful Infoguide Presentation made our Top 10 list, likely due to its outstanding images, charts, interactive infographics and, of course, quality information on a diverse range of Arctic issues from governance to economic prospects.
  6. Blog: USA steps up Arctic game with appointment of Papp as special representative, Heather Exner-Pirot (Eye on the Arctic) - This year’s decision to create a U.S. Special Representative to the Arctic and the subsequent appointment of Admiral Robert Papp to the position drew a lot of attention, interest and speculation as to the growing importance of the Arctic among U.S. policymakers, and Exner-Pirot’s blog was one such excellent assessment of this development.
  7. Donlin gold mine brings hope of jobs -- and fear of destruction, Lisa Demer (Alaska Dispatch) - The inclusion of a mining-centered article in our Top 10 is indicative of the growing mining developments and controversies in the Arctic. Demer’s piece nicely captures the conflicting concerns surrounding large mining projects, such as the Donlin gold mine near Anchorage, juxtaposing the economic and human impacts of these endeavors.
  8. Congenial Arctic Council Displeased By Russia's Move Into Crimea, Sidsel Overgaard (NPR) - We can’t recap 2014 without mentioning Russia and Ukraine. This NPR discussion about the impact of Russia’s actions in Crimea and Ukraine is one of many pieces centered on this critical development in global politics and its potential impact on Arctic cooperation.
  9. A Russian Perspective on China’s Arctic Role, Nadezhda Filimonova and Svetlana Krivokhizh (The Diplomat) - The Diplomat’s staff has outlined a convincing and thorough argument as to the strategic calculations behind Russia’s newfound openness to China’s expanded role in the Arctic, as well as the continued tensions between the two countries, nicely demonstrating the complexities and nuances of the relationship.
  10. Advice for the Ice King: 5 recommendations for America's new Arctic ambassador, James Stavridis (Foreign Policy) - Our final Top 10 most popular piece is an argument for increased U.S. presence and assertiveness in the Arctic, with the author calling for more icebreakers, increased U.S. leadership in both the Arctic Council and NATO Arctic issues, enhanced dialogue with Russia, and a dedication to the interagency approach.  


TOP 10 THE ARCTIC INSTITUTE ARTICLES IN 2014

  1. A response to Admiral Robert J Papp, Jr.: America is Not (Yet) an Arctic Nation, Victoria Herrmann - Choosing to focus on the oft-overlooked human element of the Arctic region, Herrmann argues that the U.S. should use its Arctic Council chairmanship as an opportunity to educate people about the Arctic and encourage cultural exchange between northern and southern citizens to overcome the common perception that the Arctic is a remote, uninhabited wilderness.
  2. Arctic Security: Global Dynamics Upset Stable Regional Order, Mikkel Runge Olesen and Jon Rahbek-Clemmensen - Arctic aficionados will be well aware of the frequency with which the deterioration of Arctic cooperation is predicted. Olesen and Rahbek-Clemmensen take a welcome departure from this way of thinking as they outline the varied reasons why the Arctic is unlikely to become a new conflict zone, though they do argue that any devolution into conflict will likely be due to larger geopolitical shifts than from any one specific regional disagreement.
  3. Arctic Shipping: An Analysis of the 2013 Northern Sea Route Season, Malte Humpert - In his detailed annual report on Arctic shipping, which was published as part of this year’s Arctic Yearbook, Humpert’s research points to the Northern Sea Route remaining a limited, niche shipping route primarily for one-way traffic to Asia.  
  4. Greenland’s New Frontier: Oil and Gas Licenses Issued, Though Development Likely Years Off, Kevin Casey - Despite a number of licenses being awarded to major oil and gas companies in Greenland early in 2014, Casey argues that there are too many complicating factors and challenges that will prevent Greenland from achieving sustainable oil and gas production in the near future.
  5. From Seal Ban to Svalbard - The European Parliament Engages in Arctic Matters, Andreas Raspotnik and Andreas Østhagen - Delving into the complex politics of the EU, Raspotnik and Østhagen chronicle the various policy actions the EU has taken in regards to the Arctic, focusing on the interaction of Member State priorities, such as fisheries, with wider EU goals.
  6. Ukraine Crisis and the Arctic: Penalties or Reconciliation?, Andreas Østhagen - In response to the crisis in Ukraine and dwindling relations between Western countries and Russia, this piece assesses the varying responses of the Arctic states, arguing that the extent to which this conflict will impact the thus-far positive Arctic cooperation is far from clear.
  7. Proposed Law Amendment May Threaten Good Greenlandic Governance, Marc Jacobsen - A controversial proposal in Greenlandic parliament that would block public access to documents related to the development of Greenlandic natural resources would harm good governance and is reminiscent of other countries that have made the same sacrifice with negative results.
  8. How We Learned to Stop Worrying About China's Arctic Ambitions: Understanding China's Admission to the Arctic Council, 2004-2013, Matthew Willis and Duncan Depledge - This investigation into China’s journey to Arctic Council observer status presents a story that differs from the commonly espoused theories of Chinese ambition, positing that China’s admission was long-awaited and delayed by Arctic Council institutional barriers, not member state fear of Chinese motive.
  9. Coast Guards in the Arctic – Troubles Ahead?, Andreas Østhagen - In analyzing the role of coast guards in light of changing realities and needs in the Arctic, Østhagen makes a convincing argument for the benefits of cross-border collaboration through an Arctic Coast Guard Forum.
  10. Evaluation of the Arctic Shipping Season 2013, Kathrin Keil - Keil’s assessment of the 2013 Arctic shipping season is sobering for those convinced of surging usage of Arctic shipping lanes. She argues that, although there is a higher number of ships overall, when examined, this increase is due primarily to Russia’s internal use of the Northern Sea Route, and the number of foreign vessels using these waterways has actually decreased from 2012.

TOP 10 MOST RETWEETED TWEETS FROM 2014

  1. #Russia circumventing #EU #sanctions to get deep-sea #oil and #gas technologies for #Arctic productionhttp://thearctic.in/1oDzQAa
  2. Inuk teenager living in Nunavut is doing an "Ask me anything" on Reddit right now. Follow along + ask questions herehttp://thearctic.in/1oYn8Ip
  3. #Russia resumes #Arctic research along Northern Sea Route after 30-year breakhttp://thearctic.in/1vdLRxx
  4. New report on #Arctic Shipping analyzes the 2013 NSR shipping season. Concludes limited opportunities exist.http://thearctic.in/1wl1wxw
  5. New analysis: How We Learned to Stop Worrying About China's Arctic Ambitions: China's Admission to #Arctic Councilhttp://thearctic.in/1x0vPL6
  6. Soon, you'll be able to take a virtual trip to #Nunavut national parks on #GoogleStreetViewhttp://thearctic.in/VCRSXS #Arctic
  7. Scientists find leaking #methane in #Arctic seafloor, shows what may be in store for warming Arctichttp://thearctic.in/1ol5NbM
  8. #Greenpeace launches new campaign against #LEGO over partnership with #Arctic driller #Shellhttp://thearctic.in/1xdm89V
  9. New analysis by @AndreasOsthagen : Coast Guards in the #Arctic - Troubles Ahead?http://thearctic.in/1vTHQjF #coastguard
  10. International #Inuit conference hopes to address consequences of changing #Arctichttp://thearctic.in/1rvxQcv




























Arctic News: The Arctic This Week January 14

$
0
0



The Arctic This Week January 5 - 11, 2015



7006446649_71d73b1770_o.jpg
photo: Mariusz Kluzniak



Welcome and thanks for joining us for our first edition of the new year! We hope that you find TATW interesting and entertaining to read. If you’re not a subscriber yet, you can sign up here. As always, all editorial choices, opinions and any mistakes are the authors’ own. Anything that we missed? Please feel free to share material with us if you think it deserves inclusion in TATW.

The new year brings new changes here at TATW, and we would like to take this opportunity to say farewell to Maura Farrell. Maura joined TATW in February 2013 and co-authored 80 issues between then and December 2014, taking over leadership of the publication in April 2014. Furthermore, she has been singlehandedly producing the beautiful PDF version of TATW since the fall of 2013. Her editorial and managerial duties will be taken over by Doris Friedrich and Caitlin Del Sole, but for the time being, we will no longer have the PDF version of TATW. She will be sorely missed by our staff, and we wish her all the best in her new endeavors and thank her for her long commitment to making this newsletter a success.
 
Today is the final day of our fundraiser to support TATW in 2015. Please consider supporting us this year so our authors can keep working on the newsletter throughout 2015 and put out another 40 stellar issues in 2015! We are hoping to raise sufficient funds to continue the production of all features you have grown used to, including the PDF version of TATW and our list of Arctic conferences and events. Click here to donate.

Donate-Button.png

TAI’s RECENT ACTIVITIES

TAI’s Executive Director, Malte Humpert, was cited this week in this New York Times article, commenting on the decline of Northern Sea Route traffic in 2014. Additionally, in a recent interview with Deutsche Welle, Humpert discussed his expectations for the U.S. Arctic Council Chairmanship and reflected on the now ending Canadian Chairmanship.

THIS WEEK’S TOP STORIES

Ukraine Crisis Strains Russo-Finnish Relations

A Yle survey of 500 Russian-speakers who live in Finland found that some 66% of respondents “felt the Ukraine conflict had negatively impacted on Russia-Finland relations” (AD). However, another poll by Yle also found that only 1/3 of respondents “feel that Russia could pose a risk in the short term,” with over 60% believing it “unlikely that Russia would threaten security in Finland” (BO). Finally, in a third Yle poll, some 63% of respondents favor an advisory referendum on the subject of whether Finland should join NATO, with previous polls showing that “a solid majority of Finns [are] against joining the military alliance” (EOTA).

Polar bears moving north towards the Canadian Archipelago
A study published last week onPLOS One looked at the circumpolar genetic structure of polar bears and the effects of a decline in their sea-ice habitat in the last two decades. The researchers found that the polar bears have migrated towards the Canadian Archipelago in the farthest-north part of Canada, which could be a potential future refugium for the animals (PLOS One). This might be explained by the persistence of the sea-ice, which is more likely to stay year-round. But even this region might not be a favourable habitat for the bears for long (AD). A short video of the USGS gives insights into the methods used for the study (USGS).
Drastic measures proposed in Greenland

In order to save NunaMinerals, a minerals exploration company, from bankruptcy, the newly formed Greenlandic coalition government has suggested a rare measure to write off the company’s share capital, thereby declaring worthless all investments held by the Self-Rule government and essentially nationalizing the firm (Arctic Journal).

Walking with Our Sisters exhibit opens

The Walking With Our Sisters exhibit, which opened this week in Yellowknife, commemorates the high numbers of missing and murdered aboriginal women and will remain on display until January 24th (CBC). Perhaps even more powerful than the exhibition itself are the stories and discussions heard in the “teach-in” series hosted by local women surrounding the event, which encourage women to share their stories and to accept who they are through conversation (CBC).

THE POLITICAL SCENE
United States
Canada
Europe
ENERGY
Shell looks to future in Arctic, while some look to the past

Foss Maritime has announced that it is considering leasing dock space in the port of Seattle as a winter home for up to eight vessels that will be supporting Shell’s offshore Arctic exploration campaign, slated to begin again later this year after a land hiatus due to Shell’s accident-plagued 2012 drilling campaign (KIRO). Shell is proposing an ambitious agenda for 2015 with two rigs working simultaneously to complete up to six wells in Chukchi Sea over the coming years (ADN). Not everyone in that environmentally conscious city is pleased with the news. Meanwhile, many are looking back at Shell’s 2012 season. A fantastic article by McKenzie Funk appeared in the New York Times Magazine that gives the most comprehensive account to date of the grounding of Shell’s drill rig Kulluk and the extraordinary efforts that went into saving it. Truly a fantastic and gripping read. Funk has also authored Of Ice and Men, a book length account of Shell’s 2012 drilling season which will be released this week. Carey Rastino provides an Alaska perspective on Funk’s account in an editorial for the Bristol Bay Times, while Joe Nocera chimed in for the New York Times.
U.S.

Norway

Russia

Canada

Greenland

Sweden

Finland
Screen Shot 2014-10-21 at 9.44.51 PM.png
SCIENCE, ENVIRONMENT AND WILDLIFE

Norwegian researchers drifting through the Arctic
Two Norwegian scientists are currently “working their butts off” during their “FRAM-2014” expedition - a Norwegian ice drift 118 years after the FRAM. Their goal is to gather data to find out more about the “Arctic Ocean paleoenvironment of the Late Cretaceous ‘greenhouse world’ and document a possible asteroid impact” (UiB). In his interview with the New Scientist, Yngve Kristoffersen of the University of Bergen provides some insight into the daily life being frozen in an ice floe, such as losing food, fuel and equipment due to moving ice and snowstorms (New Scientist). Ashort video allows a glimpse on their hovercraft “Sabvabaa,” which is an Inuit word meaning "flows swiftly over it" (Polar Hovercraft).
Similarly, the Norwegian Polar Institute sailed the research vessel “Lance” into the Arctic ice-cap north of Svalbard last Wednesday. There, she will also freeze in and drift in a southwest direction while studying the dynamics of first year ice (BO).

Leave the Arctic oil in the ground
A study by Christophe McGlade and Paul Elkins of the University of College London’s Institute for Sustainable Resources, which was recently published inNature, quantifies the resources that should remain in the ground. If global warming is to stay below the 2°C target agreed by policy makers, a third of oil reserves, half of gas reserves and over 80% of current coal reserves globally should be left untouched until at least 2050. Geographically, we should completely refrain from developing resources in the Arctic (AJ). How this might be achieved politically is another incredibly complex  story, analyzed by Mia Bennett (Cryopolitics).
Weather & climate
Our Shared Arctic - The Future (video clip) (U.S. Embassy Sweden).
The Arctic Streak (Discover Magazine).
Flora and fauna, wildlife & ecology
Environmental management
Expeditions & research blogs
Science news, research, courses
Joint Master Degree in Borderology - Application deadline February 15 (UiN).
Miscellaneous

MILITARY / SEARCH & RESCUE
Europe
New Norwegian spy ship in the Barents Sea (Spitsbergen-Svalbard.com).
Russia
Russia has begun sea trials on a new rescue vessel – the Igor Belousov– and is ready for transfer to the Northern Fleet (BO). Similarly, submarines from the Black Sea Fleet are undergoing training in the Arctic, with a Varshavyanka-class diesel sub en-route to the Barents Sea (BO).
Canada

MINING
Mixed mining economic outlook for Canada in 2015
Slowing growth in Asia, particularly China, has caused prices of a number of metals to fall over the last year, a trend which economists predict will continue into 2015 and cause Canada’s mining sector to face financial challenges (PN). Furthermore, the Hays Canada Salary Guide predicts that full-time mining jobs will decline, with only one third of the mining industry planning on increasing permanent full-time staff, even as more than half intend to grow their business (CMJ). The Territories, however, are projected to see a growth spurt this year due to strong mining investments, according to the Conference Board of Canada (PN).  

2014 bad year for Yukon workplace safety

According to the Yukon Workers’ Compensation Health and Safety Board, as many as 180 people may have been exposed to lead from the former Sa Dena Hes mine during remediation which began in 2013. This is the latest in a series of workplace safety issues of 2014 in Yukon, which had five workplace deaths and 1,700 reported workplace injuries (CBC).

DeBeers has signed an impact benefit agreement with the Deninu Kue First Nation in Fort Resolution, N.W.T.  which gives the group benefits once construction begins in 2016 on the Gahcho Kue diamond mine (CBC).
Peregrine Diamonds Ltd. announced that over CAN 2 million worth of shares of the Chidliak diamond project are up for grabs, the sales from which will be used for the company’s mineral exploration projects (NN).
Victoria Gold Corp., owner of the Eagle gold project, has indicated that the forecast looks bleak in 2015 in Yukon’s gold mining industry, citing lack of financing opportunities (YN).
Nunaminerals fighting for life (Kalaallit Nunaata Radioa, in Danish).
New director appointed to Store Norske (Aftenbladet, in Norwegian).
FISHERIES, SHIPPING AND OTHER BUSINESS NEWS

Border business
The border crossings from Russia to Norway and Finland have dropped remarkably since December. One of the reasons is the Russian economic slump. In Norway, a counterbalance to this drop has been the local border traffic regime introduced two years ago for people living close to the border, including people from Kirkenes, Nikel and Zapolyarny (BO,EOTA). A study, funded by the European Regional Development Fund, investigated the possible effects an agreement with Russia on visa-free border crossings could have on northern Finland (BO). The master program on “Borderology” offered by Murmansk State Humanities University (MSHU) in Russia and University of Nordland (UiN) in Norway illustrates the complexity and importance of the interactions in border zones. Application deadline for the program is February 15 (UiN).

Shipping down along the NSR
The year 2014 has seen a drop in the ships sailing along the Northern Sea Route from more than 70 in 2013 to around 50, of which 22 used only part of the route. Malte Humpert, Executive Director of TAI, considers this as a sign the “pendulum of excitement and reality” on Arctic shipping is possibly swinging back to reality, which is also a good indicator of the general economic activity in the Arctic (Alaska Public).

Low oil prices affecting Alaska

Energy efficiency and “super-insulated” homes in the U.S. and Canadian Arctic
Fisheries
Video: Fishing Legislation will be changed (Greenland) (KNR, in Danish).
Shipping
Aviation
Other business and economic news
HEALTH, EDUCATION, SOCIETY AND CULTURE
Two Nunavuts
This editorial argues that there are “two Nunavuts,” where the first is poor majority which is excluded from the territory’s economic growth, while the other is the wealthy and comfortable minority located in large communities.  He argues that, while it is easy and often pleasurable to place blame for this social inequality on party politics, in reality it is the whole system that is broken (NN).  

A ‘culture within a culture’

Alaska has the highest percentage of Orthodox Christians in the U.S., and this group celebrates Christmas according to the Julian calendar for a full week starting on January 7th.  The Yup’ik culture and Orthodox religion have embraced one another, and the distinct cultural holiday traditions celebrated in this Western Alaska region are truly fascinating to learn about (AD).  

Major community stories from 2014

For a really great overview of some of the major stories and challenges that Arctic communities met this year, this Arctic Sounder piece is a good read.  From politics to fish and deaths to natural events, it takes a look at some of this year’s important community developments.

Alaska’s housing crisis

This opinion piece makes a compelling argument for why Alaska’s housing crisis demands construction of buildings that are more tailored to the environment and specific climate demands, citing high energy costs and low efficiency housing as causes of illness that place huge economic demands on families (AD).

Health
The Danes have found a way to stay positive and happy despite the long, cold, dark winters, by participating in the uniquely Danish concept of “hygge,” which calls for long periods of time spent with family and friends, often eating large meals (CBC).
According to Health and Human Services, over 9,000 Alaskans enrolled in federal health insurance plans for 2015, which is promising, however many will struggle to afford this year’s plan rate increases by between 22 and 40%, which are primarily due to the imbalance between healthy Alaskans and those with greater medical needs (AD).  

Youth
Yukon College in Whitehorse has its own therapy dog to help students feel comfortable and relaxed when talking to the school’s counselor (CBC).
The final meeting of the Sustainable Education Task Force, established by the Alaska House in 2013, ended with dissatisfaction and dissenting opinions over the progress made and decisions reached by the task force (AD).
Swiss open agricultural college in Grønnedal(Kalaallit Nunaata Radioa, in Danish).
Debate Poor transition from elementary school and beyond(Kalaallit Nunaata Radioa, in Danish).

Society
Equinox Adventures has made it possible for Yukoners and visitors of all ability levels to participate in adventures and extreme activities, such as ice climbing, providing a safer and more accessible environment for outdoor adventure (YN).
The percentage of females in prison in Alaska has risen from 8% to 12% in the last 10 years, placing a high demand on the capacity of women’s prison and necessitating the shift of some women to all-male jails (AD).
Building a new airport in Iqaluit will be a massive undertaking and will require the construction of an asphalt plant on land which, contrary to an understood agreement, is currently being used by dog sled owners, causing tension between the owners and the government which have conflicting records of ownership (NN).
Who would have thought that surfing would be a popular sport in the Lofoten Islands of Norway? The Lofoten Masters Tournament is the world’s northernmost surf event, and draws dedicated surfers from around the world (Video - AD).
New language requirements can be costly for business (Kalaallit Nunaata Radioa, in Danish).

Culture
Icelandic composer, Johann Johannsson, became the first Icelander to win a Golden Globe this week, winning the “Best Original Score” award for his work on the film The Theory of Everything (Iceland Review).
After a long month of winter with no sunlight, the people of Inuvik, N.W.T., are holding their annual Sunrise Festival to celebrate the return of the sun, including igloos, bonfires, music and, of course, sun selfies (CBC).  
Despite having received federal funding to the tune of CAN 463,000, Yellowknife aboriginal broadcaster CKLB radio station has been off the air since August 2014 and have not submitted supporting paperwork, claiming that funding was late (CBC).
The proposed Winnipeg Inuit Art Centre, which may break ground within the next 2 years, will be built by and for Inuit to serve as a forum for Inuit culture in the South and will draw international acclaim as the largest public collection of contemporary Inuit art in the world (CBC).
A DJ and music historian has compiled a newly released album of Native North American folk, rock and country music from the 1960s-1980s, featuring Inuit artists from Alaska, the Northwest Territories, Nunavut and more (NN).
Nominations for this year's Koda Greenland awards in place (Kalaallit Nunaata Radioa, in Danish).
VIDEO X-Factor in Nanortalik (Kalaallit Nunaata Radioa, in Danish).
Gay Greenland nominated for Cultural Award (Kalaallit Nunaata Radioa, in Danish).
Information Fair on cultural foundations (Kalaallit Nunaata Radioa, in Danish).
Niviaq Korneliussen nominated for prize (Kalaallit Nunaata Radioa, in Danish).

INFRASTRUCTURE
United States
Canada

Abbreviation Key
Aboriginal Peoples Television Network (APTN)
Aftenbladet (AB)
Alaska Business Monthly (ABM)
Alaska Dispatch (AD)
Alaska Journal of Commerce (AJC)
Alaska Native News (ANN)
Alaska Public Media (APM)
Anchorage Daily News (ADN)
Arctic Info (Russian) (AIR)
Arctic Institute (TAI)
Barents Nova (BN)
Barents Observer (BO)
Bristol Bay Times (BBT)
BusinessWeek (BW)
Canadian Mining Journal (CMJ)
Christian Science Monitor (CSM)
Eye on the Arctic (EOTA)
Fairbanks Daily News-Miner (FNM)
Financial Times (FT)
Globe and Mail (G&M)
Government of Canada (GOC)
Government of the Northwest Territories (GNWT)
Huffington Post (HP)
Indian Country Today Media Network (ICTMN)
Johnson’s Russia List (JRL)
Kalaallit Nunaata Radioa (KNR)
Lapin Kansa (LK)
Moscow Times (MT)
National Geographic (NG)
Natural Gas Europe (NGE)
Naval Today (NT)
New York Times (NYT)
Northern Journal (NJ)
Northern News Service Online (NNSO)
Northern Public Affairs (NPA)
Norwegian Polar Institute (NPI)
Nunatsiaq News (NN)
Oil & Gas Journal (OGJ)
Ottawa Citizen (OC)
Petroleum News (PN)
RIA Novosti (RIAN)
Russia Beyond the Headlines (RBTH)
Russia Today (RT)
Voice of Russia (VOR)
Wall Street Journal (WSJ)
Washington Post (WP)
Whitehorse Star (WS)
Winnipeg Free Press (WFP)
Yukon News (YN)
































Report from 2015 Arctic Frontiers Conference „Climate and Energy”,

$
0
0



Report from 2015 Arctic Frontiers Conference „Climate and Energy”, Tromsø, 18-23 January 2015
Kathrin Keil, January 20, 2014


16131212049_4704fb2d22_o.jpg
Photo: Overland Andersen / UD


Part II: Second day of policy section, 20 January 2015
On day 2 of the policy section at the 2015 Arctic Frontiers Conference, the Prime Minister of Norway Erna Solberg, the Prime Minister of Finland Alexander Stubb, and the Minister for Strategic Development and Nordic Cooperation in Sweden Kristina Persson discussed the new “Growth from the North - How can Norway, Sweden and Finland achieve sustainable growth in the Scandinavian Arctic?” The report suggest as priorities to increase liquefied natural gas (LNG) production and export, develop greener mining solutions, increase tourism to the region, and enhance technological cooperation on ice and cold climate solutions.
As instruments to achieve these goals, the independent expert group developing the report suggests:
  • One regulatory framework (removal of border obstacles, better coordination of construction regulations, and borderless public services)
  • One pool of talent and labour (harmonization of education and qualification standards, new solutions between labour service agencies, make better use of existing Nordic exchange networks, and creating joint education and research programs)
  • One long term transport and infrastructure plan (opportunities for creative funding, better coordination with European Union)
  • One voice in Arctic matters (raise awareness and lobby together in Brussels, develop two or three common Arctic policy objectives per year)
Prime Minister Stubb also brought up the idea of branding the Scandinavian North better to tourists and visitors, using a slogan like “The Arctic – Even cooler than you think!”

Artur Nikolaevich Chilingarov, the First Vice-president of the Russian Geographical Society and famous through the 2007 Russian flag-planting endeavor at the North Pole, referred to the current political challenges in the Arctic. While in absence of international cooperation the potential of the Arctic cannot be used, he sees no problems out there that cannot be resolved through constructive dialogue, including issues of the limits of the outer continental shelves using means of existing international law. He also does not think that Cold War thinking and behaviour will reoccur. Rather, Arctic people will continue their work and their cooperation.

Anders Oskal, the Executive Director of International Centre for Reindeer Husbandry in his talk on “Beyond Rapid Climate Change: Is there a Future for Arctic Indigenous Peoples in the World´s New Energy Region?” reminded us of the many challenges that Arctic inhabitants face in these times of tremendous change. He pointed to the very valid fact that what we do not recommend for the rest of the world to happen (warming of more than 2 degrees) is already well on the way to happen in the Arctic where warming is double as high as in mid-latitudes. He also issued great concerns about the fact that many discussion are not about the “if” but only about the “how” of Arctic economic development.

Salve Dahle, Chairman of Steering committee of Arctic Frontiers, closed the policy section of the Arctic Frontiers Conference with the announcement of the next Arctic Frontiers in 2016. Next year will mark the 10 year anniversary of the Arctic Frontiers Conference. The theme will be “Industry and Environment”, which was the theme of the very first conference back in 2006. The event will thus also be an opportunity for a stocktaking of what has happened during the past decade since this topic was discussed.



Part I: First day of policy section, 19 January 2015
It is early in the year, which means it is time again forArctic Frontiers (AF), one of the biggest annual conferences on and in the Arctic. This year, 877 registered participants coming from 37 countries gather in the north Norwegian town of Tromsø. As during the last conferences, the week-long AF starts off with a two day policy section with high-level speakers and discussion rounds, followed by a three-day science section with Arctic scientists presenting their latest finding in oral and poster presentations. This year’s AF is under the overall headline “Climate and Energy”, with the science section divided into three main themes:

  1. Arctic climate change – global implications,
  2. Ecological winners and losers in future Arctic marine ecosystems
  3. The Arctic's role in the global energy supply and security.

There are a few new initiatives at this year’s AF, such as a separatebusiness section as well as an “Opening Dialogue” on 18 January, introducing the conference theme in a high-level panel discussion addressing among other things the issue of future energy needs, the tension between continuing fossil fuel utilization and a necessary increase of green energy supplies, and the (non)sense of developing Arctic energy resources. Among others, Prince Albert II of Monaco, Nina Jensen (CEO, WWF Norway) and Fran Ulmer (Chair of the US Arctic Research Commission) participated in the panel.

An interesting statement during the discussion came from Jens Ulltveit-Moe, CEO ofUmoe who said in reference to the future of the Barents Sea as an energy frontier for Norway, environmental concerns are not a big issue since the track record of energy operations in the area is too good to have serious concerns here. Rather in focus are economic concerns given that Arctic energy projects are economically risky and unlikely to last for many more decades. This is so because demand for these resources is likely to decline, among other things because the European Union is on the way to adopting more stringent CO2 reduction targets and thus there will be efforts to reduce fossil fuel intensive operations (not immediately but expectedly over the next few decades).

As another argument against long-term Norwegian energy engagement in the Arctic, Mr. Ulltveit-Moe mentioned the high costs that the Norwegian taxpayer has to bear, even for those exploration operations that are not successful, given the strong state-sponsored support energy companies enjoy for looking for energy resources in the Arctic. Nevertheless, no one will probably doubt that Norwegian taxpayers also reap the benefits from successful resource developments, which is not little since it made Norway a very rich country.

Overall, Mr. Ulltveit-Moe’s line of argument is interesting since it questions the economic feasibility and thus relevance of Arctic oil and gas generally and Barents Sea developments specifically (at least in the mid- to long-term), also for an energy-focused country like Norway.

Another interesting aspect of the 2-hour discussion round was that it took until the last five minutes that for the first time the “human dimension” or the fact that in all the discussions about the climate change and energy challenge in the Arctic we have to think about the people who live in the Arctic. Also surprisingly, it was the non-Arctic participant of the round that brought the issue up, i.e. HSH Prince Albert II of Monaco.
Thepolicy section of the conference on 19 and 20 January 2015 involved a large number of speakers, ranging from Aili Keskitalo (President of the Samii Parliament), Prince Albert II of Monaco, Erna Solberg (Prime Minister of Norway), Alexander Stubb (Prime Minister of Finland), Sam Tam (Minister of State in the Prime Minister’s Office, Singapore), Vincent Rigby (Chair of the Arctic Council’s Senior Arctic Officials, Canada), Robert Papp (Special Representative for the Arctic, USA), Tim Dodson (Executive Vice President, Statoil), Artur Nikolaevich Chilingarov (First Vice-President of the Russian Geographical Society), and many others. The following summarizes a few highlights from the first day (19 January) of the policy section.
HSH Prince Albert II of Monaco emphasized that the Arctic is not only of regional concern but also a global issue of resource challenges, environmental degradation, and especially climate change. Also, the Arctic is a strong symbol of the threats humankind is facing, ranging from climate change, degradation of ecosystems, and risks of pollution of all kind from human activities. From this follows that Arctic states surely have special responsibilities and rights in the Arctic but this does not mean they can evade collective, global responsibility for the region. In short, local (protection of the Arctic) and global efforts (prevention of climate change) have to go together since they are two sides of the same coin. The protection of the Arctic has to become an issue of public attention and acceptance just as the opposition to and fight against climate change has made it unto people’s radars. He closed on the words that while “today the Arctic may be a symbol for our illusions, tomorrow it might be a symbol of our ability to overcome the global challenges we are facing.”
16129823558_751c1dc885_o.jpg
Photo: Overland Andersen / UD

The Minister of Foreign Affairs of Norway, Børge Brende, also referred to the global picture we have to keep in mind when thinking about the Arctic. The world is increasingly looking south and east, to Asia, especially China, and also Africa where many countries show high growth rates. But the world also looks to the North for its resources, for growth and ideas for the future, and not least for “our values of democracy, trade, and cooperation”. Brende emphasized the importance of the increasing international attention to the Arctic and thus that the Arctic has turned into an area of cooperation between Europe, North America and Asia, illustrated by many representatives from Asian countries attending the Arctic Frontiers conference. On Arctic specific issues, the Norwegian government wants North Norway to become an innovative and knowledge-driven region, something like a “mini Silicon Valley”. As one small piece of the puzzle, Norway offers to host a secretariat in Tromsø of the 2014 founded Arctic Economic Council.

In addition to outlining theUS government’s strategy for its upcoming Arctic Council chairmanship from 2015 to 2017, Admiral Robert Papp, US Special Representative for the Arctic suggested to use the Disney movie “Frozen” as an example and engage Walt Disney to rise the attention of the American population (and beyond the US) to the Arctic.
16317381195_d63aaa32c7_o.jpg
Photo: Overland Andersen / UD
Ian Storey, Senior Fellow at the Institute of Southeast Asian Studies in Singapore in this talk on “Asia’s interests in the Arctic” emphasized that the Asian countries that have been accepted as established observers to the Arctic Council in 2013 should not be seen as a coherent block. Rather, each applied on the basis of their national interest but they share some interests in the Arctic, too. These range from global governance, climate change, resources and Arctic shipping. In a response to a question from the audience if there might be a bigger role for Asian countries especially in Russian Arctic resource development because of the current western economic sanctions on Russia, Storey sees providing capital for Arctic resource projects as a contribution from Asian countries but not really for technology transfer. This is so since Asian countries themselves cooperate with western companies for resource development technology.

Zha Daojiong from the Beijing University School of International Studies said in his talk on “Arctic Geopolitics: a view from China” that domestically there is not a lot of debate in China about the Arctic. Some interest is discernible in form of perceptions of the Arctic as a possible “new Middle East” and its role and relevance for climate change. But Arctic oil and gas developments are inflicted with many uncertainties, and also Arctic shipping will only be sporadic. For the time being, rail links between China and Europe more important, and are also boosted by a newSilk Road project.

Tim Dodsen, Executive Vice President of Statoil, emphasized in his talk that exploration decisions are not made on the basis of short-term oil prices, i.e. the current low price is not a decisive decision-making criteria for the development in the Arctic, which is a long-term endeavor. He nevertheless conceded that $50 bbl is a substantial challenge for the oil industry. But he emphasized that Arctic development is a marathon, not a sprint. As an example, the offshore gas project Snøvit in northern Norway took 26 years from discovery to development. Oil prices might change significantly during such a time span.



















Arctic News: The Arctic This Week January 21

$
0
0



The Arctic This Week January 12 - 18, 2015

233611521_65cb6c91cb_o.jpg
photo: Ville Miettinen



Welcome and thanks for joining us this week! We hope that you find TATW interesting and entertaining to read. If you’re not a subscriber yet, you can sign up here. As always, all editorial choices, opinions and any mistakes are the authors’ own. Anything that we missed? Please feel free to share material with us if you think it deserves inclusion in TATW.

The Arctic Institute is seeking a Research Associate to join the team of our weekly news brief The Arctic This Week (TATW). To find out more about the position or to apply please consult the call for applications.

TAI’s RECENT ACTIVITIES

TAI’s Executive Director, Malte Humpert, was quoted in this Politiken article (in Danish), commenting on the departure of oil companies from Greenland. Additionally, he was interviewed for an article by Alaska Public Media concerning the impact of falling oil prices on Arctic oil exploration.

UPCOMING CONFERENCE
The annual High North Dialogue Conference will take March 17-19, 2015 in Bodø Norway. In connection with the conference the University of Nordland is organizing its annual Master Course. The course focuses on developing knowledge about opportunities for value creation in the High North, as well as on an international dialogue between important stakeholders in the Arctic region. Application deadline is February 1, 2015. To find out more click here.

Screen Shot 2015-01-21 at 2.53.54 PM.png


THIS WEEK’S TOP STORIES
Arctic oil only for the brave these days

The dual challenges of plummeting oil prices and international sanctions have led many international companies to suspend planned oil and gas projects in Russia’s Arctic. The steep drop in oil prices is not only leading to shelved exploration projects, but is causing some to question the ambitious plans Moscow had for developing its Arctic regions, a development that was to be propelled by oil and gas (MT). Some are suggesting that Russia focus on conventional fields in less extreme locations that will be much less expensive to develop and more feasible given current prices (BO). Indeed we hear a lot about conventional fields in Russia of late, probably because they can also be developed under the current sanctions regime that limit importation of oil and gas technologies that will be necessary to develop tight oil and gas fields (Sputnik News). Despite the gloomy forecasts, Gazprom Neft is plowing ahead with plans to develop new Arctic fields west of Novaya Zemlya (BO, WorldOil). One wonders if politics is driving this decision more than economics. Price jitters aren’t restricted to Russia’s Arctic. Oil prices and environmental concerns have caused many to delay investment decisions in oil and gas development across the Arctic (Bloomberg, Sputnik News). Three oil companies decided this week to hand back exploration licenses in western Greenland despite hefty government incentives (AJ).

Russian troops begin moving to new Arctic bases

Russian troops have begun to arrive at the country’s latest Arctic base at Alakurtti, some 60 kilometers from the Finnish border on the Kola Peninsula. The first to arrive are elements of a motorized infantry brigade, which will likely consist of some 7000 soldiers eventually, with a number of signals intelligence units likewise expected to join them (Businessinsider.uk,Itar-Tass,BO,EOTA). Russia has announced plans to “strengthen its military capabilities this year” in the Arctic, along with Kaliningrad and Crimea (Reuters).

Uproar over the Peel Watershed appeal
Several news articles last week discussed the Yukon government’s appeal of the December court decision on the Peel watershed, which found that the Yukon government’s modifications to the plan did not respect the land use planning process set out in the agreement with First Nations. As reason for the appeal by his government, Yukon Premier Pasloski states that the court’s ruling undermines the authority of the territorial government and that First Nations do not have the authority to make decisions on Crown land (CBC). On the other hand, Yukon's opposition politicians want the government to abandon the appeal, which they say goes against the spirit of the final agreement (CBC). Likewise, Na-Cho Nyak Dun Chief Ed Champion told supporters of the Peel coalition that he will carry on the fight for the Peel plan recommended by the Commission (CBC).

Alaska universities prepare for tight budget
The University of Alaska system prepares for a reduced budget due to the falling oil prices. While the University of Alaska Fairbanks (UAF) announced that it might have to cut 200 to 250 jobs (AD), the University of Alaska Southeast (UAS) already closed its unprofitable bookstore in Juneau at the end of last year (Alaska Public). In the meantime, the Alaska Pacific University (APU) will lease 65 acres of land on its Midtown Anchorage campus in order to keep tuition costs down (AD).


THE POLITICAL SCENE
United States
U.S. Special Representative for the Arctic Admiral Robert J. Papp, Jr. will travel to Russia this month to “meet with government officials, indigenous communities, representatives of non-governmental organizations along with scientific, academic, and business leaders” (Sputnik News).
Russia
Europe
Police Kutter missing crew (In Danish, KNR).
Canada
Makivik Corp. president Jobie Tukkiapik was re-elected in 15 January elections with 51% of the vote, some 20% ahead of his closest challenger (NN).
Elections in Nunavik (In Danish, KNR).

ENERGY

Shells use of Seattle’s port doesn’t sit well with some residents, as challenges still lie ahead for Shell

A decision by the Seattle Port Commission to allow Shell’s fleet to use West Seattle as its home port led to objections from some of the city’s residents who asked the commission to block the proposal (KUOW). Despite Shell’s preparations for the 2015 drilling season, obstacles still stand between the company and Arctic black gold. Several legal challenges are still working their way through the courts and depressed oil prices may yet change Shell’s calculus on Arctic exploration (ADN). In a related development, the Bureau of Ocean Energy Management quadrupled its estimates for crude oil in 2008 licenses in the Chukchi Sea in response to a court ruling that found that the bureau significantly underestimated the amount of oil, thus downplaying spill risks (FuelFix). The BOEM also released a draft environmental study based on the higher estimated reserves (ADN). Shell, Statoil and ConocoPhillips are all asking Washington for extensions on their Arctic leases, set to expire in 2017, as all have faced greater challenges than anticipated with advancing their Arctic exploration plans (ADN).
Greenland

Canada

Russia
Check out this nice montage of photos from an oil platform in Russia’s Arctic (Slavorum.org).

US

Nordics
SCIENCE, ENVIRONMENT AND WILDLIFE

Research during the Arctic winter?
Accompany Irene Quaile on her trip to Svalbard. On her Ice-Blog, she gives insights into the research carried out on the Polar Marine Night expedition, the fascinating marine life in the Arctic winter, and the perks of working and living with an international team aboard the RV Helmer Hanssen (EOTA):

Hot, shaky Alaska
Alaska set new records last year. The 40,686 earthquakes detected by the Alaska Earthquake Information Center in the state and bordering parts of Canada dwarf the previous high of 28,000 quakes detected in 2013 (AD). In addition to that, 2014 was also Alaska’s hottest year on record (AD). This, apparently, made for some greatpictures (AD).

Climate
Wildlife & ecology
Expeditions & research blogs
Environmental management
Landbank Lawsuit Aimed at USACE Regs (Susitna wetlands mitigation bank) (Alaska Public).

Miscellaneous

MILITARY / SEARCH & RESCUE
United States
Russia
Canada
Europe

MINING
AGMC set to move in April
The Alaska Geologic Materials Center (GMC) is moving to its new, larger headquarters in Anchorage in April this year.  The center is the repository of all geologic materials collected across the state, allowing them to be displayed, stored properly, and studied, and the new facilities will provide more space, climate-control, and display options to best present the state’s resources (PN).

Cooperation between First Nations and government  

The author of this opinion piece in The Northern Miner makes a compelling and impassioned argument encouraging territory governments to develop on-the-land stewardship programs with First Nations when it comes to land development, drawing from recent experiences in the Northwest Territories.  The Yukon is seemingly heeding this advice, with the Yukon Chamber of Mines aiming to improve relations between the territory’s First Nations, government and industry, hoping to work with these group to develop guidance for how to create successful partnerships and work respectfully with each other (YN).

If you have been following the progress (or lack thereof) of the Pebble Mine project in the Bristol Bay region of Alaska, you may find this opinion piece, which argues the EPA was certainly acting beyond its authority, an interesting read this week (PN).
Mæland will take time to help (In Norwegian, Svalbard Posten).
FISHERIES, SHIPPING AND OTHER BUSINESS NEWS
Oil price decline affects Alaska’s revenue

Alaska's fiscal perfect storm (AD).


Fisheries

Shipping
Feds, Irving agree on Arctic ship deal (Canada) (National Newswatch).
Aviation
Other business and economic news

Alaska

Greenland

Yukon

HEALTH, YOUTH, SOCIETY AND CULTURE
Russian Leviathan film proving contentious

After winning a Golden Globe and being nominated for an Academy Award this week, the Russian film Leviathan, set by the Barents Sea, has started a debate in Russia over its perceived anti-Russian perspective (TASS Russian News Agency). Filmed on the Kola peninsula, the film tells the story of a man facing a corrupt mayor to prevent his house from being destroyed, and it has been acclaimed as a “new Russian masterpiece” (BO). The regional government of Murmansk is among the critics of the film, with many local theaters claiming to have received a recommendation from the governor of Murmansk to not show the film due to its poor portrayal of northerners (BO).

“Why isn’t he in jail?”

An ongoing investigation into the allegations against a Montana man accused of sexual abuse of nine of his elementary school students in Tuluksak, Alaska, has resulted in a settlement and a controversy, with many wondering why the man is not in jail. Many are commenting that the lack of state action on the case reflects the underlying racial tensions in rural Alaska. This Alaska Dispatch article does a really nice job of giving the background of the case, the varying evidence, and also placing the story in a broader societal context.

Alaskans register for Affordable Care Act health insurance

By mid-January 2015, over 15,000 Alaskans have registered for federal health insurance under the Affordable Care Act (AD). This is a 3,000 person increase in the number of registrants during the initial open enrollment period, and over 90% of Alaskans who signed up are eligible for a subsidy (Alaska Public).

Barents Russia sees huge surge in HIV cases
In the Barents region, both Norway and Sweden have reported the lowest HIV rates in ten years, while Barents Russia reported the highest rate ever in 2014, and this article presents fascinating data and charts in its discussion of this troubling trend (BO).
Kusko 300 began this weekend

The annual Kuskokwim 300 dogsled race began this weekend in Southwest Alaska, drawing participants and viewers from around the region, despite this year’s shortened course due to low snow (AD). The event started off with a lighthearted quick 65 mile race, known as the Akiak Dash, which provides entertainment and allows locals and amateur mushers to join in on the competitive spirit (AD).  

Health

Youth
Yukon College will now include First Nations traditions in the curriculum and take other measures, including an increase in indigenous staff, to better serve indigenous students (CBC).
A renovated Nunavik building will reopen later this month as a community-run family support center for families in crisis, with the goal of keeping adults out of jail and children healthy (NN).

Society
Alaska has the highest rate of people walk to work each day, however, it is also ranked third in the country for pedestrian deaths, prompting the development of innovative designs to improve traffic flow, visibility and pedestrian awareness (Alaska Public Media).
The Inter-American Commission on Human Rights, a Washington, DC-based human rights group that focuses on the Americas, released a report this week assessing the high number of cases of murdered and missing indigenous women in British Columbia, concluding that this problem can only be helped by addressing the underlying factors, including poverty, inadequate housing, and discrimination (NN).
Mushers are making a last minute push for securing sponsors for the upcoming 32nd annual Yukon Quest sled dog race in Whitehorse, hoping to raise enough to fund the race and its 26 mushers that are currently signed up to compete (CBC).
Initiative to Sermiligaaq (In Danish, KNR)
The Prodigal Sun (The Arctic Journal).

Culture
Musician Christine Fellows, whose visit to Yukon inspired her album, will be performing in Dawson City and Whitehorse this week, hoping to share her story and return to the roots of her inspiration (YN).
Verbatim theater, a novel style of performance art based on transcripts of interviews, is coming to a theater in Yukon, where interviews with First Nations elders, immigrants, and children will be performed at the Open Pit Theatre (YN).

INFRASTRUCTURE
Canada
United States
Russia
Europe

Abbreviation Key
Aboriginal Peoples Television Network (APTN)
Aftenbladet (AB)
Alaska Business Monthly (ABM)
Alaska Dispatch (AD)
Alaska Journal of Commerce (AJC)
Alaska Native News (ANN)
Alaska Public Media (APM)
Anchorage Daily News (ADN)
Arctic Info (Russian) (AIR)
Arctic Institute (TAI)
Barents Nova (BN)
Barents Observer (BO)
Bristol Bay Times (BBT)
BusinessWeek (BW)
Canadian Mining Journal (CMJ)
Christian Science Monitor (CSM)
Eye on the Arctic (EOTA)
Fairbanks Daily News-Miner (FNM)
Financial Times (FT)
Globe and Mail (G&M)
Government of Canada (GOC)
Government of the Northwest Territories (GNWT)
Huffington Post (HP)
Indian Country Today Media Network (ICTMN)
Johnson’s Russia List (JRL)
Kalaallit Nunaata Radioa (KNR)
Lapin Kansa (LK)
Moscow Times (MT)
National Geographic (NG)
Natural Gas Europe (NGE)
Naval Today (NT)
New York Times (NYT)
Northern Journal (NJ)
Northern News Service Online (NNSO)
Northern Public Affairs (NPA)
Norwegian Polar Institute (NPI)
Nunatsiaq News (NN)
Oil & Gas Journal (OGJ)
Ottawa Citizen (OC)
Petroleum News (PN)
RIA Novosti (RIAN)
Russia Beyond the Headlines (RBTH)
Russia Today (RT)
Voice of Russia (VOR)
Wall Street Journal (WSJ)
Washington Post (WP)
Whitehorse Star (WS)
Winnipeg Free Press (WFP)
Yukon News (YN)































Article 1

$
0
0


State of the Union From the Top of the World
Victoria Herrmann, January 20, 2014


6167391543_395a7cabfd_b copy.jpg
Photo: Blmiers2

On Tuesday night President Obama took the Senate floor with almost half of the country approving of his economic actions – the most since his hope-filled early months in office. And for good reason. Unemployment has fallen to its lowest levels since 2008, and a rapidly increasing annualized growth rate has led to some of the country’s best quarterly reports in over a decade. While other national economies like Japan and those of Europe flirt with renewed recessions, America seems to have more in common with the thriving, commerce rich boom of the late 1990s.
But not every state in the Union is returning to the economic glory days of “Don’t stop thinking about tomorrow” and colorful scrunchies. The sudden plunge in oil prices has sent a chill across our coldest, and at times most forgotten, region. In 2013 Alaska was the only state where real GDP decreased, in large part due to a decline in mining. With the effects of the ongoing fall in oil prices already seen in a soaring unemployment rate, Alaska is poised to continue its downward spiral and widen the already existing gap between its economic wellbeing and that of the lower 49.
While dropping oil prices inevitably generate concern across a region so heavily reliant on natural resource revenue, it need not be an economic crisis. Instead, this could be an opportunity for America to rethink how it invests in the North as it looks to lead the Arctic Council in a few months.
The upcoming Chairmanship provides a chance for the U.S. to transform Alaska’s economic concern into an international opportunity to create an example of a healthy, diversified, and sustainable Arctic economy for nations across the circumpolar north to follow.
This week Admiral Robert J. Papp, Jr. – the U.S. Special Representative to the Arctic – is touring Scandinavia to present the key issues America will focus on over the coming two years. On Monday at Arctic Frontiers, a meeting of scientists, industry, and policymakers, in Tromsø, Norway, Admiral Papp emphasized his aim to improve economic and living conditions for residents of the Arctic.
His ambitious plan includes building robust infrastructure to connect Arctic communities to each other as well as the rest of the world through deep-water ports, roads, and telecommunication. His hope is, through America’s leadership, to create a supportive environment where those living across the high North can achieve self-actualization.
But in order to realize this resiliency, President Obama, Secretary Kerry, and Admiral Papp must look beyond investments in physical infrastructure towards creating a social system that supports the educational opportunities and entrepreneurship that a healthy, diversified polar economy needs.
While providing free community college education could help reduce the inequality gap in America, Alaskans – particularly Native Alaskans – living in remote communities would face great physical and financial difficulty in traveling to one of the seven community colleges in the state. Alaska is not alone in facing issues of remoteness in accessing education. Long distances and extreme weather make high school and college difficult to attend throughout the Arctic, and often result in high drop out rates and a poorly educated workforce.
Investing in free virtual community college courses and the telecommunication infrastructure for residents to access them could significantly lower drop out rates, provide an educated workforce, and inspire students towards pursuing a variety of careers that would diversify the Arctic economy. The University of Tromsø, for example, offers a free, one-year distance-learning course on topics that apply directly to governance, development, and innovation in the Arctic. Such a program in Alaska could strengthen its economy and encourage other countries to work towards access to schools throughout the north.    
But even with a high school education, today many Arctic students pursue higher education and settle permanently in the southern part of their countries where they can find better, more appealing employment after college. On Monday Norway’s Minister of Foreign Affairs Børge Brende spoke about transforming the Norwegian Arctic into a “mini Silicon Valley.” He described a high north where the local economy was driven by innovation and knowledge. Innovation Norway, a government initiative to support entrepreneurship and development of local business, has helped make this a reality in places like Tromsø. The program gives broad business support, financial provisions, and networking services to small enterprises.  
President Obama boasted that, “No country has more successful companies, or grants more patents to inventors and entrepreneurs” – and that’s true. America is filled with hard, intelligent thinkers in every state. But it’s time to do more to link those hard workers in Alaska to opportunity. This could be done through a national program akin to Innovation Norway that provides strategic assistance and start-up financial support to local entrepreneurship, partnered with successful American companies across the nation.
By investing in people instead of resources, in communities instead of companies, America can show success and global leadership in a region quickly growing in geostrategic importance. During its Chairmanship America needs to build the social and physical infrastructure necessary to educate, stably employ, and economically empower its Arctic residents.
The Union is strong – we have picked ourselves up, dusted ourselves off, and begun again the work of remaking America. But if we are to truly be a strong, tight-knit family, President Obama must not forget his brothers and sisters at the top of the world.





















Arctic News: The Arctic This Week January 28

$
0
0




The Arctic This Week January 19 - 25, 2015

198385159_97f26edefa_o.jpg
photo: Ville Miettinen


Welcome and thanks for joining us this week! We hope that you find TATW interesting and entertaining to read. If you’re not a subscriber yet, you can sign up here. As always, all editorial choices, opinions and any mistakes are the authors’ own. Anything that we missed? Please feel free to share material with us if you think it deserves inclusion in TATW.

THIS WEEK’S TOP STORIES
Executive Order to streamline U.S. Arctic policy

President Barack Obama issued anexecutive order aimed at “Enhancing Coordination of National Efforts in the Arctic.” Significantly, the order “establishes an ‘Arctic Executive Steering Committee’ to guide federal policy and coordinate with state, local, Native governments, research and academic institutions and nonprofit organizations” (AD).

Hong Kong firm takes ownership of Greenland’s largest mining project

General Nice Group, a large Hong Kong-based firm, has taken over exploration of the iron ore-rich Isukasia area after the original firm, London Mining, went bankrupt last year, necessitating the sale of the license it had purchased for record amounts in Greenland. Many have condemned this project to failure after this development, however, with the purchase of the license by General Nice Group, a much larger and capital rich firm, there is renewed attention and promise for the Greenlandic mining industry (The Arctic Journal).   

To drill or not to drill?
The dispute about whether to allow oil drilling in the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge (ANWR) in Alaska, which has been much discussed since the 1970s, has seen new developments in the past few days. Last Sunday, the Obama administration recommended designating the entire refuge as wilderness area, to which the most restrictive level of conservation management would apply (NM,Reuters). This led to outrage from several Alaskan Republican Senators and officials (NM,NM), with conservation groups and the Gwich’in Steering Committee on the opposite side welcomed the proposal (The Arctic Journal; see alsoCenter for Biological Diversity). Sarah James, the chair of Gwich’in Steering Committee, considers oil development as a threat to the caribou and, therefore, “the Gwich’in way of life” (AJ). At the same time, U.S. District Court Judge Sharon Gleason has to decide whether the U.S. Department of the Interior ought to accept an application for a limited winter exploration program (AJ).

Arctic Frontiers: “Climate and Energy”
From 18 to 23 January, theArctic Frontiers conference convened in Tromsø to discuss this year’s topic, “Climate and Energy”, and possibly to solve the question whether it is possible to cater to the world’s energy needs while the Arctic sounds the alarm over climate change (NRK, in Norwegian). After two days dedicated to policy issues, the science sections dealt with three main themes: 1) Arctic climate change and global implications, 2) Ecological winners and losers in the future Arctic marine ecosystems, and 3) The Arctic’s role in the global energy supply and security. Kathrin Keil of the Arctic Institute provides us with a comprehensive and detailedreport of the five conference days (TAI). Articles in theBarents Observer and theEye on the Arctic further explore the issue of oil investments in the Barents and the investment in infrastructure “White Elephants” (BO, EOTA). Meanwhile Germany’s Deutsche Welle examines whether the Arctic oil rush actually froze (DW, in German).

Nunavut food crisis

Food security is not a new issue in Canada’s northern territories, particularly in Nunavut, and despite government efforts to help, the problem persists. Detailing the history of food shortages and consistent increases in grocery prices, this wonderful CBC piece explains how the latest government program intended to address the issue, Nutrition North, has proven inadequate. In response to these trends and the Nutrition North program, food security social activist group, Feeding My Family, has called on supporters to boycott common food retailers across the Arctic, reflecting the frustration Nunavut residents feel (NN). The issue has not gone unnoticed by many in lower latitudes, with people organizing on Facebook to donate food and funds for groceries to northerners who need and seek help, with a particularly large presence of donors in Saskatchewan (CBC).


THE POLITICAL SCENE
Alaska budget scrutinized as state faces deficit

As the newly-elected Alaskan legislature begins its first session, it faces the immediate and unpleasant task of scrutinizing the state’s budget in light of an estimated USD 3.5 billion shortfall due partly to low oil prices and decreasing oil production (FNM,APM,FNM). In proposing cuts, lawmakers have asserted that “everything is on the table,” and while lawmakers have admitted that “there’s no way the Legislature will be able to completely eliminate the…shortfall,…lawmakers will ‘chip away’ at it this year” (AJ,FNM).
United States
Europe
"All" will discuss Arctic (In Norwegian, nrk.no).
Russia
Canada
Asia

ENERGY
Final report on fracking in Yukon – no consensus
After several months of public consultations, the Yukon Legislature’s select committee on hydraulic fracturing (fracking), released itsfinal report last Monday, January 19 – without a consensus. Recommendations include further research and additional collection of data. It remains unclear whether fracking could be done safely and whether the support of Yukoners is needed (CBC). The fracking committee further underlines the difference between the requirement of support and of consent of First Nations (YN). While the opponents of fracking claim that the report shows Yukoners’ opposition (CBC), the industry wants to prove fracking safe (CBC).


Norway moves ice edge north and expands oil drilling territory
Last Tuesday, January 20, Norway’s Minister of Petroleum and Energy, Tord Lien, announced the country’s 23rd License Round, awarding 54 blocks in mature areas to 43 firms, including Statoil, Lundin Petroleum, and Total. The blocks lie in an area that was considered beyond the ice edge until recently, which would pose safety threats. However, it is unclear whether the Norwegian government will succeed in winning the parliamentary approval (Reuters,Reuters). The recent new definition of the ice edge by the Norwegian Polar Institute, on which the government plan is based, is criticized by several opposition parties, as well as scientists (NRK andNRK, both in Norwegian). Another issue is the blocks located in formerly disputed waters with Russia or immediately along the borderline (EOTA). National Geographic’s article focuses on the reasons for the expansion of oil drilling territory (NG).

Arctic general

Russia

Russia’s former prime minister suggests pause in Arctic oil & gas projects (EOTA).


US
FNG defending turf in contract (Fairbanks Natural Gas) (PN).
Greenland
Canada
Nordics



SCIENCE, ENVIRONMENT AND WILDLIFE

Seismic testing in Clyde River
The “battle” between proponents and opponents of offshore seismic testing in the area gained momentum since the Canadian Energy Board approved the seismic testing plan in the waters near the community of Clyde River on Baffin Island.
Climate, weather, cryology
Flora and fauna, ecology
Expeditions & research blogs
Environmental management
Research news
Call for abstracts – the Arctic Yearbook. Deadline: 1 March 2015 (AJ).
Miscellaneous

MILITARY / SEARCH & RESCUE

United States
Europe
Canada
Russia

MINING
Estimates do not bode well for Northern mineral development
According to revised estimates released Wednesday by Natural Resources Canada, the amount of money companies spent exploring and developing mineral properties in the North dropped by a combined 22 per cent in 2014 (CBC). The Northwest Territories is the only area to have seen an increase in spending in mineral exploration, however, amounts are still lower than in Yukon and Nunavut, which both saw declines, and are lower still than in the years before the financial crisis (CBC). Nunavut in particular saw a 43% decrease in exploration expenses from 2013 to 2014, with the majority of investments targeting precious metals (NN).

Dominion Diamond Corporation asks for expedited review timeline

Dominion Diamond is asking the Mackenzie Valley Environmental Impact Review Board to accelerate its timeline for assessing the planned expansion of the Ekati diamond mine, arguing that the difference in timing will allow construction to commence early enough to prevent the layoff of employees and allow the mine to continue operations seamlessly without jeopardizing the economic viability of the project (CBC).

First Nation dissatisfied with level of inclusion in mining negotiations

The Deninu Kue First Nation wrote a letter to Minister of Aboriginal Affairs and Northern Development Bernard Valcourt this week expressing their feeling of unequal treatment and inclusion in negotiating Impact Benefit agreements for two proposed projects in their traditional territory (CBC).

XS Platinum, a mining company accused of polluting salmon streams in Western Alaska, failed to show up for their initial court hearing this week and have been ordered to explain their absence or be held in contempt, possibly facing fines and additional penalties (EOTA; see also Alaska Public Media).
A group of Inuit employees at Agnico Eagle’s Meadowbank mine near Baker Lake, Nunavut have claimed they are being discriminated against, particularly arguing that language differences and inadequate communication has, at times, placed them in unsafe situations at work (CBC).
Finland’s Talvivaara mining company is seeking another state bailout to sustain operations and ensure regulatory compliance while new ownership and investment is sought out  (EOTA).
As part of a show of goodwill and business cooperation to the mining industry, Yukon First Nations are hosting a reception at the annual British Columbia Mineral Exploration Roundup, in light of a series of court battles between the industry and First Nations groups (CBC).
FISHERIES, SHIPPING AND OTHER BUSINESS NEWS
Fisheries
Shipping
Aviation
Other business and economic news
Canada
Alaska

HEALTH, YOUTH, SOCIETY AND CULTURE
Warmer weather impacting an iconic Northern tradition - the Iditarod

Given the low snow levels currently in Alaska, the Iditarod Trail Committee is seriously considering moving the start of the trail north to Fairbanks if conditions do not improve (EOTA). The 1,000 mile race, traditionally beginning in Willow, AK, is slated to begin March 7th, with the ceremonial start in Anchorage (Alaska Public Media). Last year’s tricky terrain on the traditional route is also a contributing factor being weighed in the final course decision, which will be made by February 15th (Reuters). The Iditarod is not the only event potentially impacted by warmer temperatures and lack of snow, with other outdoor activities, such as the Yukon Ultra marathon, the Yukon Quest, and the Yukon Sourdough Festival, being reconsidered or adjusted for subpar conditions (AD).

Trial of convicted child sex-offender concludes in Nunavut

With charges against him dating back to 1995, former priest Eric Dejaeger, concluded his final day of sentencing hearings on charges of child sexual abuse this week (CBC). He stands convicted on 32 counts, primarily of sex crimes committed against Inuit children in Igloolik between 1976 and 1982 (NN). Many of his victims, now adults, were present for his trial and gave chilling and emotional testimony against him, with feelings ranging from pity to anger and stories reflecting both emotional and physical scars (NN). The Crown prosecutor called for the imposition of a 25 year jail sentence, and Justice Kilpatrick is expected to issue a written decision by mid-February (CTV News; Alaska Highway News).

Les débats sur l'éducation en français au Canada continuent

Northern Canada’s French-language schools have drawn a variety of criticism as of late. Nunavut’s only French-language school has come under fire from parents who are concerned over the lack of communication and constant changes in staffing and curriculum, resulting in francophone students leaving the school (NN). A case was brought before the Supreme Court of Canada this week by members of francophone communities across Canada, who argue that the Yukon government should take a more lenient interpretation of the law giving minority language speakers the right to an education in their native language, thereby allowing more French-speaking children access to French education and admission to be determined by the French school board (CBC). The Yukon government has interpreted the law more narrowly, and the case has become a really fascinating debate within Canada over minority rights and division of power between the federal and territorial governments (CBC). Similarly, a trial in Northwest Territories asking for expanded French-language schools and admissions, has added to the discussion, and the Yukon case is likely to pave the way should the francophones succeed (CBC).
Health
Proposed legislation in Northwest Territories intended to regulate and properly investigate health professionals has drawn criticism for its potential to violate people’s privacy, as the law would mandate access to confidential health records in investigations (CBC).
A new research study, slated for publication in a prestigious journal in February, found that high marijuana use is linked to low body weight in Nunavik. Researchers claim this may lead to insights into the relationship between weight and diabetes as well as the impact of cannabis on people (NN).

Youth

Society
Holly Jarrett, the cousin of Loretta Saunders, an Aboriginal woman who was murdered last February in New Brunswick, continues to fight for social justice and raise awareness of the marginalization, abuse and bias Aboriginal women in the North face regularly. Her story is worth reading (NN).
A Juneau ski program teaches people with disabilities to ski and snowboard, helping them learn new skills, become more independent, and socialize regularly (Alaska Public Media).

Culture
SOL, a documentary film investigating the death of Solomon Uyarasuk, who was found in a jail cell in Nunavut, deals with the far too common issue of suicide in the Arctic, and will be screened for the first time in Nunavut on January 28th (The Arctic Journal; see also NN& CBC).
As Canada prepares to hand over the Arctic Council chairmanship to the U.S. this spring, Lenore Grenoble, a linguistics professor at the University of Chicago, plans on attending an Arctic language symposium this spring in Ottawa to develop realistic goals and a roadmap for continued AC focus on northern language development (NN).
“Fortitude,” a thriller television series based in the Arctic set to air on January 29th on British television channel, Sky, promises to not just use the Arctic as a backdrop, but to feature it and make it an integral part of the story (The Arctic Journal). For details on the storyline, dynamo cast and inspiration behind the series’ creation, take a look at this article and accompanying trailers, and check out the season premier (Examiner).
Sume: The sound of a success (The Arctic Journal).
INFRASTRUCTURE
Canada
United States

Abbreviation Key
Aboriginal Peoples Television Network (APTN)
Aftenbladet (AB)
Alaska Business Monthly (ABM)
Alaska Dispatch (AD)
Alaska Journal of Commerce (AJOC)
Alaska Native News (ANN)
Alaska Public Media (APM)
Anchorage Daily News (ADN)
Arctic Info (Russian) (AIR)
Arctic Institute (TAI)
Barents Nova (BN)
Barents Observer (BO)
Bristol Bay Times (BBT)
BusinessWeek (BW)
Canadian Mining Journal (CMJ)
Christian Science Monitor (CSM)
Eye on the Arctic (EOTA)
Fairbanks Daily News-Miner (FNM)
Financial Times (FT)
Globe and Mail (G&M)
Government of Canada (GOC)
Government of the Northwest Territories (GNWT)
Huffington Post (HP)
Indian Country Today Media Network (ICTMN)
Johnson’s Russia List (JRL)
Kalaallit Nunaata Radioa (KNR)
Lapin Kansa (LK)
Maritime Executive (MarEx)
Moscow Times (MT)
National Geographic (NG)
Natural Gas Europe (NGE)
Naval Today (NT)
New York Times (NYT)
Northern Journal (NJ)
Northern News Service Online (NNSO)
Northern Public Affairs (NPA)
Norwegian Polar Institute (NPI)
Nunatsiaq News (NN)
Oil & Gas Journal (OGJ)
Ottawa Citizen (OC)
Petroleum News (PN)
RIA Novosti (RIAN)
Russia Beyond the Headlines (RBTH)
Russia Today (RT)
Voice of Russia (VOR)
Wall Street Journal (WSJ)
Washington Post (WP)
Whitehorse Star (WS)
Winnipeg Free Press (WFP)
Yukon News (YN)
































The Future of Arctic Research: Multi-, Inter- and Transdisciplinary Approaches

$
0
0


The Future of Arctic Research: Multi-, Inter- and Transdisciplinary Approaches
Kathrin Keil, February 2, 2014


This article is based on a presentation the author gave at the 2nd Arctic in Rapid Transition (ART) Science Workshop, “Integrating spatial and temporal scales in the changing Arctic System: towards future research priorities” (ISTAS), 21-24 October 2014 at the European Institute for Marine Studies (IUEM) Plouzané, France.

Next to all Arctic researchers these days are confronted with the notion that multi-, inter- and transdisciplinary research approaches are inevitable for the future progress of Arctic research. At the latest when working on funding applications, hardly any of us can avoid addressing these approaches in order to secure funding for Arctic projects. More and more funding agencies put these approaches down as necessary requirements for the Arctic research they want to fund. As one example, the recent Belmont Call for Proposals on Arctic Observing and Research for Sustainability explicitly stated in its call that

“All proposals must integrate across the natural sciences and social sciences and should include an interdisciplinary, multinational approach, demonstrate strong relevance for user needs, and examine a variety of coupled interactions and feedbacks among relevant systems.”

So there was a clear “must” for inter- and transdisciplinary research in this call, and this is just one out of many examples. However, it seems that often these approaches remain as mere buzzwords or “tags” for projects, although no one disputes the usefulness of inter- and transdisciplinary work. One reason for this is the lacking debate about the exact meaning of these terms, their virtues but also vices for the progress of research generally and for the Arctic specifically.

Let’s start with the terms and their meanings. This article does not claim to give objective definitions of these terms but rather gives one possible understanding and ways of working with them. The classical variant is of course disciplinary research, where separate disciplines work in separate departments and have research projects on their own, producing cutting each research work in their respective field. Usually, inter- and multidisciplinary are used interchangeable although one could argue that interdisciplinarity goes a step further in also implying that disciplines need to truly integrate their research work and outcomes. In contrast, multidisciplinarity could mean that different disciplines are represented in a common project or department but they work relatively independently from one another and not a lot of integration and actual exchange and cooperation between the disciplines takes place. Often, inter- and multidisciplinarity are understood as being part of transdisciplinarity, which goes even beyond the research realm to include societal and other stakeholders in the research work (figure 1).

Figure 1: Different “Disciplinarities”
kathrin2.png© Kathrin Keil

In more detail, disciplinary research is research within academia involving one discipline. Inter- or multidisciplinary research is also research within academia but involving more than one discipline, either in a rather weak fashion where the disciplines are organised more in silos or separate working groups in a common project or in a more integrated way. Transdisciplinary research goes beyond academia and involves stakeholders from policy, civil society and other non-academic groups (figure 2). Since this process usually also involves more than one discipline, interdisciplinarity is often assumed as part of transdisciplinarity.

Figure 2: Disciplinary, interdisciplinary and transdisciplinary research
kathrin1.png
© Kathrin Keil

But why and when doing transdisciplinary research? In brief, transdisciplinary research is appropriate when your research is not or not only about science delivering solutions mono-directionally (i.e. only for scientific purposes), but when it is (also) about co-development where science is only one piece of the puzzle, and where the aim is to co-develop a range of options that support societal transformation pathways. These latter options are usually intended in sustainability research and thus transdisciplinarity is a useful approach here.

And how can transdisciplinary research work? There are surely many ways to operationalize transdisciplinary research. As one example, the Institute for Advanced Sustainability Studies (IASS) puts at the core of its transdisciplinary approach the engagement of societal stakeholders in all phases of the research process, where it appears sensible and possible to do so. These phases range from topic identification and process design to generation of solution-oriented knowledge to discussion with societal stakeholders. Especially this last step is intended to provide the crucial link between research work and a transformative effect on society and also to new impulses for research.

But let’s get back to interdisciplinarity. I have come to think of interdisciplinary work not only in its differentiation to multidisciplinary work, but also in a “weak” and a “strong” version. For example, the time at my graduate school – which was of course branded as being “interdisciplinary” – was an experience of rather weak interdisciplinarity. While the students and academic personnel of the graduate school were from various disciplines including political science, sociology, communication studies and the school was generally open to students also from backgrounds in law, economics and history, we all stayed more or less comfortably within the borders of social science. This interdisciplinary work within social (or for that matter natural science) borders, I would call weak interdisciplinarity. In contrast, an institute like the IASS designs projects including political scientists, human geographers, lawyers, meteorologists, atmospheric scientists and chemists (like the SMART project). This is what I would call strong interdisciplinarity, i.e. joint research across natural and social science disciplines, or humanities, engineering etc., wherever one prefers to draw the line between the disciplines.

The terms “weak” and “strong” are by no means intended to imply that the latter is better than the former. Communication and collaboration within the social and within natural sciences is also hard work and not easy since every discipline has its own language, underlying assumptions, concepts, traditions etc. Both approaches can make sense (or no sense) depending on the specific research and questions addressed.

This brings us to the necessity to discuss some problems, open questions and lessons learned from using inter- and transdisciplinary approaches in our research work. A general big issue about inter- and transdisciplinarity is that everyone agrees it is necessary to do, adopt and implement but little more information, debate, discussion, ideas, examples of how to actually do it is provided. We are therefore in dire need of more examples of inter- and transdisciplinary work, outlining the successful and the less successful or even failed attempts of such research approaches to be able to learn from them. We need to ask and answer:

  • For which questions is inter- and transdisciplinary work sensible, relevant and possible?
  • For which are such approaches not recommended?
  • How to share the burden between disciplines in such approaches?
  • How to avoid silo knowledge or how to achieve true integration of different disciplines and with societal knowledge and concerns?
  • How to inform each other about assumptions, ideas, models, approaches, concepts etc.? How to convey the general thinking behind one’s work, the “101” of each subject or how it generally works?
  • What is the context-dependent “right” relationship between disciplinary, interdisciplinary and transdisciplinary work?

Against this background, the following provides some lessons learned from my personal experience in working in an inter- and transdisciplinary research environment. First of all, interdisciplinary research cannot and should not replace good disciplinary work. In some research projects, and also there often only in parts, inter- and transdisciplinary work is warranted, sensible, necessary and feasible. But where it is not conducive to the intended research outcome and/or where it is just not feasible, it will not help to force inter- and transdisciplinary work into the project.

Second, it is hard and a lot of work to interact with researchers from other disciplines and to engage non-academics truly and thoroughly in a research project. Since many funding organisations nowadays ask for inter- and transdisciplinary work - and rightly so since many research areas demand such approaches to make steps forward - also the research environment and structures researchers work in have to adapt accordingly, ranging from human to time to financial resources. This might also require a bit of a change in focus of many research calls, away from the necessity to always provide new data, to providing resources also for working with existing data but applying it with the help of new approaches.

Third, although many of us would say “sure, we need interdisciplinary research”, my sense is that pre-existing images of “the other science” (in the sense of natural vs. social science) are still very strong, on all sides. Since most of us were trained in disciplinary subjects, it might be hard to understand the differences between, for example, social sciences and humanities, the relationship and difference between social science and politics, the basics of natural science methods such as modelling, the uncertainties and limitations of models etc.

After all these words of warning and perils, this article should nevertheless finish on a positive note. Inter- and transdisciplinary work is such a great opportunity for us as researchers to broaden our horizon and to tackle research questions, challenges and problems that we possibly would not have even thought about within our own disciplinary boundaries. It is not only hard work as outlined, it is also fun and fulfilment for us as researchers. And not least, it is also our responsibility as credible researchers to go down that path.

Given the manifold developments at play in the changing Arctic region, we also need manifold disciplines to tackle the challenges on the way towards sustainable Arctic futures. For example, natural sciences observe and model the changing nature of the Arctic sea ice, environment and atmosphere. Social sciences like law, economics and political science can draw on this knowledge to provide input as to the likely development of, for example, the pace and extent of Arctic resource exploration and exploitation. This data can inform natural science models as to the expected amount of pollutants and black carbon from Arctic sources and thus how we can expect Arctic air pollution to develop, the role of black carbon for the future development of Arctic sea ice, and the possibility of long-range transport of pollutants between Arctic and non-Arctic regions. It further provides data as to the possible and likely effects on Arctic societies and cultures.

Multidisciplinary research work is also indispensable to disclose the ever-tightening connections between Arctic and non-Arctic actors, processes, systems and stake- and rights-holders. The involvement of more and more non-Arctic actors in Arctic governance on the one hand provides insights in the possible investments and social development of the region. On the other hand, it discloses the delicate relationship between opportunities and responsibilities that non-Arctic actors have in relation to Arctic changes.

But as said, while multidisciplinary research is indeed indispensable to achieve advances in Arctic research, this should not be understood as replacing disciplinary research. State-of-the-art research from all disciplines is of course still invaluable and very often forms the very basis for fruitful multidisciplinary research or synergies between separate disciplines.





















High North Dialogue Podcast – Interview with Kristin Halvorsen

$
0
0



High North Dialogue Podcast – Interview with Kristin Halvorsen
Andreas Raspotnik, February 3, 2014

Screen Shot 2014-11-10 at 4.06.30 PM.png



In our 2nd podcast for the High North Dialogue 2015 we talked with Kristin Halvorsen, Director of CICERO, Center for International Climate and Environmental Research in Oslo. Kristin Halvorsen was leader of the Socialist Left Party in Norway from 1997 to 2012 and served as Minister of Finance and Minister of Education from 2005 to 2009, and 2009 to 2013, respectively.
During our conversation Kristin delivered one essential and undeniable message: the global climate is changing and its negative effects on the Arctic region increase alarmingly. Consequently, she hopes that future discussions on matters of Arctic security will first and foremost concern the climate aspect of security. One of the concepts that are often referred to with regard to the future of the Arctic is sustainable development. Kristin explicitly emphasised that in order to not end up with an empty concept of sustainable development, it is necessary to actually live up its very meaning. In that regard, she stressed current discussions in Norway on the most recent decision by the Norwegian government to open the south-eastern Barents Sea to oil and gas explorations. According to Kristin, the main task of climate research is the contribution of knowledge to that particular debate. Only interdisciplinary research can tackle the comprehensive problems of climate change and consequently provide scientific support for decision- and policymakers. She further highlighted the positive bilateral relationship between Norway and Russia in the Arctic, which is currently not affected by the Ukrainian unrest and the related problematic relationship between the EU and Russia.

Transcript
Hello and welcome to this 2nd podcast for the High North Dialogue 2015, a collaboration of the University of Nordland, the University’s High North Centre for Business and Governance, and The Arctic Institute. We are speaking with attendees and speakers about their work, the High North Dialogue and the conference’s themes of security and business in the Arctic. Thanks for joining us. I am Andreas Raspotnik.
Today we are talking with Kristin Halvorsen, Director of CICERO, Center for International Climate and Environmental Research in Oslo. Kristin Halvorsen was leader of the Socialist Left Party in Norway from 1997 to 2012 and served as Minister of Finance and Minister of Education from 2005 to 2009, and 2009 to 2013, respectively.
Andreas Raspotnik: Dear Kristin, thanks for joining us today. Let me start with our first question. The theme of HND 2015 is “The Arctic in a Global Perspective - Arctic Business & Security”. Being the Director of a leading research institute on climate change and climate policy, what is your first association when you think of security in and security for the Arctic?
Kristin Halvorsen: Hallo and thank you for inviting me. I just like to explain to you what CICERO is working on because we are an interdisciplinary research institute. We have natural scientists and social scientists and we work on research on climate issues from different angles. The reason why I am at the conference and my role there is that I am going to highlight the consequences of climate change in the Arctic, which is closely connected both to business and to security. We have a lot of information about this area. It is very vulnerable and theIPCC synthesis report tells us that since 1875 the Arctic has warmed at a rate of 1.36 degrees Celsius per century and that is approximately twice as fast as the global average.[i] All the climate scenarios in the IPCC report shows that there will be dramatic reductions in the Arctic sea ice, the same applies when it comes to near-surface permafrost and the global glacial volume is also projected to significantly decrease. There will be similar increases in the global mean sea level by 2100, anything in between 0.25 and 0.8m[ii] and finally the Arctic as a region will continue to warm more rapidly than the global mean. And that means of course that the climate change in the Arctic is far more dramatic than anywhere else in the world and closely connected to security issues and of course it affects all sectors.
Andreas Raspotnik: A term, closely related to Climate security is at least in my understanding sustainable development. In 1987 the Brundtland Report “Our Common Future” prominently defined the term “sustainable development” as “development that meets the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs”. Today, sustainable development has become a buzzword in the Arctic context that contains different meanings when used by different sectors and actors. How would you perceive and scrutinise the nexus of “sustainable development” and the well-known challenges and opportunities of a future Arctic? Has the term become somewhat of an empty concept used only to legitimise certain actions?
Kristin Halvorsen: Well, it’s nothing wrong with the concept but of course we have to live up to it. Otherwise it will become an empty phrase. Of course the change we can see now in the Arctic region is irreversible and not living up to the content of sustainable development. That means that we have to be extremely careful about all kind of business and activity in the region. We need to know more about how different threats or different elements impact the situation in the Arctic. We have to look closely into because there is a lot of pressure – it is kind of a cocktail. Currently it is not what was meant by sustainable development. Maybe I should also mention to you that is a topical issue in Norway right now. The government has decided to open blocks to oil and gas exploration further north in the Barents Sea and the discussion in the Norwegian media and the Parliament is of course if that is according to sustainable development. So, I think we have to be very careful. The phrase “sustainable development” is not empty but we really have to live up to it.
Andreas Raspotnik: Norway’s 23rd licensing round is actually part of my 3rd question. As a long term policy- and decision maker in Norway and now interested observer of the Norwegian political scene, how would you personally see the Norwegian Arctic future, especially related to that topical licensing round and the related opening of the south-eastern Barents Sea?
Kristin Halvorsen: Well, we know from the latest IPCC report that there is a carbon budget and that we have used more than half of it. The situation in the Barents Sea and further north is very vulnerable, so I think that all climate researchers would agree that this is an area that we should not explore, both because of global heating and green house gas emissions and because this part of the world is so vulnerable. But I think there is a lot more attention now connected to the Arctic than it was just 10, 20 years ago. It was important for the government, which I was a member of in 2005 to highlight the situation and pay attention to the development in the north and that has been followed up by the new conservative government. But I think that when it comes to explore oil and gas and to other activities in this region the government should be confronted by the latest IPCC report; that is a part of the political debate and we climate researchers should contribute with knowledge to that debate.[iii]
Andreas Raspotnik: Staying in the Barents Sea region, how do you see the current relationship with Norway and its Arctic neighbour, the Russian Federation, especially if you consider this relationship in terms of businesses, environmental concerns and security?
Kristin Halvorsen: The collaboration between Russia and Norway in the north connected to our common border has increased tremendously. Just some few years back it was really hard for Russians to come to Norway and the other way around. And I think that we are collaborating well in the Arctic Council and about environmental questions too. It is not that much affected by the conflict between Russia and NATO, as we could fear because it is really very important that we have an open dialogue with the Russians in the Arctic.
Andreas Raspotnik: So is it fair to say that Norway and Russia follow a very pragmatic and cooperative Arctic approach?
Kristin Halvorsen: That is my experience so far. We hope that we will continue because we have a lot of common issues that we have to solve. We have a lot of knowledge that is very important to be open both to Russia, to Norway and all the other members of the Arctic Council.
Andreas Raspotnik: During the last years “big data” has become a key term in our digital understanding of data collection and data management. Companies such as Facebook or Google have opened necessary server farms in Sweden and Finland in order to save energy based on the region’s colder climate. But also in Iceland businesses are putting much effort into the development of so-called “green data centres”. According to your opinion, could the Arctic or the broader north in general serve as a blueprint for related global considerations?
Kristin Halvorsen: Well, I think it is interesting. As you know we have theSvalbard International Seed Vault. That is not for business purposes that is more like to store and preserve genetic materials for humanity but it is interesting because it is placed on Svalbard because of the climate. But I think that we have to be very careful when it comes to Svalbard and the most northern part of the Arctic region. It is another discussion when we discuss the north of Sweden, Finland or Iceland. But we have to be careful in this area because all kinds of activities have a footprint and either when it comes to global emission or when it comes to other kinds of activities. Because this part of the world is so vulnerable I don’t think that this is the one solution for business activity in the north; it can be interesting if we do it wisely and consider all consequences.
Andreas Raspotnik: Coming to our last two questions: Can you shortly describe CICERO’s current Arctic engagement and your related plans for the future?
Kristin Halvorsen: We have several applications connected to the situation in the Arctic because we need more knowledge about this very vulnerable region. But we have projects going on now connected to for instances to black carbon in Arctic snow, short-lived climate forces what is really happening connected to shipping and also connected to adapting to the climate changes in the Arctic. So we are collaborating closely with other research institutes to get more knowledge about the situation in the Arctic and we try to connect our different disciplines to look into the challenges because we know if we work interdisciplinary we can see the climate changes from different angles and come up with knowledge that is relevant to those who are making decisions.
Andreas Raspotnik: And final question now, what would you hope to be the main outcome of this year’s High North Dialogue?
Kristin Halvorsen: I hope that when we highlight security in the Arctic the discussion will be about the climate situation because that is really the closest connected to the security situation in the years to come. It is very dramatic what is going on in the Arctic. It is closely connected to the global climate development but you can double the global warming in the Arctic from what is the mean global increased temperature and that makes it a very special situation. So climate issues and security is very closely connected in the Arctic.
Andreas Raspotnik: Well, Kristin. Thank you very much for taking the time to share your perspectives on the Arctic with us. We look very much forward to seeing you at the coming High North Dialogue conference in Bodø.
Kristin Halvorsen: Thank you very much, see you soon.
Andreas Raspotnik: Thanks for joining us for this podcast. Follow along with the series on iTunes or via our websites highnorthdialogue.no and thearcticinstitute.org. In our 3rd podcast we will talk with Alexander Sergunin, Professor at St. Petersburg State University.
The music you’ve heard at the beginning and at the end comes from Hebber Zepherin and can be found at ccmixture.org.



[i] Note by Andreas Raspotnik: the numbers can be found inClimate Change 2013: The Physical Science Basis, p. 398, an IPCC’s Working Group I report.
[ii] “m” was added by Andreas Raspotnik
[iii] Note by Andreas Raspotnik: Unfortunately and due to some problems with the recording program the last sentence of Kristin Halvorsen’s statement was not sufficiently recorded. Andreas Raspotnik inserted the word “should” in this transcript for matters of better readability.






















Arctic News: The Arctic This Week February 4

$
0
0


The Arctic This Week January 26 - February 1, 2015



9096196132_65b315b379_o.jpg
Photo: Thomas Leth-Olsen


Welcome and thanks for joining us this week! We hope that you find TATW interesting and entertaining to read. If you’re not a subscriber yet, you can sign up here. As always, all editorial choices, opinions and any mistakes are the authors’ own. Anything that we missed? Please feel free to share material with us if you think it deserves inclusion in TATW.

THIS WEEK’S TOP STORIES

Drilling Restrictions in ANWR, Beaufort, and Chukchi Seas

Proponents of Alaskan oil and gas have suffered a double setback as the Obama administration has moved to limit exploration and drilling in Alaska’s Arctic National Wildlife Refuge, as well as ban drilling in parts of the Beaufort Chukchi Seas (NYTimes,AD,AJ). Reactions have been, as expected, varied, hyperbolic, and intensely emotional: Rep. Don Young called Obama a “wacko” and Sen. Murkowski has accused him of acting via “executive fiat” (AD); the Heritage Foundation’s Stephen Moore accuses Obama of hiding a “radical climate-change agenda” behind what Moore considers more tolerable concerns about protecting wildlife and wilderness areas, much to the glee of ISIS and Vladimir Putin (Daily Signal); and, Alaska Governor Bill Walker described himself as “very frustrated” with the move (APM). Fairbanks Republican Click Bishop mustered one of the more creative responses: drawing inspiration from Ted Cruz’s infamous Green Eggs and Ham filibuster, Bishop read a Dr. Suess-inspired speech on the floor of the legislature (APM). Conversely, “conservationists in Alaska and outside the state praised Obama, saying that while his recommendation currently has no practical change on refuge management, the action replaces Reagan-era policy and will send an enduring signal of the administration’s commitment to protecting the wilderness” (AD).

Volcanoes galore
This week has been heavy on volcano news. Earlier last week, an Alaska Airlines flight to Nome had to skip its destination because of debris from the Russian volcano Shiveluch on the Kamchatka Peninsula, which erupted again last Monday (AS). In Alaska, it has been one year since the Shishaldin Volcano “woke up… and didn’t go back to sleep” (APM). Meanwhile, Augustine Volcano in Cook Inlet has a tendency to become top-heavy, causing occasional rock slides into the ocean. Zebulon Maharrey of USGS has discovered evidence for a tsunami caused by Volcano Augustine around the time of the construction of the Egyptian pyramids (APM). In Iceland, the sulphur dioxide emitted since the eruption at the lava field Holuhraun has been found to be harmful with 50 - 60 thousand tons of the gas being released every day (mbl).

Federal government considering changes to Nutrition North program

The Canadian federal government has posted a tender seeking out new proposals for how to operate the Nutrition North food subsidy program. The program replaced the previous Food Mail program in 2011 as a means of lowering food prices in northern communities. However, a November audit found that the government has failed to provide proper oversight as to whether the subsidies are actually lowering prices for customers (CBC). Along these lines, activists called for a boycott of North West Company stores on January 31 to protest high food prices (CBC). While volunteers and donors in southern Canada have sent large amounts of groceries north in response to Nunavut’s current food crisis, some Nunavut activists are saying the donations are only a temporary fix that’s masking bigger problems (CBC, NN).

Yukon Zinc shuts down Wolverine mine, faces financial difficulties

Yukon Zinc will shut down the Wolverine mine for at least two to three months, citing a decline in metal prices. The announcement came as members of Yukon’s First Nations met with mining executives in Vancouver regarding legislation concerning mining activities on native lands in Yukon, British Columbia, and the Northwest Territories (YN, with a more detailed perspective on the event from CBC). It was revealed later in the week that financial problems have also put Yukon Zinc behind on a nearly $3 million payment in overdue security deposit payments to the Yukon government meant to fund the mine’s eventual closure and environmental reclamation. This has put the company out of compliance with its mining license, which may create legal issues (YN). The shutdown was not a shock to industry insiders, however, given global economic conditions (CBC).

UPCOMING CONFERENCE
The annual High North Dialogue Conference will take March 17-19, 2015 in Bodø Norway. To find out more click here.

Screen Shot 2015-01-21 at 2.53.54 PM.png




THE POLITICAL SCENE

United States
Europe
Russia
Canada


ENERGY

Arctic general
Call for Presentations - 2015 Arctic Energy Summit, September 28-30, Alaska. Abstracts due by February 27 (Alaska Business).
Russia
US
Canada
Nordics
SCIENCE, ENVIRONMENT AND WILDLIFE

Weather and climate
Flora and fauna
Environmental management
Research and university news                       
Miscellaneous

MILITARY / SEARCH & RESCUE

SOCOM Commander Sees Arctic as Priority

On the eve of a trip to Norway, General Joseph Votel, head of U.S. Special Operations Command, has highlighted tensions in the Arctic as a potential threat, with a focus on Russia’s increasing military buildup in the area (National Defense Magazine).
United States
Russia
Europe
Canada

MINING
Weak ruble compensates falling nickel price

Russian conglomerate Norilsk-Nickel expects strong returns despite the decline of global nickel prices. This has been offset by the weak ruble and the company’s avoidance of Western sanctions that have plagued many other Russian companies (BO).

Talvivaara may seek more state aid

Troubled Finnish mining company Talvivaara may need more state aid in addition to a 60 million euro bailout granted last November (BO). The company has received a brief reprieve, however, as a Finnish court gave it until mid-March to submit a corporate restructuring plan (EOTA).

The future of Greenland’s mining industry: opinions

Two editorials worth a read this week address resource issues in Greenland: one discusses the impact of nationalizing the NunaMinerals mining company on investors (Arctic Journal), while the other assesses a report on a potential resource rush one year after its publication (Arctic Journal). Another article, in Danish, shows NunaMinerals’ chairman casting doubt on the company’s survival (KNR).

Store Norke requests crisis loan from the Norwegian government

The financially-beleaguered Svalbard coal mining company Store Norske has requested a 450 million NOK ($58 million USD) crisis loan from the Norwegian government to avoid bankruptcy. Following the company’s loan request, the Norwegian government announced it is commissioning a whitepaper on Svalbard that will focus on development issues, including the future of the coal mining industry in the Arctic archipelago and the industries effect on the town of Longyearbyen (BO).

Lower oil prices have mixed impact on Alaska’s mining sector

The recent drop in oil prices has had both positive and negative effects on Alaska’s mining industry. While energy and transportation costs have decreased, the state’s budget shortfall has put several development projects on hold that would benefit the mining sector, including the planned 200-mile long Ambler Road project that would link the Ambler Mining District with global markets (PN).

The Canadian federal government accepted the Nunavut Impact Review Board’s recommendation to approve Agnico Eagle Mines’ Meliadine gold project in the Kivalliq region, marking a big step forward for the project that is expected to produce 2.8 million ounces of gold (NN).
Ucore Rare Metals Inc. announced promising new findings from exploratory drillings conducted at its Bokan-Dotson Ridge rare earth element project on Prince of Wales Island, Alaska that could lead to a deeper expansion of the existing site (PN).
The project manager for the Kaunisvaara mine in Swedish Lapland has claimed that there are parties interested in buying the mine. The mine shuttered this past December following the bankruptcy of owner Northland Resources (BO).
Nordea’s decision to divest itself of coal mine holdings has raised questions about the financial future of investments in the coal industry (EOTA).   
FISHERIES, SHIPPING AND OTHER BUSINESS NEWS

Selling marijuana in Alaska
Since the legalization of marijuana in Alaska, there has been much discussion about how to distribute and profit from it. The “Alaska Cannabis Club” is planning to open a medical marijuana dispensary in Anchorage on February 24, the day that recreational marijuana becomes legal. Since the sale of marijuana will remain illegal, patients will make donations in return (AD).

Fisheries
Shipping
Aviation
Other business and economic news
Alaska and Canada
Greenland
Russia
Time to tighten the belt (Murmansk Oblast) (BO).
Finland
Nordics

HEALTH, EDUCATION, SOCIETY AND CULTURE
Alaska, cities deal with school funding and workload issues

The chairman of the Anchorage School District has called for the sparing of teachers when facing budget cuts in the next fiscal year, and has even proposed funding for 24 new teaching positions (AD). Still, some Anchorage teachers have protested claimed inequities in pay and workload between elective and core subject teachers (APM). In order to address budget and retention issues that have resulted in reliance on out-of-state teachers, the University of Alaska is planning an initiative to recruit more homegrown teachers from within the state (AD).  

Highly anticipated TV crime thriller set in the Arctic debuts to positive reviews

“Fortitude”, a crime thriller set in the Arctic, premiered on the British television network Sky on January 29th to positive reviews (ABC). The story is set in a fictional town in Svalbard, and if the show is successful, the Norwegian Arctic archipelago is expected to see a bump in tourism dollars (Daily Mail). Prompted by the premier of the show, the The Independent newspaper took a look at the Arctic as an increasingly-frequent setting in arts and entertainment (The Independent). Finally, as part of the marketing for the show, a life-sized animatronic polar bear was recently unleashed on the London Underground, much to the shock of commuters and the delight of social media (London Evening Standard, Daily Record).

Final preparations underway for 2015 Yukon Quest dog race

The Yukon Quest, Alaska’s lesser-known long distance dog race after the Iditarod, is scheduled to begin on February 7th in Fairbanks, Alaska. Mushers have been making their final preparations this week ahead of the 1,000-mile race, which concludes in Whitehorse, Canada (APM). This year will mark a first in the race’s 31-year history, as musher Brent Sass will be the first competitor to wear a helmet a year after he suffered a concussion during the same race (CBC).

Health

Youth
A group of parents at Nunavut’s only francophone school have called for leadership changes in the territory’s francophone education board, citing a lack of transparency regarding recent staffing issues  (NN; see also CBC).
A youth perspective on the challenges facing the North (Centre for International Governance Innovation).

Society
A revived form of Norse paganism is making a comeback of sorts in Iceland, where the construction of a new temple devoted to the Norse gods was recently announced (G&M).
Ahead of the Super Bowl, Alaska Dispatch News profiled George Nix, a Haida Indian who became the first Alaskan to play in the NFL in 1926 (AD; see also AD).
The upcoming legalization of recreational marijuana use in Alaska is expected to force the retirement of 10 dogs from the Alaska State Troopers’ K-9 unit. They will be replaced by a new corps of dogs who will instead only be trained to detect drugs that still remain illegal (AD).
Arctic 30: Tales from a Russian prison (Responding to Climate Change).

Culture
Two northern recording artists - one from Nunavut and one from NWT - have each been nominated for the Aboriginal Album of the Year at the 2015 Juno Awards (CBC).
The documentary film festival DocPoint 2015 kicked off this week in Helsinki, featuring over 160 films, several of which focus on Finland and Russia  (Yle).
The Whatcom Museum in Bellingham, WA will host an Arctic-focused art exhibition until late April entitled, “Vanishing Ice: Alpine and Polar Landscapes in Art, 1775-2012” (McMichael).
The Daily Mail published an interesting travel review of Svalbard (Daily Mail). Perhaps the long-time allure of the Arctic would inspire a trip to such a place (The Independent).
INFRASTRUCTURE
United States
Canada

Abbreviation Key
Aboriginal Peoples Television Network (APTN)
Aftenbladet (AB)
Alaska Business Monthly (ABM)
Alaska Dispatch (AD)
Alaska Journal of Commerce (AJC)
Alaska Native News (ANN)
Alaska Public Media (APM)
Anchorage Daily News (ADN)
Arctic Info (Russian) (AIR)
Arctic Institute (TAI)
Barents Nova (BN)
Barents Observer (BO)
Bristol Bay Times (BBT)
BusinessWeek (BW)
Canadian Mining Journal (CMJ)
Christian Science Monitor (CSM)
Eye on the Arctic (EOTA)
Fairbanks Daily News-Miner (FNM)
Financial Times (FT)
Globe and Mail (G&M)
Government of Canada (GOC)
Government of the Northwest Territories (GNWT)
Huffington Post (HP)
Indian Country Today Media Network (ICTMN)
Johnson’s Russia List (JRL)
Kalaallit Nunaata Radioa (KNR)
Lapin Kansa (LK)
Moscow Times (MT)
National Geographic (NG)
Natural Gas Europe (NGE)
Naval Today (NT)
New York Times (NYT)
Northern Journal (NJ)
Northern News Service Online (NNSO)
Northern Public Affairs (NPA)
Norwegian Polar Institute (NPI)
Nunatsiaq News (NN)
Oil & Gas Journal (OGJ)
Ottawa Citizen (OC)
Petroleum News (PN)
RIA Novosti (RIAN)
Russia Beyond the Headlines (RBTH)
Russia Today (RT)
Voice of Russia (VOR)
Wall Street Journal (WSJ)
Washington Post (WP)
Whitehorse Star (WS)
Winnipeg Free Press (WFP)
Yukon News (YN)



Arctic News: The Arctic This Week February 19

$
0
0



The Arctic This Week February 9 - 15, 2015

198385159_97f26edefa_o.jpg
photo: Ville Miettinen

Welcome and thanks for joining us this week! We hope that you find TATW interesting and entertaining to read. If you’re not a subscriber yet, you can sign up here. As always, all editorial choices, opinions and any mistakes are the authors’ own. Anything that we missed? Please feel free to share material with us if you think it deserves inclusion in TATW.

We are thrilled to announce the newest addition to TATW. Ryan Uljua joins TATW from Boston, Massachusetts, where he is currently an Intelligence Analyst at an international risk management and crisis response firm. Ryan graduated from the George Washington University Elliott School of International Affairs where he focused on security and defense policy as well as geographic information systems (GIS) and remote sensing. He will be taking over the Society and Mining sections from Caitlin Del Sole, who after nearly a year of writing must, regrettably, leave TATW for a new career opportunity.

UPCOMING CONFERENCE
The annual High North Dialogue Conference will take March 17-19, 2015 in Bodø Norway. To find out more click here.
Screen Shot 2015-01-21 at 2.53.54 PM.png

THIS WEEK’S TOP STORIES

Canada’s northern territories receive poor grades in national health report

In a nationwide study that issued health ‘report cards’ for each of Canada’s provinces and territories, Yukon, N.W.T., and Nunavut all received a failing 'D-' grade (CBC). The study, conducted by the Conference Board of Canada, examined health factors such as life expectancy, infant mortality, and deaths caused by cancer, suicide and heart disease. British Columbia received the top grade with an 'A' and the national average was a 'B'. Meanwhile, Newfoundland and Labrador also received a poor ‘D-’ grade (CBC).

Shell’s Chukchi leases reconfirmed while administration approves ConocoPhillips plan for NPR-A
The Bureau of Ocean Energy Management has decided not to modify Shell’s Chukchi leases after the Bureau was directed to reevaluate the leases by a federal appeals court ruling (APM). The final decision on whether to certify or cancel the leases rests with Interior Secretary Sally Jewell (ADN). In related business, the Obama administration also approved a ConocoPhillips plan to open the National Petroleum Reserve-Alaska to oil and gas exploration. The plan will include building an eight mile road into the reserve and an elevated pipeline to move oil from a 12 acre drilling pad (ADN). Shell, meanwhile, is moving ahead incrementally with plans for the 2015 drilling season, including receiving permission to moor two of its vessels near Dutch Harbor (PN).

Further sinkholes in Yamal
Scientists in Russia have discovered eight new sinkholes near the Bovanenkovo gas field in the Yamal Peninsula. They are located around a major crater discovered last July with a diameter of around 60 meters – the Black Hole of Yamal. The holes are likely to be a result of the release of methane, followed by permafrost collapse. The development of further holes could endanger the infrastructure established by Gazprom, such as the railway connection to the national grid or the gas pipeline to Europe (BO).

Norwegian Air is not allowed to overfly Russia
After being denied rights to fly across Russia, Norwegian Air asks the Norwegian government to reply by denying Russian airliners Norwegian airspace. The detour the airline has to make incurs an extra 4.5 tons of fuel and 50 minutes per flight, which weighs heavy on the company’s profits (BO).


THE POLITICAL SCENE

United States
In a meeting with U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry, Alaska Senator Lisa Murkowski urged the senior U.S. diplomat to pay increasing attention to the region, especially to issues beyond climate change (APM). In-state, the Alaska House of Representatives has passed an Arctic policy bill, which “lays out the state’s values concerning the Arctic, and provides a general sense of direction for how lawmakers would like to see it developed” (APM). Meanwhile, the Alaska Senate has proposed legislation pushing back on the White House’s attempts to designate ANWR as wilderness area by opening the area’s coastal plain to drilling (FNM).
Europe
Russia
Canada

ENERGY
Alaska energy bills advance through committee
Two energy related bills moved forward in the Alaska legislature this week. The first bill addresses modifications to the Interior Energy Project. Originally intended to develop infrastructure for the trucking of North Slope gas to Fairbanks, the bill will now refocus on shipping Cook Inlet gas from southcentral Alaska to Fairbanks (FNM). The whole endeavor could be scuttled as lawmakers balk over the prospects of a state-owned gas distribution system. For some background on this complicated issue, see this short article in Petroleum News. The second bill will modify oil and gas lease settlement approvals based on concerns regarding the process that led to the state’s current leases in Point Thompson (FNM).  Governor Bill Walker has filed to drop his personal lawsuit around the Point Thomson leases. Before his election, he filed the suit claiming the leases were illegal, but now as governor has moved to make amendments to the leases through the legislative process (ADN). Budget cuts are also forcing the state to trim oil and gas related expenses, including eliminating senior positions in the State Pipeline Coordinator’s Office (PN).


Canada
Stymied in the lower 48, Alberta floats idea of moving tar-sands oil through Alaska (EOTA).

Russia

Alaska
SCIENCE, ENVIRONMENT AND WILDLIFE
Weather & Climate
Geology
Wildlife & ecology
Environmental management
Miscellaneous
MILITARY / SEARCH & RESCUE

United States
Russia
MINING
Agnico Eagle reports strong financial performance in 2014

Canadian gold producer Agnico Eagle posted a profit of $83 million for 2014, a significant increase from its $687 million loss reported in 2013 (NN). Agnico Eagle’s record gold production in 2014 was due in part to a notable increase in productivity at the company’s Amaruq gold project in central Nunavut Kivalliq region, as well as the continued development of its other Nunavut mining projects at Meadowbank and Meliadine (CMJ).

Financially-beleaguered Finnish mining company Talvivaara received more bad news this week when a district prosecutor pressed charges against the company’s CEO over alleged environmental crimes (EOTA).
NovaCopper announced it will spend roughly $10 million in 2015 on a feasibility study for the company’s promising Arctic copper project in Northwest Alaska’s Ambler Mining District (PN).

FISHERIES, SHIPPING AND OTHER BUSINESS NEWS

The economic opportunities follow the mushers
Moving the starting point of the Iditarod also requires the business that comes with the race to move. The event is an important income source for the companies and villages along the trail. However, they are working quickly to reorganize logistics and adapt to the changes (APM).
12 recommendations for Greenland’s economy
A joint report released by the Danish and Greenlandic governments last week suggests developing Greenland’s tourism and mining industries in order to stimulate the country’s economic development. In the longer term, water exports and services around Arctic shipping could also contribute significantly to economic growth (AJ).

Fisheries
Shipping
Pollution - Clearing the air (emissions from increased Arctic shipping) (AJ).
Aviation
Other business and economic news
In Cambridge Bay, Canada, the yearly Kitikmeot Trade Show took place from February 9 to February 11:
U.S.
Russia
Europe
Greenland
Vittus modernizes the commercial rules (Greenland) (KNR, in Danish).
Canada
HEALTH, YOUTH, SOCIETY AND CULTURE
Finland keeps top spot in annual press freedom rankings

Reporters Without Borders released their annual World Press Freedom Index and Finland retained its number one ranking for the fifth year in a row (Reporters Without Borders). Finland was joined in the top-five by fellow Arctic nations Norway at two, Denmark at three, and Sweden at five (BO). Outside of the top-five, Canada was ranked at eight, Iceland at 21, the United States at 49, and Russia at 152.

Iditarod starting location moved north to Fairbanks

Due to a lack of snow cover, the Iditarod Trail Committee announced that the start of the famous 1,000 mile race will be moved north from Willow, AK to Fairbanks, AK (ADN). The ceremonial start of the race will still take place in Anchorage on March 7, while the restart will occur in Fairbanks on March 9 for only the second time since 1973. The decision to reroute approximately 600 miles of the trail is expected to have a significant negative impact on the economies of towns and communities that will now be bypassed by the race (EOTA).

Bill to abolish daylight savings time in Alaska moves forward

Alaska lawmakers are developing a bill that would exempt the state from daylight savings time beginning in 2017. Under the bill, Alaska would be five hours behind Eastern Standard Time from March through November, rather than the current four (APM). If the bill is successful, Alaska would join Hawaii and Arizona as the third US state to abandon daylight savings (Reuters).

Health
Alaska Governor Bill Walker announced a planned expansion of the state’s Medicaid program that is expected to save millions annually (AJC).

Youth
Oil and gas giant ExxonMobil pledged $600,000 over the next three years to the Alaska Native Science & Engineering Program in order to expand its pre-college offerings (Arctic Sounder).
Magnet dorm opens (Arctic Sounder).

Society
Greenland’s population has dropped below 56,000 for the first time since 1997, after peaking at 57,000 in 2006 (NORA).  

Culture
“Into the Wild” author Jon Krakauer put forth a new theory on how Chris McCandless may have died, his fifth different theory since 1993 (ADN).
A new documentary, “Svi­ta­hof”, examines the history and culture surrounding sweat lodges in Iceland (mbl).

INFRASTRUCTURE

Canada
United States
Europe


Abbreviation Key
Aboriginal Peoples Television Network (APTN)
Aftenbladet (AB)
Alaska Business Monthly (ABM)
Alaska Dispatch (AD)
Alaska Journal of Commerce (AJC)
Alaska Native News (ANN)
Alaska Public Media (APM)
Anchorage Daily News (ADN)
Arctic Info (Russian) (AIR)
Arctic Institute (TAI)
Barents Nova (BN)
Barents Observer (BO)
Bristol Bay Times (BBT)
BusinessWeek (BW)
Canadian Mining Journal (CMJ)
Christian Science Monitor (CSM)
Eye on the Arctic (EOTA)
Fairbanks Daily News-Miner (FNM)
Financial Times (FT)
Globe and Mail (G&M)
Government of Canada (GOC)
Government of the Northwest Territories (GNWT)
Huffington Post (HP)
Indian Country Today Media Network (ICTMN)
Johnson’s Russia List (JRL)
Kalaallit Nunaata Radioa (KNR)
Lapin Kansa (LK)
Moscow Times (MT)
National Geographic (NG)
Natural Gas Europe (NGE)
Naval Today (NT)
New York Times (NYT)
Northern Journal (NJ)
Northern News Service Online (NNSO)
Northern Public Affairs (NPA)
Norwegian Polar Institute (NPI)
Nunatsiaq News (NN)
Oil & Gas Journal (OGJ)
Ottawa Citizen (OC)
Petroleum News (PN)
RIA Novosti (RIAN)
Russia Beyond the Headlines (RBTH)
Russia Today (RT)
Voice of Russia (VOR)
Wall Street Journal (WSJ)
Washington Post (WP)
Whitehorse Star (WS)
Winnipeg Free Press (WFP)
Yukon News (YN)



The Arctic Melt: Turning Resource Development into Human Development

$
0
0


The Arctic Melt: Turning Resource Development into Human Development
Victoria Herrmann, February 23, 2015

1-23642145@N00_h.jpg
Photo: Flickr/Luke Jones

The Arctic Melt is a three-part analysis of the Arctic Human Development Report II: Regional Processes and Global Linkages. Developed over a ten-year period, the study assesses the state of Arctic human development and highlights major regional changes. Its findings will be important in informing the decisions and policies of the upcoming US Arctic Council Chairmanship.

In the context of Alaska, this series will take an in-depth look at three of the key trends underscored by the Report: globalization, urbanization, and demographic shifts. On Monday, Part I: Investing in Place will explore how we create livable, localized places in a globalized north. On Wednesday, Part II: Investing in Innovation will consider the opportunities of urbanization for entrepreneurship and economic ingenuity. On Friday, Part III: Investing in Communities will conclude the discussion by looking at ways to sustainably connect the growing young and old sectors of Alaska’s population.

Taken together, these three trends provide a chance to redefine how we conceptualize, and realize, Arctic investment – a chance to turn economic growth into human development.   

Part I: Investing In Place

Today more than ever before, the circumpolar region is integrated into the international system. [1] Although the North has always been connected to the rest of the world through trade networks and migratory routes, globalization and climate change have created unprecedented connectivity through communication systems, global markets, and environmental cooperation.

But the Arctic is not just connected globally – it has quickly moved from the periphery to the world’s center stage.

Flag plantings on the ocean floor, shipping prospects for financial prosperity, and images of polar bears on icebergs are just a few narratives that collectively construct the Polar Vortex craze that’s consuming media, politicians, businessmen, and the global public alike.

With such linkages facilitating a marketable awareness of the Arctic through science and geopolitics, it is easy to forget that globalization is a two-way street. While the south may still visualize the Arctic as the last, albeit melting, frontier, the northern environment and its people are very much a part of, and influenced by, the international economic, political, and cultural developments of today.

For the past decade, globalization has been transforming the social and political milieus of the Arctic as much as climate change has changed its physical landscapes – if not more so. The second Arctic Human Development Report reaffirms that the combination of rapid and stressful changes highlighted in the first study ten years ago continue today, amplified in both rate and magnitude. It finds that the societal and environmental changes brought about by globalization and global climate change challenge the wellbeing of Arctic residents, local communities, and many northern socioeconomic sectors. [2]  

Globalization brings complex, multifaceted challenges to human development in the Arctic; but it also provides an opportunity for policymakers to retool globalization’s effects to benefit communities in Alaska. Harnessing the political, economic, and social benefits of globalization can help build sustainable, locally oriented built infrastructure for the Arctic of the 21st Century.

Globalization from the Top of the World

In many ways, the effects of globalization are no different for the Arctic than they are for the rest of the globe. Economically, globalization has internationalized the decision-making for resource development. Extractive companies are increasingly multinational and operate according to the world’s demand for and cost of producing and moving Arctic resources. This translates to the transfer of primary concerns away from places in the north to international headquarters and markets.   

While economic globalization provides an opportunity to break the internal colonialist processes of 20th Century extractive activities, the increased mobility and privatization of capital also makes it difficult for governments to tax, support a welfare state, and protect the environment. Companies are too often interested in meeting the market test – expected revenues must exceed expected costs – without investing in long-term development. [3]  

Despite the economic buzz surrounding an ice-free Arctic, the Arctic Human Development Report emphasizes that the region’s harsh climate conditions, its sparse population, and the remoteness of deposits from centers of consumption, production, and decision-making will continue to drive production costs up. [4] Beyond these conditions, the uncertainty in petroleum commodity prices from new unconventional oil production, a pending global climate change deal in Paris later this year, and the net costs of climate-induced storm surges and shoreline erosion also contribute to high costs of doing business in the north.        

Globalized resource production and consumption will continue to be economically important in the Arctic. However, the worldwide volatility of petroleum prices, international climate treaties, and the negative consequences of global environmental shifts have created a space to rethink the northern economy.

These globalized trends that hinder investments in the large-scale, short-term infrastructure of extractive industry provide the chance to redefine Arctic development. Redefining what successful development means requires a new matrix of infrastructure investment that prioritizes employment diversification, the maintenance of social services at the local level, and the strength of small-scale design that support a healthy, inclusive Alaskan society.

Nome_Alaska.jpg
Photo: Wikipedia/Mildred Pierce
Beyond Profit: The Internationalization of Place and People

In order to move investment away from creating extractive settlements and into investing in places of vibrant, livable communities, Alaska should take advantage of the positive socio-political effects of globalization. Politically, globalization has divested the power of state governments both upwards and downwards. The events of the 1990s established the Arctic as an international space, where regional and sub-national actors became important players in international relations. The Arctic Council and the Barents Euro-Arctic Council are products of the post-Cold War processes of fostering cooperation across East-West lines that empowered local actors. [5] Today, the Arctic’s international links have moved beyond its immediate neighbors to countries like Singapore and South Korea. The communications revolution has enabled the exchange of knowledge, ideas, and practices from the North Pole to the Southern Hemisphere. Prior to this revolution, Alaskan communities only had easy access to design concepts, policy ideas, and infrastructure plans from their own governments and companies active in the Arctic. Now, with the advent of virtual and telecommunication, Alaskans can share, adapt, and build off of policy models and build best practices from a much larger, more international pool of thinkers and practitioners.           

Conversely, there has also been devolution of power to local authority through political decentralization. [6] This transfer of authority to empower localities not only endows local governments and political leaders in policy making for their own communities – it also emboldens the voices of community members themselves. Being closer to decision makers empowers the opinions and choices of societal subgroups with different needs informed by gender, class, age, and heritage.      

This is particularly important given globalization’s cultural impacts. With increased migration from the south, and internal migration within Alaska from rural to urban areas, come increased interactions amongst people with varied experiences, cultures, and identities. Day to day living in a globalized Arctic, much like daily life in New York or London, is comprised of countless cultural negotiations and contestations that culminate in a new definition of what it means to be “a Northerner.”  

By accessing global communication and information sharing systems to support local development, capitalizing on political decentralization to include all stakeholders, and tapping into the rich cultural and social positives of globalization, Alaska can create local infrastructure that is both resilient to the economic challenges of globalization the Human Development Report emphasizes and supportive of its advantages.

Building a Smarter Arctic

Originally, most Arctic settlements based on Euro-American colonialism and capitalism were built as extractive communities rather than places to live. [7] Their vitality was dependent on local resource extraction and their creation as small, remote settlements were based on where the highest concentration of these commercialized sea and land resources could be found.

Globalization processes political centralization and market volatility from more competitively priced natural resource production southward have created a space to redefine Arctic settlements into livable communities independent of the extraction of a single resource. However, while there have been a number of initiatives aimed at building community through arts festivals, community centers, and civic programming, the built environment that serves as the site for negotiating communal sustainability and viability has been overlooked.   

Complete Streets for Skiing and Dog Sleds

The Arctic is not alone in this transition from investing in companies towards investing in place. The American Planning Association, a national organization that brings planners, citizens, and elected official together by providing leadership in the development of vital communities, conducted a national poll in 2014 on community preferences. Sixty-five percent of respondents believed that investing in schools, public transportation networks, and walkable neighborhoods was a better way to grow the economy than investing in business-oriented infrastructure. APA Executive Director Paul Farmer noted at the report’s press release, “If there is a single message from this poll, it’s that place matters.” [8]

The lower 48 have development new planning strategies that create a built environment where place matters and resilient communities are built. Alaska is just beginning to adopt these design principles and adapt them to its particular geography. In early 2014 Senator Mark Begich introduced the Safe Streets Act, a national act from 2004 that requires states and regions to adopt Complete Streets policies for federal transportation project funding. [9] Complete streets are roadways designed and operated to enable safe access for all users, including pedestrians, bicyclists, motorists, and transit riders of all ages and abilities. In the Arctic, this also means building streets that are inclusive of cross country skiers, dog sledders, snowmobiles, and all-terrain vehicles.

Anchorage, Fairbanks, and Juneau have already begun to adopt Complete Street models to provide safer, multimodal transportation networks that reflect Alaska’s unique local demands of geography and climate. Fairbanks, for example, is replacing traffic signals with modern roundabouts, which cut congestion, emissions, and crashes while moving traffic more smoothly. [10] Anchorage has hired several staff members to the city’s transportation office to work specifically on conceptualizing and building non-motorized transportation pathways. Widening sidewalks, adding bike lanes, and reducing motorized lane widths on key downtown arterials to slow speeds down all enable safer, healthier transportation options for commuters, students, and community members.     
Supporting complete street infrastructure has helped Alaska to become the top states in the nation in the proportion of people who walk or bike to work and top per capita funding for non-motorized transportation infrastructure in the last year. While both of these statistics are in part facilitated by Alaska’s low population, they still speak to the influence complete streets have on citizen’s transport choices, their perceived sense of safety, and the state’s commitment to investing in place.

1-Screen Shot 2015-02-23 at 10.59.29 AM.jpg
Graphic: Wikipedia/AG Freiraum und Vegetation
Adapting Smart Growth to Alaska

However, in order to truly invest in place and take advantage of globalization Alaska must reach beyond pedestrian and bicycle friendly roads in its three major cities. Investing in smart growth infrastructure in both urban and rural communities, adapted to the Arctic’s climate and geography, build off of the current success of complete streets.

Smart growth is a type of community planning that encourages compact, walkable, and transit-oriented development. It focuses on sustainability and creating a unique sense of place through expanding the range of transportation, employment, and housing choices; promote public health, and preserve and enhance local identity and culture. [9] Through policy regulations like zoning ordinances, local growth boundaries, shared development rights, and environmental assessments, smart growth increases family income and wealth; provides safe walking routes for children; stimulates economic activity; and fosters livable, healthy places for diverse communities. [11]    

Kiruna, a small city in Sweden’s North, has incorporated a number of smart growth elements into its new design. The city is in the beginning stages of moving its entire built-infrastructure and population eastward several kilometers over the next 100 years to allow the nearby iron mine to continue operations. The new plan, designed by Swedish firm White, aims to rebuild a denser, more economic diversified city that can exist independent of its namesake mine. All new development will be oriented around a compactly built central town hall square surrounded by narrow streets. [12]

Vastly different than its sprawling neighborhoods today, these streets, designed to protect pedestrians from wind and encourage walking, will be filled with shops and cafes. Residences, converted into mainly apartments instead of single-family homes, won’t be further than three blocks from a central green space built for cross-country skiing and tobogganing. Although the new plan incorporates many energy efficient building codes, the new Kiruna will go a step further to harness the excess heat created from the mine to power and heat the town. Beyond the physical infrastructure, Kiruna’s smart growth planning is mindful of all residents and values a diverse set of viewpoints. The relocation team includes executives of the mining company, locally elected representatives, urban planners, residents, and anthropologists. [13] Such a multidisciplinary approach ensures that the result is an inclusive, identity-rich community.
    
1-Kirunavaara.jpg
Photo: Wikipedia/Johan Arvelius

Smart growth does not just apply to cities. An increasing share of planning research focuses on the application of compact design and mixed land use patterns to rural and small towns. Small, cold-weather communities like Howard, South Dakota, small towns along US Route 1 in Maine, and Winooski, Vermont have all won national awards for adapting smart growth principles to sparsely populated areas. [14] Creating mixed use, green complexes as town centers, recycling temporary housing from once-mined areas into new compact neighborhoods, and developing sustainable regional transport plans are just a few examples of rural smart growth adaptations. An innovative Alaskan application of smart growth could come from including their principles in the planning process of towns relocated by climate change like Newtok or Shishmaref.  

In addition to complete streets and the long-range regional considerations of sustainably, smart growth also advocates for mixed-use development and neighborhood schools, which will be respectively examined in Parts II and III. Each piece in the series, when woven together, creates a robust picture for sustainable investment and development that serves the economy, the community, and the environment.    

Harnessing the Power Information Sharing Systems

Many of the principles above have already been implemented south of the Arctic Circle. While some will need to be adapted to Arctic-specific contexts, much of the planning foundational pillars and practices will remain the same. Arctic communities should take advantage of globalization’s communication and information sharing systems. Best practice sharing and collective brainstorming between successful communities and those in Alaska just beginning their investments in smart growth can provide much needed technical assistance.  

C40 Climate Leadership Group, a 63-city network that aims to ‘implement meaningful and sustainable climate-related actions locally that will help address climate change globally,’ is one just one example of an already existing platform for best-practice sharing. [15] The network sees itself as an effective forum where cities can collaborate, share knowledge, and drive meaningful, measurable, and sustainable action. It does this by breaking the larger group down into smaller networks built on commonly identities opportunities, interests, and priorities. Staff at C40 help to facilitate peer-to-peer exchanges of knowledge, support, and novel ideas in developing policies, programs, or projects connected to the groups theme. Projects like the Waterfront of Toronto, which is building mixed-use communities in the naturalized and flood-protected mouth of the Don River, and the South Waterfront District project in Portland, which intends to turn the city’s larger underdeveloped industrial site into a mixed use public area with parks, plazas, and river access, use the Delta Cities themed network to share ideas and give advice across borders on these two positive development projects. [16]

The durability of new practices can be reinforced by visits to successful communities by Alaskan planners and policymakers. For example, when Mayor Bill Peduto and County Executive Rich Fitzgerald prioritized bus rapid transit for the city of Pittsburgh, they took a cohort of business leaders, advocates, city staff, and other stakeholders to Cleveland to learn about the success of that city’s HealthLine bus rapid transit project. [17] Stakeholders often credit study tours for opening up their horizons to find solutions to their local obstacles.

Redefining the DEW Line for the 21st Century  

Despite meaningful moves away from colonial policies, the globalized narrative of the North is still an extractive one. Political rhetoric, business forecasts, and climate science all measure the Arctic’s significance in terms of benefits for the rest of the world. Because of its ecological vulnerability, the region is often called the canary in the coalmine for climate change. What happens in the Arctic in the years to come will be an early indicator of the future environmental changes for the rest of the Earth.

What’s more, climate change consequences like rising sea levels that are deemed unacceptable for the developed south are not only tolerated in the Arctic, but capitalized on. Anticipated open waters from climate change have prompted countries to highlight the importance of their national Arctic territory for mineral development, shipping routes, and energy security for economic growth.  

Rather than concentrate global attention on what can be extracted from a melting Arctic, the international community should focus on the new avenues globalization has created for investment in and knowledge exchange with Alaska. Unstable markets and high cost of production provide policymakers in Juneau and US the chance to reformulate how decisions on infrastructure investment are made – the chance to invest in livable, sustainable places rather than resource rush settlements.  

Investing in complete streets and smart growth principles are one key way to take advantage of that opportunity. It capitalizes on globalization’s decentralization of political power; utilizes today’s international communication and information systems; and supports the rich, diverse cultural perspectives of Arctic residents. Smart growth provides the physical infrastructure to increase productivity and innovation. to develop a thriving local economy, and to take advantage of access to global markets. On Wednesday, Part II will build off of the physical infrastructure detailed here by exploring how to create policy and institutional infrastructure that works in tandem with Alaska’s built environment to encourage a diversified economy.          

In a way, the Arctic is inevitably the world’s distant early warning line for climate change. The North Pole, along with other geographies like small island nations in the Pacific, will be the first and potentially hardest hit by ecological shifts and weather pattern variations. But unlike the original Distant Early Warning (DEW) Line, national and international policymakers today must think beyond constructing expensive, isolated stations that provide little to Arctic peoples but security to the lower 48. Investing in place means moving beyond the dominating narratives of an extractive Arctic globalization from a southern perspective. Investing in pace means investing in local infrastructure that foster economically, environmentally, and culturally thriving communities for the ‘northerners of the 21st Century’ that live there.


[1] E. Carina, H. Keskitalo, and Chris Southcott. “Chapter 10 Globalization,” Arctic Human Development Report: Regional Processes and Global Linkages. Edited by Yoan Nymand Larsen and Gail Fondahl.
[2] Ibid.
[3] Lee Husky, Ilmo Mӓenpӓӓ, and Alexander Pelyasov. “Chapter 4 Economic Systems,” Arctic Human Development Report: Regional Processes and Global Linkages. Edited by Yoan Nymand Larsen and Gail Fondahl.
[4] Idib.
[5] E. Carina, H. Keskitalo, and Chris Southcott. “Chapter 10 Globalization,” Arctic Human Development Report: Regional Processes and Global Linkages. Edited by Yoan Nymand Larsen and Gail Fondahl.
[6] E. Carina, H. Keskitalo, and Chris Southcott. “Chapter 10 Globalization,” Arctic Human Development Report: Regional Processes and Global Linkages. Edited by Yoan Nymand Larsen and Gail Fondahl.
[7] Rasmus Ole Rasmussen, Grete K. Hovelsrud, and Shari Gearheard. “Chapter 11 Community Viability and Adaptation,” Arctic Human Development Report: Regional Processes and Global Linkages. Edited by Yoan Nymand Larsen and Gail Fondahl.
[8] American Planning Association, “Investing in Place: Two Generation’s View on the Future of Communities.” https://www.planning.org/policy/polls/investing/
[9] National Complete Streets Coalition at Smart Growth America, “The Last Frontier: Complete Streets in Alaska.” http://www.smartgrowthamerica.org/documents/alaska-complete-streets.pdf
[10] Idib.
[11] Smart Growth America, http://www.smartgrowthamerica.org/what-is-smart-growth
[12]  Feargus O’Sullivan, http://nextcity.org/features/view/the-city-that-is-moving-9-kilometers-down-the-road
[13] Idib.
[14] US Environmental Protection Agency, http://www.epa.gov/smartgrowth/sg_rural.htm
[15] C40, c40.org
[16] C40, Deltacities.com
[17] Merrill Stabile, http://www.post-gazette.com/opinion/Op-Ed/2015/01/18/Let-s-move-forward-with-Bus-Rapid-Transit-in-Pittsburgh/stories/201501180063





















High North Dialogue Podcast – Interview with Alexander Sergunin

$
0
0



High North Dialogue Podcast – Interview with Alexander Sergunin
Andreas Raspotnik, February 23, 2014

Screen Shot 2014-11-10 at 4.06.30 PM.png

In our 3rd podcast for the High North Dialogue 2015 we talked with Alexander Sergunin, Professor in the Department of International Relations at St. Petersburg State University. Alexander Sergunin received a Ph.D. in history from Moscow State University in 1985. He is the author of numerous publications on regionalism, foreign and security policy, EU-Russia relations and Russian Arctic policy.
In the often referred to so-called “Western World”, the public perception of Russia foreign and security policy is still dominated by black-and-white Cold War paradigms. The main objective of our conversation with Alexander was to counteract that particular picture and briefly highlight some aspects of Russia’s current Arctic endeavour.

Alexander stressed that Russia’s main Arctic intention is its focus on regional cooperation, avoiding any potential spill-over from the Ukrainian unrest. Consequently, Russia’s current aim to modernise its armed forces, of which most are located in the Arctic region, should not be perceived as Russian re-militarisation efforts of the Arctic. According to Alexander the simple purpose of related efforts is to modernise antiquated strategic and conventional forces.

Alexander was also highly critical about Denmark’s most recent submission to the UN Commission on the Continental Shelf concerning an extended continental shelf that partly covers the central Arctic Ocean. The submission seems to lack sufficient geological and geophysical proof that justifies Denmark’s claim, a mistake that has also been made by Russia in its first submission in 2001.

Again, he also commented on the oil and gas situation in the Russian (offshore) Arctic, criticising the Western sanctions, underscoring the long-term detrimental effect for both Russia and Western countries. However, a closer relationship between Russia and China is not exactly the ideal situation neither. Especially from a technological perspective Russia still heavily depends on their Western partners. Yet, a closer relationship between these two countries could give boost to the Northern Sea Route, a sea route that could be developed jointly for mutual benefit.

Transcript
Hello and welcome to this 3rd podcast for the High North Dialogue 2015, a collaboration of the University of Nordland (Bodø), the University’s High North Centre for Business and Governance, and The Arctic Institute.
We are speaking with attendees and speakers about their work, the High North Dialogue and the conference’s theme of security and business in the Arctic. Thanks for joining us. I am Andreas Raspotnik.
Today we are talking with Alexander Sergunin, Professor in the Department of International Relations at St. Petersburg State University. Alexander Sergunin received a Ph.D. in history from Moscow State University in 1985. He is the author of numerous publications on regionalism, foreign and security policy, EU-Russia relations and Russian Arctic policy. He currently works on a research project entitled “EU and Russia: Two Competing ‘Soft Power’ Projects in the Baltic Sea Region.”
Andreas Raspotnik: Dear Alexander, thanks for joining us today.
Alexander Sergunin: Thank you Andreas. I am looking forward to our conversation because I guess what we are lacking most recently is the lack of dialogue between Western and Eastern experts, particular on the Arctic.
Andreas Raspotnik: Let met start with our first question. The theme of High North Dialogue 2015 is “The Arctic in a Global Perspective - Arctic Business & Security”. Discussing Arctic security in our 1st podcast Michael Byers explicitly highlighted the increasing need for Arctic policing – provided either by militaries or coast guards. What is your first association when you think of the term “Arctic security”?
Alexander Sergunin: Well, actually the first perception is certainly not associated with military or hard security. I guess for Russia it’s much more important the soft security aspects – the soft security dimensions, such as environment, such as economic challenges, such as some non-traditional challenges related to potential oil spills, things like potential increase in poaching, in smuggling. Also we still have a residual problem with indigenous peoples, so that kind of stuff. And I think that we have to distinguish between the journalistic things and the experts’ opinions on approaches because sometimes the journalists, not only Western but also Russian, they tend to focus on hard security, military security issues rather than on real problems which face Russia in the Arctic.
Andreas Raspotnik: And yet it is still hard security that dominates our Western public perception of Russia, which did not seem to have changed even thirty years after the end of the Cold War. As a matter of fact the Ukrainian unrest has revealed a still prominent public conception of the West vs. the East – political rationality vs. political inconsistence. In the Arctic the picture seems to be rather similar with analysts claiming that the “Russian bear” aims to militarise the Arctic in order to achieve its regional economic goals. How do you oppose this distinct Russian-Arctic picture?
Alexander Sergunin: Yes again, it’s just one more journalistic stereotype about Russia and its foreign policy behaviour in general and specifically in the Arctic region. I would say that actually it’s not the intention of Russia to militarise the Arctic. On the opposite I guess Russia wants to keep the Arctic cooperation, which is quite a unique one as compared to other regions. And the Russian leadership many times repeatedly told that we wouldn’t want to have a spill-over effect of the Ukrainian crisis to such a fragile and unique region like the Arctic. I think that some of these stereotypes on the Western part about Russian military policies in the Arctic they stem from the fact that they tend to forget that actually what Russia is doing is the continuation of previous plans to rebuild and modernise the Russian armed forces and Russian military infrastructure which actually degenerated over the last quarter of the century after the end of the Cold War. Let me remind you that in the 1990s the Russian military simply abandoned all these air bases, naval bases and border stations in the Arctic region. And the whole military infrastructure just deteriorated for years and years. And about 10 years ago the Russian leadership decided to just keep alive all this military infrastructure, so talking about modernisation, quite modern modernisation of Russian armed forces and military infrastructure in the high north, rather than about revisionism and expansionism, some aggressive plans, that kind of things. So I mean don’t forget that other Arctic nations also do the same. Maybe the problem is that and again some journalists tend to forget that in contrast with other Arctic nations Russia has to combine the modernisation of its conventional forces and strategic forces in the Arctic. I mean it’s a unique combination. None of the other Arctic states have that kind of combination. For example the United States: They have strategic forces, nuclear weaponry which is not only based in the Arctic. But in Russia the uniqueness is that the Russian Arctic, in particular the Kola Peninsula, hosts ⅔ of Russia nuclear submarines. So when Russia wants to modernise its armed forces it has to take care of both conventional and strategic components. That might have some negative impressions on the rest of the World that Russia has some aggressive plans but that’s not the case. I mean if you compare for example the modernisation of Russian conventional forces in the region and those for example of the Norwegian ones I would say that Russia does not have and will not have in the foreseeable future that kind of class, let’s say frigates like Norway has or will have; or Denmark. So in terms of conventional modernisation, I guess we now have forces comparable with those neighbours. The strategic component is different but it has nothing to do with the Arctic region as such it is just for the global confrontational interaction with the United States.
Andreas Raspotnik: Another Arctic topic often connected with the issue of militarisation and potential dispute in the region is the question of an extended continental shelf. Russia is supposed to re-submit its submission in 2015. In the context of Canada and Denmark’s submissions it seems that the public media and some analysts already start again to invoke potential conflict and disagreement between the Arctic states, as for instance in a recent article byNewsweek. How would you analyse this particular issue?
Alexander Sergunin: Yes, first of all let me clarify the status of these submissions on claims of the continental shelf. Canada filed the claim for the continental shelf but not in the Arctic region. It did it with regard to the North Atlantic continental shelf, which has nothing to do with its claims on the Arctic maritime spaces and Arctic continental shelf. Canada did not submit that kind of claim yet. Russia also is only planning to do that this spring but we will do it because Russia several times postponed this submission because it did not have sufficient geological and geophysical proofs and materials to prove that kind of claim. So Russia now is very cautious, because, let me remind you, Russia had already filed that kind of submission in 2001 and it was declined by the UN Commission on the Limits of the Continental Shelf because Russia was unable to provide sufficient geological and geophysical arguments. So Russia is now very cautious. The only country, which submitted its application for the extension of the continental shelf, is Denmark. And it’s quite strange because first it overlaps with the potential Russian one and to my knowledge Denmark did it without that kind of detailed investigations like Russia did over the last several years. So I guess the chances for the approval of the Danish application is not very good, not very high. My impression is that Denmark repeats the same mistakes like Russia did it in 2001, so I mean the legal experts said that the chances are not very good. And I guess Russia has a much more balanced approach with this problem because actually what are we talking about – we are talking about the extension of the continental shelf, extending over 200nm, which already every Arctic country has this 200nm maritime territory and the seabed. So if you look at the mineral resources, I mean the potential mineral resources, especially oil and gas which can be discovered in these waters, I would say that approximately 70% or 80% of these potential mineral resources are already within these exclusive economic zones (200nm) and even having that kind of exclusive economic zones, I mean the extraction of oil and gas in these deep waters is impossible for many, many decades ahead. What are the Arctic countries doing now? They simply would like to have a strategic control over these territories or maritime spaces rather than having real plans to start extraction immediately or in the foreseeable future. The Arctic, I guess, is something very distant.
Andreas Raspotnik: Turning to “business”, the High North Dialogue’s 2nd theme. Over the last decade the development efforts of the various oil and gas fields located on the Russian Arctic continental shelf have seen a multitude of up and downs. What do you think is the immediate, let’s say 10 years, future of Shtokman or the various fields on and surrounding the Yamal Peninsula, especially if we consider the current low oil price?
Alexander Sergunin: Let me just repeat what I have already said. The Russian leadership and also the people from the oil and gas business they never had that kind of rosy picture of the future of Russian gas and oil extraction. They are quite realistic about that. They are thinking about some distant future, they are preparing for that kind of distant future. They believe that in order to develop oil and gas industries in the high north you should plan it well in advance. You have to plan these kinds of things 20, 30 years ahead and the problem is that you cannot do it over night. First you have to explore these territories, then you have technologies for offshore drilling and Russia does not have these kinds of technologies for the time being. Then you have skilled workforce for that, so you also need time to train it. Anyway, I mean Russia has very strategic plans for the future not for now. More or less we can speak realistically about oil and gas industries on the Yamal Peninsula and also the shallow waters of the Pechora and Kara Seas, that’s it. Where Russia has its own technologies and technologies it obtained from Western companies before the sanctions. And of course Western sanctions they impede the development of that kind of technologies and impede Russian plans to develop these areas. But I guess it’s not very smart on the Western part because not only Russia but also Western countries would need the Arctic oil and gas in the future. So why make barriers and obstacles now for what these countries will need, not tomorrow but the other day. So I think that that kind of sanctions in case of the Arctic is quite detrimental not only for Russia but also for the Western countries themselves.
Andreas Raspotnik: Coming to our last question now. Over the last years China has often been depicted as the “hot” new Arctic actor. With regard to the region and keeping in mind both “security” and “business” what is your opinion and assessment on a closer Arctic-relationship between Russia and China?
Alexander Sergunin: Yes, it’s also quite a complex question. As in the case of Arctic oil and gas Russia’s mass media had quite high expectations about the Sino-Russia cooperation in the high north. I myself was quite critical and sceptical about that because actually China has little to offer for Russia in terms of cooperation in the Arctic. China does not have the technology for drilling at big depths and the technology of China is quite backward compared to Western companies and Western industries. So what Russia hopes and hoped that China would provide some investment to the development of the, let’s say, Northern Sea Route and the infrastructure and also to mining in the Arctic – that kind of stuff. But quite recently both Chinese officials and Chinese experts have visited several kinds of seminars and conferences over the last months and they all told that actually China is now quite cautious about the prospects for that kind of cooperation, for many reasons. First of all, because of the drop of the oil price, which actually makes the extraction of oil and gas in the Arctic not profitable; also because of political reasons, plus when it came to the practice it turned out that actually Russian companies, mining companies and oil and gas companies, they are quite reluctant to let Chinese companies in. The most lucrative businesses they want to keep to themselves. Not very welcome to Chinese companies when asking about things to share. So when it comes to practicalities it seems quite difficult to find a common ground for cooperation. So now I guess right we have some kind of shaky moments, as both sides are quite sceptical about those kinds of cooperation. The natural gas deals are not about Arctic gas, they would come from Siberia rather than from the Arctic. I think that both sides have to work slowly, gradually, cautiously and just single out priorities. The most promising is the Northern Sea Route as both Russia and China need that kind of sea route and it could actually be done jointly for the mutual benefit.[i]
Andreas Raspotnik: Dear Alexander, thank you very much for taking the time to highlight some of the most pending questions concerning Russia’s Arctic endeavour. We look very much forward to see you in Bodø.
Alexander Sergunin: Thank you, it’s my pleasure. I am also looking forward to the conference. I think all of us will come there with a lot of ideas, fresh ideas and also very inspiring dialogues, rather than confrontation. This is my hope. Thank you.
Thanks for joining us for this podcast. Follow along with the series on iTunes or via our websites highnorthdialogue.no and thearcticinstitute.org.
The music you’ve heard at the beginning and at the end comes from Hebber Zepherin and can be found at ccmixture.org.



[i] Due to some problems with the recording program, the sound quality of the last sentence is considerably poorer. Sorry!!
























Arctic News: The Arctic This Week February 25

$
0
0



The Arctic This Week February 16 - 22, 2015


1-15270039179_48eedec13e_o.jpg
Photo: Flickr/Visit Greenland

Welcome and thanks for joining us this week! We hope that you find TATW interesting and entertaining to read. If you’re not a subscriber yet, you can sign up here. As always, all editorial choices, opinions and any mistakes are the authors’ own. Anything that we missed? Please feel free to share material with us if you think it deserves inclusion in TATW.

THIS WEEK’S TOP STORIES
New US Arctic drilling regs to require backup rig

New regulations were released by the Obama administration this week to guide oil and gas exploration in the US Arctic. The new regulations will require detailed, Arctic specific drilling plans, including a 24 hour blow-out response capability and, controversially, the presence of a back-up rig that can drill a relief well in the event of an accident (Guardian). The plan is already stirring controversy on all sides of the Arctic oil debate. Oil and gas drillers have questioned the need for a back-up rig, a contingency that Shell has said would cost up to USD 250 million a year, when other, equally effective options exist (The Hill). The American Petroleum Institute, an industry trade association, stated it would carefully review the new regulations and emphasized its position that Arctic oil and gas is a key component of the US’s energy future (Press Release). The National Offshore Industries Association (NOIA) also said it would review the new regulations, but cautioned against the chilling effect the new regulations may have on Arctic energy investment (Press Release). While environmental groups have welcomed what they see as tighter rules for Arctic drilling, some expressed concerns that the new regulations don’t go far enough (Think Progress).

Alaska tops Gallup’s Index of Well-Being

Alaska took the top spot among US states in Gallup’s latest Index of Well-Being survey (APM). Alaska scored particularly high in the ‘Purpose’ and ‘Physical’ categories. It’s the first year that Alaska has earned the number one ranking in the survey, which that has been conducted annually since 2008. However, the state did finish in the top-5 in 2009, 2010, and 2011, though in last year’s ranking it came in at number 15 (AJ).

Alaska’s 2014 mining production valued at over USD 3 billion

For the fifth consecutive year, Alaska’s mineral production value is estimated to be over USD 3 billion. The state’s 2014 figures have been bolstered by high zinc prices and strong output at Red Dog Mine. Zinc, lead, and silver production increased statewide, gold production fell slightly, and zinc alone made up for approximately 42 percent of the state’s mineral production value in 2014. With an estimated total mineral production value of USD 3.3-3.5 billion, Alaska was the seventh-largest mineral producing state in the US in 2014 (PN).

Drones for science
Earlier this month, the U.S. Navy’s research office presented several gadgets, among others a robotic seaglider to study the development of ice on the Arctic Ocean. The Navy is currently testing its equipment and conducting research on polar areas. With little experience in cold temperatures so far, the Navy hopes to be ready to operate in the Arctic region by the year 2030 (Red Orbit).

Arctic marine emissions are likely to increase dramatically
Alyson Azzara, co-author of astudy for the International Council on Clean Transportation, estimates that ship emissions could increase by 600% over the next decade in the Western Arctic alone. The pollutants, namely carbon dioxide, sulphur dioxide, which contributes to acid rain, fine particles, and black carbon are significant drivers of climate change and snow and ice melt. The increase in emissions also has severe health implications. A maritime standard for cleaner fuel, as discussed by the IMO, would help alleviate the impact (CBC).


THE POLITICAL SCENE

United States
Alaska Politicians Take Obama Administration to Task

Alaska Congressman Don Young “called into question the Obama Administration’s many actions and proposals that take away the rights of Alaskans to responsibly develop their land for social and economic well-being, as written in the Alaska Native Settlement Claims Act” in an address to the Alaska Federation of Natives Board Retreat (ANN). Similarly, “Alaska legislators left Kotzebue unsatisfied after a Feb. 16 meeting with Interior Secretary Sally Jewell,” during which many took issue with President Obama’s recent decision to limit oil and natural gas drilling in Alaska (AJ). Meanwhile, during an address to the Alaska Legislature in Juneau, Senator Lisa Murkowski accused the Obama administration of using the wilderness designation of ANWR to try and “starve the trans-Alaska Pipeline of new oil” (KDLG).

Russia
Canada
Europe

ENERGY
Rosneft seeks to postpone Arctic projects
In another sign that Western sanctions are having a significant impact on the development of Russia’s Arctic oil reserves, Rosneft this week sought permission from regulators to postpone exploration activities on 12 of its Arctic licenses (BO). Rosneft is seeking the postponement as sanctions have made it increasingly difficult for the company to secure the necessary investments to move the projects forward. And Rosneft is not alone: several other companies including Gazprom Neft, Surgutneftegaz, Bashneft and Tatneft are also seeking relief from license obligations in the Russian Arctic (EOTA). Sanctions are also taking a bite out of Russia’s oil production across the board. The International Energy Agency reported this week that Russia’s output could fall by 560,000 barrels a day by 2020 due to the combination of falling prices and difficulties accessing financing and technology due to sanctions (MT). And while China can help fill the financing gap, it is unlikely that the country can fill the technology gap needed to help develop unconventional resources in Russia (The Diplomat).

Norway

Sweden

More wind for Västerbotten (BO).


Canada
Well worth a read this week is an article by Meg Sherval titled “Canada's oil sands: The mark of a new ‘oil age’ or a potential threat to Arctic security?” The article, which appears in the latest edition of The Extractive Industries and Society, explores Canada’s oil sands through the lens of both resource scarcity and Canadian Arctic sovereignty.

Russia

Alaska
SCIENCE, ENVIRONMENT AND WILDLIFE

Norilsk, the Arctic industry, and the framing of climate change
Mia Bennett writes about the “company town” of Norilsk Nickel in the Russian Arctic and the different ways of framing climate change. Through the city of Norilsk, which she sees as a prime example of the Anthropocene, she illustrates the Arctic industrial-urbanization complex (AD).

Polar Seas Portal being set up
Neill Conroy, Managing Director and Editor of the forthcoming Polar Seas Portal, presents his project, which is intended to provide comprehensive information on shipping in polar waters (MarEx).

Climate, weather and geology
Seismic activity in Iceland:Seismic activity at similar levels (Bárðarbunga) (mbl),The eruption could soon be over (Holuhraun) (mbl).
Climate Changed (Arctic News).

Wildlife and ecology
Environmental management
Research and university news
MILITARY / SEARCH & RESCUE
United States
Russia
Pugwash Conferences, a Geneva-based think-tank, has called upon the public to lobby their respective governments to de-militarize the Arctic (AJ).
Europe

MINING
Swedish iron producer LKAB cuts budget, personnel

Due to falling iron prices and declining profit margins, Sweden’s leading iron producer Luossavaara-Kiirunavaara Aktiebolag (LKAB) has been forced to cut costs and layoff employees. LKAB, which reported a 93 percent decrease in profits in 2014, announced that it will reduce its budget by approximately USD 83 million and layoff 400 people. The sharp drop in the price of iron, which began in late 2014 and is expected to continue, has severely impacted iron mines across northern Scandinavia (BO).

A preliminary study conducted by the NWT Geoscience Office indicates that there is strong gold, tungsten tin, lead and zinc production potential in the Flat River valley area southwest of Nahanni National Park Reserve (NJ).
Barents Observer takes a look at how the world’s leading nickel producer, Norilsk Nickel, has stayed profitable despite a worldwide drop in nickel prices and a decline in production. The answer? The weak value of the Russian ruble (BO).

FISHERIES, SHIPPING AND OTHER BUSINESS NEWS

6th Arctic Business Forum – Rovaniemi, March 10th to 12th
Business community perspectives to the changes in the Arctic needed: Arctic Business Forum, March 12th (University of Lapland).
Fisheries
Shipping
Tourism
Other business and economic news
General Arctic
Canada and U.S.
The Path to the Arctic (Newfoundland and Labrador) (Marine Technology News).
Russia
Europe & Iceland
Haarde authorised the emergency loan (Kaupthing Bank) (Iceland) (mbl).
Greenland
HEALTH, YOUTH, SOCIETY AND CULTURE
Canadian Arctic scores poorly on Arctic Human Development Report

Canada’s Arctic region received mediocre grades in the newly-released Arctic Human Development Report. The study compares human development statistics across the Arctic regions of Canada, the United States, Russia, Greenland, Iceland, Scandinavia, and the Faroe Islands. The Canadian Arctic only received middling scores for health categories such as infant mortality rates and homicide rates, largely due to poor health indicators among the country’s indigenous population (EOTA). However, the Canadian Arctic did lead the survey in the innovative governance category (CBC).

Alaskan Brent Sass wins Yukon Quest sled dog race

American musher Brent Sass won the Yukon Quest long distance sled dog race in Fairbanks, Alaska with an official time of nine days, 12 hours, and 49 minutes (YN). Sass, who was the first competitor to wear a helmet in the 31-year history of the race after suffering a concussion in last year’s event, won in a close sprint to the finish line (CBC). Fellow Alaskan and last year’s winner Allen Moore finished in second place while Canadian Ed Hopkins placed third and rookie Canadian musher Damon Tedford finished fourth (CBC).

Details released regarding planned Arctic yacht race

Organizers of the Sailing The Arctic Race (STAR) have announced details regarding the planned trans-Arctic yacht race. The sail-powered race, which involves six separate legs, is tentatively scheduled to begin in New York City in July 2017, continue across the Arctic via the Northwest Passage, and conclude in Victoria, Canada (Sailing Scuttlebutt).

Health
A study conducted by the University of Alaska indicates that over 50 percent of women in the Nome, Alaska census area have reported being a victim of sexual violence or abuse (ADN).
Discussions over a Medicaid expansion plan in Alaska have kicked off in Juneau and the debate is expected to be fierce (AJC, NM).
The Yukon Council on Disability in Whitehorse, which helps individuals with mental and physical disabilities find employment, is expected to close due to a lack of government funding (CBC, YN).

Youth
Aurora College in NWT has announced that it will begin teaching all business administration courses via videoconferencing starting in September 2015 (CBC).
Governor General praises Nunavut teachers for their work (NN).

Society
According the NWT’s Housing Minister, a program intended to help subsidize housing costs for low-income individuals is being underused (CBC).

Culture
Welcome to the Russian Arctic village of Teriberka, the real-life setting for the Oscar-nominated film Leviathan (The Telegraph).
Iceland held its version of the Oscars, the Edda Awards, and the film Vonarstræti was the big winner, taking home awards for best film, best mu­si­cal score, best ac­tress in a leading role, best ac­tor in a lead­ing role, and best cos­tume de­sign (mbl).


INFRASTRUCTURE
Canada
United States
Europe

Abbreviation Key
Aboriginal Peoples Television Network (APTN)
Aftenbladet (AB)
Alaska Business Monthly (ABM)
Alaska Dispatch (AD)
Alaska Highway News (AHN)
Alaska Journal of Commerce (AJC)
Alaska Native News (ANN)
Alaska Public Media (APM)
Anchorage Daily News (ADN)
Arctic Info (Russian) (AIR)
Arctic Institute (TAI)
Barents Nova (BN)
Barents Observer (BO)
Bristol Bay Times (BBT)
BusinessWeek (BW)
Canadian Mining Journal (CMJ)
Christian Science Monitor (CSM)
Eye on the Arctic (EOTA)
Fairbanks Daily News-Miner (FNM)
Financial Times (FT)
Globe and Mail (G&M)
Government of Canada (GOC)
Government of the Northwest Territories (GNWT)
Huffington Post (HP)
Indian Country Today Media Network (ICTMN)
Johnson’s Russia List (JRL)
Kalaallit Nunaata Radioa (KNR)
Lapin Kansa (LK)
Moscow Times (MT)
National Geographic (NG)
Natural Gas Europe (NGE)
Naval Today (NT)
New York Times (NYT)
Northern Journal (NJ)
Northern News Service Online (NNSO)
Northern Public Affairs (NPA)
Norwegian Polar Institute (NPI)
Nunatsiaq News (NN)
Oil & Gas Journal (OGJ)
Ottawa Citizen (OC)
Petroleum News (PN)
RIA Novosti (RIAN)
Russia Beyond the Headlines (RBTH)
Russia Today (RT)
Voice of Russia (VOR)
Wall Street Journal (WSJ)
Washington Post (WP)
Whitehorse Star (WS)
Winnipeg Free Press (WFP)
Yukon News (YN)




The Arctic Melt: Turning Resource Development Into Human Development Part 2

$
0
0


The Arctic Melt: Turning Resource Development into Human Development
Victoria Herrmann, February 26, 2015

1-Brooks_Range_Mountains_ANWR-001.jpgPhoto: US Fish and Wildlife Service

The Arctic Melt is a three-part analysis of the Arctic Human Development Report II: Regional Processes and Global Linkages. Developed over a ten-year period, the study assesses the state of Arctic human development and highlights major regional changes. Its findings will be important in informing the decisions and policies of the upcoming US Arctic Council Chairmanship.

In the context of Alaska, this series will take an in-depth look at three of the key trends underscored by the Report: globalization, urbanization, and demographic shifts. On Monday, Part I: Investing in Place will explore how we create livable, localized places in a globalized north. On Wednesday, Part II: Investing in Innovation will consider the opportunities of urbanization for entrepreneurship and economic ingenuity. On Friday, Part III: Investing in Communities will conclude the discussion by looking at ways to sustainably connect the growing young and old sectors of Alaska’s population.

Taken together, these three trends provide a chance to redefine how we conceptualize, and realize, Arctic investment – a chance to turn economic growth into human development.   

Part II: Investing In Innovation

Last month, President Obama announced that he would ask Congress to ban drilling on 12 million acres of the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge in Alaska. [1] While environmentalists applauded his efforts, the ban was met with fierce opposition from a number of politicians. Alaskan Senator Lisa Murkowski called it “a stunning attack on our sovereignty and our ability to develop a strong economy that allows us, our children and our grandchildren to thrive.” [2]
Despite such outcries, President Obama’s proposal to explore options for economic development beyond oil drilling may be protecting Alaska’s economy as much as its environment.  
The second Arctic Human Development Report, released last week, concludes that prohibitively high costs of doing business in the north will persist long into the 21st Century in spite of high expectations for a climate-induced resource rush. [3] The net costs of climate change, combined with the volatility of commodity prices, will continue to push investments down in Alaska’s already declining petroleum production.
Major commercial conditions such as an uncertain future for Arctic oil is important to northern human development, as economic activities define the material well being of the region’s residents. With the prospects of expanding petroleum markets proving overly optimistic, President Obama’s drilling ban provides an opportunity to move Alaska’s economy beyond that of extractive industries and towards investing in human development through a knowledge economy with significant investment in human development..
Restructuring the state’s economy from resource-focused to human-centered means investing in institutional and physical infrastructure that will best serve current and future Alaskans. Architects of a new economic framework must be conscious of Alaska’s development history, able to build within the major overarching trends of change today, and mindful of the Arctic climate’s future shifts. Informed by an understanding of its past, present, and projected future, Alaska has the tools to make sound, sustainable economic decisions and the means to redirect investment towards local innovation.             
The Arctic, an Economic History
Ten years ago, the first Arctic Human Development Report noted that the circumpolar north was a natural resource reservoir that could quench the world’s energy and mineral appetite. It also highlighted the trend in Alaskan history of petroleum dominating both economic activity and state investment, thought it noted that there was a recent reduction in the role of government and federal subsidies to support extractive activities. [4] While the report touched on the beginnings of privatization and diversification of the local economy, citing new power in companies and new activities like tourism as major changes, the first report’s economic analysis in 2004 relied substantially on evaluating resource markets and effects.  
Today, both of those original statements, the Arctic as an energy reserve and as a resource-dominated economy, still hold true. A recent USGS survey estimates that the Arctic holds almost a quarter of the world’s undiscovered conventional oil and gas. [5] Unsurprisingly, Alaska’s economy is still deeply entrenched in its extractive legacies. The intermediary decade between the first and second Human Development Report saw the invention of a number of new technologies and processes to increase oil production, resulting in a dramatic expansion in the Arctic regional economy. Between 2000 and 2010, the Arctic’s regional growth far exceeded that of the eight individual Arctic nations. Its economic output, 0.6 percent of world GDP, was four times its share of the population, and at 442.8 Billion USD, the Arctic Gross Regional Product was equal to the entire national economies of Malaysia and Columbia in 2010. [6]
Some financial forecasters, particularly those cited by mass media outlets, are optimistic that high growth rates will climb even higher from the economic benefits of climate change. Throughout its globalized modern history, the biggest challenges of doing business in the Arctic have always been the region’s harsh climate and the remoteness of resource deposits from centers of consumption, production, and decision-making. The price of researching and developing cold-weather equipment and the increased costs of shipping out products and bringing in material, labor, and other resources to production sites all add to the high cost and debatable viability of doing business in the high north when compared with more temperate sites.
Climate change has the potential to change those environmental conditions once thought of as fixed. Warmer air and water are prolonging the ice-free travel period in Arctic seas, improving access and lowering costs of delivering supplies and bringing products to international markets. Warmer temperatures also mean that there is a reduced need to invest new technologies to withstand extreme conditions.
Despite optimistic business reports and news stories based on a resource rush narrative, climate change is a net cost to both those who live in and those who extract resources from the Arctic. [7] The future of an ecologically changing Arctic is uncertain. Increasing storm surges, shoreline erosion, and thawing permafrost are all challenges to existing and forthcoming industry infrastructure.

2-Prudhoe_Bay_oil_fields_1971_FWS.jpgPhoto: US Fish and Wildlife Service
But perhaps more worrisome than the impacts of climate change is Alaska’s challenge of a maturing resource economy as petroleum production is in decline. Oil production in Alaska peaked more than two decades ago, and although new fields and new production technology have slowed the decline production continues to fall. [8] With new unconventional and shale reserves being tapped in more environmentally hospitable places like North Dakota and southern Canada, world energy demands can be met without drilling in America’s circumpolar north.    
Oil revenue has significantly contributed to Alaska’s revenues, employment rate, and ability to provide welfare services from taxes since the onset of its production at Prudhoe Bay in 1977. Today it accounts for ninety percent of the state’s revenue, and it is estimated that direct activity in the oil industry and the effects of the state’s spending on oil account for one-third of Alaskan jobs. [9]
Reliance on oil for financial and human well being pose a major challenge for Alaska, but also an opportunity to rethink how it invests for an economically sustainable future. Although a number of state savings funds, of which Alaska’s Permanent Fund is the largest, will soften the effects of the petroleum decline, Alaska needs a new, more resilient economy for the 21st Century. Other natural resource industries in the state are too small to fill the gap left by petroleum – giving Alaska the chance to think beyond resource-generated wellbeing.
Globalization and Urbanization: A Framework for Innovative Growth
A new economic structure must be built in the context of the major, overarching trends identified by the Arctic Human Development Report – namely globalization and urbanization. Taken together, globalization and urbanization in Alaska provide not just the context for redefining investment; each trend provides valuable conditions to foster an economy built on sustainable innovation and resilient entrepreneurship.
Part I of this series explored the challenges and opportunities of globalization for Alaskan physical infrastructure investment, focusing on the use of smart growth principles to invest in place. Similar changes spurred by globalization also help to create an ideal environment for an innovative economy. The decentralization of political power and the increased local control and ownership of local economic resources allow more opportunities for officials to work with local stakeholders and choose investment in innovation over extraction. Globalization has also provided important access to global communication and information sharing systems, making it easier for small business to access international markets and for entrepreneurs to exchange best practices to support local development.
Investing in place through smart growth, as advocated in Part I, helps to create an ideal built environment for creating a knowledge economy and fostering economic prosperity. By planning and building smarter, municipalities can reduce the cost of water and energy infrastructure and that of transportation maintenance. Smart growth is also proven to benefit household budgets by increasing property values, reducing transportation costs, and building affordable places to live that are interdependent parts of a strong, regional economy. Local business that are an integral part of the overall regional economy likewise benefit from Complete Streets. Investing in walkable downtowns and robust public transportation systems increases foot travel for local buyers and helps attract and maintain talented, long-term workers. [10]  
As most smart growth occurs in cities, it is conducive that urbanization in the Arctic is rapidly accelerating. Over the past decade, urbanization has had just as an intense an impact on human development as has globalization. Despite the Arctic visual narrative of barren white icescapes, more than half of Alaskan residents now live in cities. Outmigration from rural communities towards more densely populated areas, net flows of immigration to the Arctic, and the emergence of “climigration” have all contributed to not only the magnitude and complexity of urbanization itself, but also the multifaceted challenges to human development in the Arctic.
In 1920, only 6 percent of Alaska’s population resided in urban areas. Today, that number is 66 percent, with 49 percent of all Alaskan Natives living in the five most-populous boroughs. While this is still far below the level of urbanization for the entire country, which currently stands at 82.4 percent, Alaska is unique in that 55 percent of the state population resides in just two cities – Fairbanks and Anchorage. [11]

3-Anchorage_Alaska_aerial_view.jpg
Photo: US Army Corps of Engineers
Like globalization, urbanization brings with it important political and social transformations that provide key underpinnings for innovation and entrepreneurship. Globally, economic activity is intensely concentrated in urban areas. While urban areas account for only 2 percent of the earth’s landmass, they are the source of the vast majority of global gross domestic product (GDP). [12] Cities also provide a unique environment for developing adaptive economic growth policy. Unlike national governments, which often split economic policy-making authority among several branches of government, city leaders often have both centralized executive power to act within their jurisdictions and some access to policy instruments needed to foster innovation and business in their cities. City mayors have a variety of economic tools to support creative industries, stimulate investment in local ventures, create a knowledgeable workforce, and ensure workers well being through public services.
In addition, because of more flexible governance structures, city leaders who confront budget and funding constraints, which are all too likely to persist in the coming decades, have the leeway to come up with creative responses. Creativity arises out of the municipal government’s ability to champion change, engage the public more quickly, enact legislation, implement new programs, or create partnerships in shorter time frames and in more targeted ways. By contrast, financing proposals hatched by national governments, even sound ones, can be more easily hampered by politics and require a much longer time frame to build the bipartisan support necessary for passage. Cities, as nodes of opportunity and economic productivity, contain an added layer of diverse cultural capital creation, which is desired by a growing class of skilled workers.
The trends of globalization and urbanization form an ideal frame within which economic innovation can occur. However, in order to use this frame effectively for local economic prosperity, Alaska must nurture and educate a skilled population that can create, share, and use knowledge; build economic and institutional regimes that provide incentives for investing in entrepreneurship; and advance an innovative system of firms, research centers, and other organizations that can facilitate the effective dissemination of best practices, tap into the global supply of knowledge, and adapt it to the Arctic.
Unlocking Entrepreneurship through Soft Infrastructure
A knowledgeable and skilled workforce is the foundation of creating a strong local economy in Alaska. As education is a central pillar for both sustainable economic development and creating a sense of place and community, the last installment of the series, Part III: Investing in Communities, will focus exclusively on education. Part III will bring Parts I and II together through a discussion of integrating schools into a knowledge-based economy and smart neighborhood design.
Beyond educated workers, Alaska must invest in regimes that provide incentives for entrepreneurship and the efficient use of existing and new knowledge. Creating a strong reputation for commitment to investment in research development, creativity, and design is one layer of such a system. This could be achieved through local innovation grants, business tax benefits, and providing funding for fixed capital that benefits a knowledge-based, localized economy instead of infrastructure that support multinational extractive industries.  
Alaska must finally create and support institutions that will create, exchange, and communicate new ideas effectively. Firms cluster in cities, creating an agglomeration effect that facilitates the spillover of knowledge between firms within and between sectors and reduces friction in matching labor market supply and demand. [13] The cross-pollination of knowledge between sectors translates into more opportunities to build knowledge capital. A result is that more innovation per capita is generated in metropolitan regions. Cities by their very nature provide agglomeration benefits and proximity that caters to the process of invention. Inventors thrive in places that can act as testing grounds for their experiments. Proximity offers a short feedback loop between inventor, competition, the market, and peers, and allows for rapid iteration and improvement.
The existence of Silicon Valley in the San Francisco Bay Area, the Raleigh-Durham-Chapel Hill research triangle in North Carolina, and the start-up technology and university community in Boston-Cambridge in Massachusetts illustrate the agglomeration effect and its positive impact on innovation. In January Norway’s Minister of Foreign Affairs Børge Brende spoke about transforming the Norwegian Arctic into a “mini Silicon Valley.” [14] He described a high north where the local economy was driven by invention and entrepreneurial initiative – an economy driven by human capital.
To help make this a reality, Norway has both Innovation Norway, a government initiative to support the development of local business, and Arctic Innovation Group, a team of investors that provide seed money for sustainable and profitable technology companies in Norway’s Arctic. [15] Both have helped many small-scale entrepreneurial goods and services reach world markets and have contributed to improving Arctic standards of living. The programs give broad business support, financial provisions, and networking services to small enterprises.
Building the soft infrastructure like Innovation Norway and the Arctic Innovation Group could give urban Alaskans an opportunity to capitalize on their cities’ assets and build their own local entrepreneurial economy. The program could provide strategic assistance and start-up financial support to Alaskans in the production of northern goods and services, partnered with successful American companies across the nation.

4-Downtown_Juneau_with_Mount_Juneau_rising_in_the_background.jpgPhoto: Alan Wu
Cities also provide an ideal testing ground for new technologies developed there. Electric vehicles are one such technology that benefit from urban testing. Former Los Angeles Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa is aiming to turn his city into the “electric car capital of the world” with 80,000 EVs by 2015. [16] Charging stations have become commonplace at airports, businesses, freeway rest stops, and big-city parking garages, which total just over 1,800 statewide, or 21.6 percent of those in use across the United States. Free parking, access to restricted lanes, discounted tolls, and purchase subsidies are all successfully being pursued in cities pushing for more electric vehicle use.   
While not as large as Los Angeles’ pilot program, electric vehicles are not only being tested, but are also being adapted by entrepreneurial northerners who are making them efficiently and economically cold-climate friendly. With over half of the state’s population living in Fairbanks and Anchorage, these two urban areas provide an ideal setting to collect necessary baseline data on the local economic and demographic needs and to implement other small-scale programs that adapt successful design from the continental US to the Arctic region. By supporting initiatives to test northern innovation in Alaskan cities, policymakers can help to make a mini Silicon Valley in America’s Arctic too.

A Kick in the Gut to Kickstart Alaska’s Economy
In the European Arctic, natural resource sector industries are responsible for less than twenty percent of economic output. This compares to more than sixty-three percent in the North American Arctic. [17] While homegrown innovation drives Nordic economies, the economy of the North American circumpolar region still relies heavily on extractive, multinational industries. Unlike local knowledge based economies that both profit from and create local human capital, large-scale resource production often brings the necessary capital, technological expertise, and labor from outside the region. This means that much of the income generated by resource projects ultimately leaves the local economy, undermining the substrata of human development.     
The decline in petroleum production and net costs of climate change provides the chance to sustainably reinvent Alaska’s economy.
Alaska must begin to invest in the commercialization of ideas in preparation for the not so distant future when resources can no longer support the wellbeing of its residents. Taking advantage of the political, economic, and social benefits of urbanization and globalization by investing in hard and soft infrastructure could spur more local economic innovation and augment the non-resource sectors of Alaska’s economy.
But beyond building infrastructure, Alaska’s economy today requires a new way of thinking about the challenges and social needs of a globalized Arctic population. The relationship between the globalized cities in which people live and the economic policies that govern their well being must be rethought to highlight the mutual returns of their connection. The uncertainty of commodity prices, the net cost of climate change to resource development in the north, and the US chairmanship together provide the chance to change how planners and citizens alike think about local infrastructure projects, welfare policies, and the Arctic economy.
In response to President Obama’s wildlife protection proposal, Senator Murkowski pledged that Alaska “will fight back with every resource at our disposal.” [18] While the National Wildlife Refuge is projected to hold large petroleum reserves, the new Arctic Human Development Report makes it clear that there will be no 21st Century resource rush for Alaska.
Instead of seeing President Obama as an opponent, Alaska should see him as a partner in using the US Arctic Council Chairmanship to develop a strong, northern economy that capitalizes on urban innovation and local design. By investing in the infrastructure needed to support a non-resource economy – by investing in local innovation instead of extractive industry – Obama’s environmental protection is not “a kick in the gut to Alaska’s economy.” It is an opportunity to rethink northern economic investment to allow Alaska to thrive for generations to come.         

[2] Idib.
[3] Lee Husky, Ilmo Mӓenpӓӓ, and Alexander Pelyasov. “Chapter 4 Economic Systems,” Arctic Human Development Report: Regional Processes and Global Linkages. Edited by Yoan Nymand Larsen and Gail Fondahl.
[4] Idib.
[5] P. Budzik, http://www.eia.gov/oiaf/analysispaper/arctic/pdf/arctic_oil.pdf (24 February 2014).
[6] Lee Husky, Ilmo Mӓenpӓӓ, and Alexander Pelyasov. “Chapter 4 Economic Systems,” Arctic Human Development Report: Regional Processes and Global Linkages. Edited by Yoan Nymand Larsen and Gail Fondahl.
[7] Idib.
[8] Idib.
[9] Idib
[11] Timothy Heleniak. “Chapter 2 Arctic Populations and Migration,” Arctic Human Development Report: Regional Processes and Global Linkages. Edited by Yoan Nymand Larsen and Gail Fondahl.
[13] Batten, D.F., 1995. Network Cities: Creative Urban Agglomeration for the 21st Century. Urban Studies, Vol. 32 (No. 2), 313-327.
[15] Innovation Norway,http://www.innovasjonnorge.no/no/english/ and Arctic Innovation Group,http://arcticinnovationgroup.com
[17] Timothy Heleniak. “Chapter 2 Arctic Populations and Migration,” Arctic Human Development Report: Regional Processes and Global Linkages. Edited by Yoan Nymand Larsen and Gail Fondahl.










The Arctic Melt: Turning Resource Development into Human Development

$
0
0


The Arctic Melt: Turning Resource Development into Human Development
Victoria Herrmann, February 26, 2015

1-North_Pole_Alaska_High_School.jpg
Photo: RadioKAOS

The Arctic Melt is a three-part analysis of the Arctic Human Development Report II: Regional Processes and Global Linkages. Developed over a ten-year period, the study assesses the state of Arctic human development and highlights major regional changes. Its findings will be important in informing the decisions and policies of the upcoming US Arctic Council Chairmanship.

In the context of Alaska, this series will take an in-depth look at three of the key trends underscored by the Report: globalization, urbanization, and demographic shifts. On Monday, Part I: Investing in Place will explore how we create livable, localized places in a globalized north. On Wednesday, Part II: Investing in Innovation will consider the opportunities of urbanization for entrepreneurship and economic ingenuity. On Friday, Part III: Investing in Communities will conclude the discussion by looking at ways to sustainably connect the growing young and old sectors of Alaska’s population.

Taken together, these three trends provide a chance to redefine how we conceptualize, and realize, Arctic investment – a chance to turn economic growth into human development.   

Part III: Investing In Community
The population of Alaska is projected to increase by 28 percent to 915,211 by 2035, nearly double the national population growth rate for the United States in the same period. [1] With lower infant mortality rates and better medical treatment for the elderly, the two biggest demographics poised to grow are the youngest and oldest sectors of Alaskan society.
And yet, through institutionalized social practices, young and old are isolated from one another now more than ever. By channeling youth into schools and expecting seniors to live a secluded home life or age-homogeneous retirement communities, these separate islands of activity have eroded the social support networks that once connected one generation to the next. This is exceptionally true for the Alaskan Native population, 39 percent of which are under the age of 20. The generational exchange of traditional knowledge in these communities is fundamental to culture and wellbeing. [2] More generally, age-segregated strata create an environment that supports age discrimination, reinforces negative stereotypes, and eliminates opportunities for intergenerational understanding and dialogue.
The connections between one generation and the next are not only culturally important, but also economically. The intergenerational contract preserved in Alaska’s economy today is one that favors the old at the expense of the young. As baby boomers live longer, there will be more older, non-working residents relying on the safety net, resulting in higher costs for social security, Medicare, and other programs. [3] With current tax revenues insufficient to cover rising expenses, particularly in light of falling oil prices, the younger generation will be fraught with taking fiscal care of their elders.
Such budgetary deficiencies come at a time when crucial components of Alaska youth’s development are under threat. The public education system is outdated, founded on inefficient funding models, and fail to take into account the varied factors that affect a student’s ability to perform well. This results in some of the highest high school dropout rates in both the United States and across the Arctic region. [4] Beyond education, childhood health is declining in the face of a rising obesity epidemic and increased mental health concerns. Free play, vital to the development of young minds, is stifled by limited public spaces. Without the support to develop active, educated, healthy children, Alaska will lack the human capital for the innovation-based economy advocated for in Part II of this series.

As Alaska’s demographic shift deepens age segregation and accelerates the proliferation of interconnected, complex social issues, there is an immediate need to address the disengagement of generations in order to establish a foundation of trust and understanding upon which both the places in Part I and the economy in Part II are built.
A solution might come from the already successful school designs implemented across the country that have demonstrated an innovative way to connect the common needs of elderly and youth. Complete school buildings that reconceptualize the relationship between education infrastructure and age inclusivity can equip northern youth with the knowledge of their elders to make investments in human development long into Alaska’s future.

Rethinking Investment for a Demographic Shift

The realities of the globalization, urbanization, and demographic shifts the Arctic currently faces require problems to be evaluated holistically, examining interrelated issues from varied sectors at different scales. Part I of this series, Investing in Place, argued for building physical infrastructure to create sustainable and enjoyable places to live in the north that capitalized on globalization while serving Alaskans and their local economy. Investing in Innovation, Part II, supported the transition of Alaska’s economy from resource development to knowledge-based built upon the benefits of Arctic urbanization. But while complete streets, smart growth, and entrepreneurial institutions create the necessary physical infrastructure and innovative climate to foster sustainable business and livable spaces, there is still a need to invest in the communities that not only inhabit Alaska’s economic and built environments, but also make them thrive.
Building a sense of community in cold places often happens indoors in shared, public spaces. Many architectural firms creating concept designs for relocated Arctic towns focus on building community through stylish public areas and green spaces, like the new town plan for the Swedish mining town Kiruna in Part I. While these inventive designs are important in their own right, many Arctic communities and cities cannot afford investing in entirely new community centers – especially in a time of uncertain natural resource production. Revamping already established public schools is one example of a more practical and economical, though still innovative, approach for Alaska to invest in communities.
Traditionally, schools are seen as a place for one section of the population – youth and those who formally teach them. But school buildings offer an opportunity to bring the sense of community built in the streets in Part I indoors during Alaska’s long winter months while simultaneously nurturing the education and creativity needed for the economy in Part II. Complete schools promote social cohesion; create more opportunities for intergenerational interactions; foster healthier living environments with localized safety nets; and strengthen support system for the development of students. Investing in communities through these education designs can improve Alaska’s wellbeing during a period of intense economic, social, and demographic change.  
Education and Alaska’s Build Environment 
Since the last Development Report in 2004, secondary education attainment has increased in all Arctic regions except Alaska. Only 68 percent of student in Alaska graduate high school, compared to the American national average of 81 percent. For Native Alaskans, that rate drops to only 42.5 percent. [5]  
There are a number of causes associated with high dropout rates. These include but are not limited to the need to babysit/lack of daycare, help (including financially and taking care of the elderly) around the home, and substance abuse. Cultural discontinuity, school culture, and parental attitudes towards formal education are also important factors. [6]      

2-Barrow_High_School_2007-12-08.jpg
Photo: Floyd Davidson
While there have been efforts to change education curriculum to better suit the needs of northern communities, particularly the inclusion of Northern culture and traditional knowledge, these changes fail to recognize the intergenerational challenges of the problem in meeting not just the needs of students, but of those younger and older family members for which they must care. Improvement programs have heavily focused on education policy and curriculum development, overlooking the connection to community needed to support students outside the classroom and the built environment in which children learn.    
There is a growing body of research that supports the connection between high-performing education and designing schools as centers of complete communities. While community-based design principles for school buildings have been adopted in state education departments and city school boards in the lower 48, their application to Arctic communities has not yet been explored. Despite this dearth in research, connecting education policy to school design could not only reduce dropout rates, but also produce co-benefits for traditional knowledge transfer, social cohesion, unemployment, and climate resiliency.  
Creating Schools as Inclusive Community Centers
At their most basic level, school designs should include universal access and promote a healthy indoor environment for elders and children, paying close attention to lighting and air quality. Community school buildings should consider traffic patterns and adopt wider hallways, doors, and lighting principles that can positively affect student behavior and attitudes towards learning while diminishing potential areas for bullying and violence. [7]    
All stakeholders, not just school board officials and contractors, should be included in the process of designing so that it fits the community’s needs. By investing in an attractive, well-designed and well-maintained center for the whole community, schools can become a place to facilitate respect, communication, and knowledge transfer between different generations.

In Gaylord Michigan, seniors have access to school gyms, health facilities, and cultural and recreational activities held in classrooms and auditoriums. Gaylord High School in Gaylord, Michigan was built as a community center as well as a secondary education institution. It includes day care facilities, senior activities, and a community health care clinic to cater to young, old, and those in between. Classrooms were designed with the community in mind, creating multipurpose, flexible spaces with accessibility outside of regular school hours and the ability to adapt to new needs of future community members. [8]  

High dropout rates often act as a problem-multiplier to other socio-economic concerns in the North. High suicide rates, unemployment, substance abuse, and intergenerational estrangement are all augmented by low graduation rates. Stunted traditional and formal education also acts as a threat-multiplier for climate change. It erodes the social and economic sustainability and capabilities of a community needed to be resilient in the face of ecological and climatic shifts.
The ability to transfer knowledge from older to future generations, to belong to a social network, to engage in a mixed economy in order to earn more income, and to actively participate in a healthy, vibrant community to increase longevity are all seriously affected by children not attending school. Building schools like Gaylord’s in Anchorage and Fairbanks that create schools as community centers can help Alaska’s demographic transition while simultaneously creating a more educated, capable workforce.    
But building complete schools do more than foster communities, promote intergenerational respect, and produce an educated workforce; they can also generate co-benefits for Alaskan’s public health, culture, and language preservation.   

Complete School’s Co-benefits to Youth and Elderly Public Health
While the level of public health is immediately the result of access to quality medical facilities and personnel, human well-being is the result of a complex set of interactions among genetic, economic, social, cultural, political, and environmental actors. Consequently, climate change and the major human-centric trends discussed in this series – globalization, urbanization, and demographic shifts – generate the majority of emerging challenges and potential threats for the health of individuals and communities in the Arctic.       

Alaska’s youth and its seniors face a shared public health challenge in the changing diet of Arctic residents. Changes from more traditional foods, based on local hunting and fishing markets, to a western type of diet has steadily increased in both cities and remote rural areas, and have had a particular effect on the health of indigenous communities. [9] Climate change impacts have had a negative effect on the health of animals harvested during fishing and hunting as well as the safety of storing community meat. Concurrently, transport costs for imported food from the lower 48 and Canada have remained high. This results in expensive grocery store produce and products, wherein healthy options from stores are out of reach of many family budgets. The Arctic Human Development Report notes that those Arctic residents who rely mainly on market foods are becoming increasingly dependent on cheaper, unhealthy choices. [10] Less-nutritious diets lead to increasing rates of modern diseases like obesity, diabetes, and cardiovascular disease.

The smart growth principles advocated for in Part I of this series, Investing in Place, can help reduce some of Alaska’s emerging public health threats connected to diet. The risk of cardiovascular diseases, for example, is 11 percent less for those who actively commute, and students who live in walkable neighborhoods have a 59 percent lower chance of being obese. [11] Neighborhood design can strengthen public health policy aimed at reducing obesity by creating safe active transport options. Complete streets, designed to support biking and walking for all ages, and the compact design of smart growth, which makes walking and biking to goods, services, and social opportunities not only viable but pleasant, can provide the daily exercise needed to fight obesity and associated illnesses. Several communities across the country have already adopted or plan to adopt the use of smart streets and smart growth principles to fight childhood obesity, and promote healthy living generally.

Baldwin Park, a majority Latino-city near Los Angeles, used funding from the California Endowment and the Kaiser Permanente Community Health Program to create a program that connected public health policies with transportation infrastructure to combat childhood obesity. [12] Adopted by its City Council in 2011, Baldwin Park is currently implementing one of America’s most comprehensive Complete Street policies to transform five major corridors into safe walking and biking options. Such designs and supportive policies can help to encourage healthier Alaskan communities through its built infrastructure.

3-Airport_and_Gillam_Ways_in_Fairbanks_Alaska.jpg
Photo: RadioKAOS
Walkable design can be augmented with nutritional programming at complete schools to holistically promote healthy living. Including community kitchens, freezers, and gardens in schools can bring communities together to learn how to make wholesome cooking choices. The Council of Yukon First Nations include a number of suggested dietary programs in their Health Promotion Spring School’s report. [13] Providing community workshops on diabetes and grocery store choices, organizing cooking classes where elders teach youth and parents how to prepare nutritious meals, and hosting events that offer healthy food choices or center around garden harvests all bring community members together to support a healthful kitchen at home.  

Many public health reports and policies focus on the younger generation, as they are often perceived as particularly vulnerable and requiring special attending as the pace of Arctic development increases. However, the Human Development Report highlights the greying of the population, the health needs of elderly people, many of whom are retired, to be a major emerging public health challenge. [14] There is much concern associated with the growing strains an aging population will have on the pension and health care system of Alaska – and for good reason. Nationally, the Congressional Budget Office reported that spending for Medicare and Medicaid accounted for 3 percent of GDP in 2009. By 2035, Medicare alone will increase to 8 percent. By 2080, 15. This national trend is mirrored in Alaska. [15]

Aging in place instead of cost-intensive designated elderly or medical homes is one way to alleviate the economic difficulties of a growing older demographic sector while simultaneously promoting a healthier lifestyle for Alaskan elders. The benefits of schools as community centers and smart growth design support aging in place. 78 percent of adults between the ages of 50 and 64 prefer to reside in their current residence as they age rather than move into a retirement community. [16] But aging in place requires built infrastructure, laws, policies, and programs to foster neighborhoods and community centers where residents can live safely, autonomously, and comfortably regardless of age or income. Many communities lack this necessary built and service substructure, forcing older adults to abandon their homes, friends, and communities in favor of assisted living complexes.

Smart growth design provides housing at ground level or with elevators, wide hallways, communal green spaces, shared facilities, and goods and services within short walking or transit distances. To buttress this infrastructure, local programming at complete schools aims to reduce service fragmentation and create greater comfort and security for seniors through voluntary social work, education, socialization, nutrition and fitness programs, and legal advice. The Queens Community House’s Neighborhood Intergenerational Chore and Errand Program connects school youth to seniors through services and social activities, which include shopping, laundry, and cooking, but also more costly needs like transportation and health care management. [17] Such programming helps multigenerational neighborhoods thrive not only as senior-friendly communities, but also as places for young families who provide the labor for neighborhood facilities.

Fostering Safe Spaces to Share, Learn, and Preserve Alaskan Culture
In an age of globalization and urbanization, now more than ever before Alaskans are exposed to and interact with different cultures and identities. Public places act as spaces where cultures are learned, negotiated, and transformed, which then creates the overall socio-economic environments and systems that dictate daily life and adaptation in the Arctic. Schools are perhaps the best example of such spaces of identity interaction. Classrooms have the ability to break barriers of ethnic, class, religious, and gender groups to promote an atmosphere of understanding and learning amongst an increasingly diverse Alaskan youth sector. The design of school buildings and community programs that are inclusive of all members of society provide the tools needed to translate that ability into an actuality.
Alaskan schools have a particular challenge of overcoming a colonial history of discrimination and racism against native peoples, the legacy of which can still be seen and felt today. Including native designs in school buildings that acknowledge the rich Native Alaskan past and aesthetics instead of relying on imported, pre-formulated school plans from the south is one way to be culturally inclusive. Another is through supporting and creating spaces for elders to speak to both native and non-native youth about cultural values and practices. Sharing traditional knowledge and practice is not just a means of communicating individual experience; it is vital in preserving history through memories from different viewpoints, in understanding the human security threats from and adaptations needed for climate change; and in safeguarding a culturally rich future. This also includes the sharing and teaching of native languages. [18] The first Arctic Social Indicators report, a 2010 follow-up study to the original Arctic Human Development Report, identified “language retention” as the single best indicator of cultural vitality. Alaska ranks low in this indicator – all but one Native language had a lower portion of speakers in 2007 than in 1997. [19] The Inuit in the Eastern Canadian Arctic continue to keep native language retention at relatively high levels through the promotion of its use in schools and public programming. Building schools as complete communities that bring multiple generations together provides an opportunity to do the same in Alaska and ensure the survival of native culture.       

4-Elder_native_Alaskan_woman_1979_FWS.jpgPhoto: Jo Keller
In order to generate such health, cultural, economic, and educational benefits simultaneously, designing schools as indoor spaces of complete communities necessitates a multidisciplinary team. Educators, students, elders, public health workers, urban planners, community members, and financiers must work together to make the necessary investments in capital and ingenuity required for the transformation of schools from places of youth education into spaces of holistic human development in the Arctic.

Multigenerational Design for Intergenerational Communities

Today’s generational schism in Alaska requires an inventive solution that facilitates interpersonal trust, educational development, and societal accountability between young and old. The demographic shifts noted by the Development Report demand a new way of thinking that cultivates a lifestyle founded on intergenerational respect and reliability, one that defines and conditions decisions that are mutually beneficial to all generations. Investment in the Arctic for the 21st Century must answer not just the tangible issues at hand, but must also address the deterioration of the very fibers that bind young and old communities together.
Following the smart growth design principles outlined in Part I of this series, establishing schools as centers of complete communities enables safe, equitable, and high-performing education in the north. Richard Rothstein, a top educational researcher, argues that, “two-thirds [of the quality of schools] is attributable to non-school factors.” [20] Such out-of-classroom influences include neighborhood quality and safety, available and affordable transportation options, accessibility of after-school programs, open space, and community. Combining smart growth and complete schools creates the best environment for support youth development and education, which in turn fosters the creative, educated, and locally dedicated workforce necessary for the sustainable economy that was described on Wednesday in Part II: Investing in Innovation.     
Solutions like those advocated in this series that ameliorate several problems concurrently will increasingly become the most efficient and cost-effective norm for fostering more livable communities in an increasingly interconnected Arctic. Multidisciplinary problem solving for how we create places in the North can help to provide the physical environment that would make Alaska’s globalization, urbanization, generational transformations a triumph rather than a terror. By entwining complementary local policy and design that buttress adequate public health, decent public education, an innovative economy, and universal accessibility, Alaska will be better prepared to confront its most immediate challenges to human development.
The future of the north will be determined by the choices of the youth and their aspirations and priorities – where, and what they choose to study, live, and work. Those choices, however, will be shaped by the infrastructure, economy, and society Alaska creates today. Investing in place, in innovation, and in community can provide the opportunities for leaders of today and of tomorrow to make the ultimate investment – that of environmentally sustainable and human-centric development for the Arctic.




[1] Timothy Heleniak. “Chapter 2 Arctic Populations and Migration,” Arctic Human Development Report: Regional Processes and Global Linkages. Edited by Yoan Nymand Larsen and Gail Fondahl.
[2] Idib.
[5] Diane Hirshberg and Angrey N. Petrov. “Chapter 9 Education and Human Capital,” Arctic Human Development Report: Regional Processes and Global Linkages. Edited by Yoan Nymand Larsen and Gail Fondahl.
[6] Melanie O’Gorman and Manish Pandey,http://www.csls.ca/events/cea2014/cea-papers-2014-pandey.pdf
[9] Arja Rautio, Birger Poppel, and Kue Young. “Chapter 8 Human Health and Well-Being,” Arctic Human Development Report: Regional Processes and Global Linkages. Edited by Yoan Nymand Larsen and Gail Fondahl.
[10] Idib.
[14] Arja Rautio, Birger Poppel, and Kue Young. “Chapter 8 Human Health and Well-Being,” Arctic Human Development Report: Regional Processes and Global Linkages. Edited by Yoan Nymand Larsen and Gail Fondahl.
[17] Queens Library,https://qchnyc.wordpress.com
[18] Peter Schweitzer, Peter Sköld, and Olga Ulturgasheva . “Chapter 3 Cultures and Identities,” Arctic Human Development Report: Regional Processes and Global Linkages. Edited by Yoan Nymand Larsen and Gail Fondahl.
[19] Idib.
[20] Richard Rothstein, http://www.epi.org/publication/ib286/















Arctic News: The Arctic This Week March 4

$
0
0



The Arctic This Week February 23 - March 1, 2015


6167391543_395a7cabfd_b copy.jpg
Photo: Flickr/blmiers2

Welcome and thanks for joining us this week! We hope that you find TATW interesting and entertaining to read. If you’re not a subscriber yet, you can sign up here. As always, all editorial choices, opinions and any mistakes are the authors’ own. Anything that we missed? Please feel free to share material with us if you think it deserves inclusion in TATW.

TAI’s RECENT ACTIVITIES

In preparation for the High North Dialogue 2015, TAI’s Andreas Raspotnik spoke to Alexander Sergunin, professor in the Department of International Relations at St. Petersburg State University about the relations between the EU and Russia. Sergunin pointed to the lack of dialogue between Western and Eastern experts, in particular on the Arctic. Listen to the podcast or read the transcripthere (TAI).

Screen Shot 2015-01-21 at 2.53.54 PM.png
THIS WEEK’S TOP STORIES
State plan to purchase Fairbanks Natural Gas raises eyebrows

The latest twist in the story of the State of Alaska’s efforts to deliver affordable natural gas to Fairbanks continues to raise questions amongst the state’s politicians. Newly-elected and politically independent Governor Bill Walker’s new proposal is for the state to purchase Fairbanks Natural Gas and its parent company, which would include a natural gas processing plant in Point MacKenzie (NM). Republican lawmakers in particular are skeptical of this move, seeing it as too much government interference in the private sector. In response, Republicans in the state legislature have required that the proposed plan pass through no less than four committees before it can be approved, usually a kiss of death for proposed legislation. Despite these concerns about government intrusion in the private sector, the president of Hilcorp, on of the primary private companies to be impacted by the new plan, said that he is not concerned about the issue (NM). Lawmakers, meanwhile, continue to scratch their heads over the proposed plan and seek more detailed information on Walker’s intentions (PN).

Nunavut to spend more on health and education in new budget

A significant increase in health and education spending is built into Nunavut’s newly unveiled budget for 2015-2016 (NN). The northern territory’s Department of Education budget will increase by 10 percent while the Department of Health budget will increase by six percent. Among the increases, the 2015-2016 budget will boost Nunavut’s spending on mental health issues by approximately 35 percent.  

Polar Bear Day

The 27th February was Polar Bear Day. On this occasion, two articles in the Arctic Journal discuss what this highly emblematic animal of the north and symbol of climate change stands for (AJandAJ). In addition, the journal asks its readers to send them polar bear-related material, “to document the importance of polar bears to their lives” (AJ). In the natural sciences, the cooperation between Russian and Norwegian scientists was announced. The scientists will count the number of polar bears around Svalbard and Franz Josef Land. At last count in 2004, 3000 animals were spotted (BO).


THE POLITICAL SCENE
House of Lords calls for Arctic Ambassador

A report issued by a committee of MPs from the House of Lords has recommends that Britain appoint an ambassador for the Arctic, in the wake of similar moves by fellow non-Arctic countries such as France and Japan (Reuters,NRK– in Norwegian.). The report, “Responding to a changing Arctic,” warns that the UK “risks being ‘outmaneuvered’ by other states” and “says that the UK has a successful history of engagement with the Arctic but concludes that the Government’s approach is too hesitant and cautious” (BO). The report also “recommends an increase in government science budgets focusing on the Arctic…[and] says oil firms should re-consider their plans for drilling in the region” (BBC).
United States
Writing inForeign Policy, Admiral James Stavridis (ret.) argues for the need of an “Arctic Treaty” – using the Antarctic Treaty as a guide – to help ramp down growing militarization in the region.
Russia
Canada
Asia

ENERGY

Sanctions continue to reshape Russia’s Arctic oil and gas sector

News that broke last week about Rosneft seeking relief from obligations on twelve of its Arctic oil and gas leases was the latest indication of how Western sanctions are reshaping Russia’s Arctic oil and gas sector (AD). ExxonMobil announced this week that its suspension of a joint venture in the Russian Arctic with Rosneft, a result of the tightened sanctions, cost the company USD 1 billion last year (Sputnik News). In response to the withdrawal of Western companies from the the country’s oil sector, Russia has been increasingly reaching out to China to finance Arctic exploration and development, though it is unclear whether China will be able to deliver the technical expertise to make many of these projects feasible (Sputnik News). The sanctions’ impacts are being felt outside of the Russian Arctic as well. British regulators this week decided not to approve the sale of 12 British North Sea oil fields to an investment fund owned by a prominent Russian oligarch (Sputnik News).
Alaska

Canada

Russia

Norway
SCIENCE, ENVIRONMENT AND WILDLIFE

Using drones to count reindeer
Norwegian authorities are considering using drones to determine the exact number of reindeer in the country. However, in contrast to taking pictures and counting the reindeer in confined spaces, it is far from certain if drones could be used to count and assign animals to owners over large areas (NRK, in Norwegian).

Climate and weather, ice, water and fire
After nearly 6 months (mbl), the eruption in Holuhraun, Iceland, came to an end on February 28th. The area will continue to be monitored as gas pollution is still detected (mbl).

Wildlife and ecology
A study recently published in the journal Diversity and Distributions concludes that the introduced Kamchatka red king crabs of the Barents Sea are capable of invading the Euro-Arctic shelves in less than three decades. Current management practices of the introduced red king crab are not adequate (Diversity and Distributions).
Environmental management and oil spills
Research and university news
On the occasion of its 25th anniversary, IASC released ashort filmabout the committee’s history (IASC).
Future Arctic Sensing Technologies:DARPA is soliciting innovative research proposals in the area of novel Arctic sensor systems (FBO).
IndianObservatory set up in Arctic region(Deccan Chronicle).

Ottawa company’s drone completes Arctic mission (Ottawa Citizen).



Conferences
Post-graduate summer school "Change and Continuation in the Arctic", Aalborg, Denmark, 12-15 Aug 2015. Application deadline: 9th April (UArctic).
Expeditions & research blogs
And on we go (Ny-Ålesund) (Helmholtz Association AWI, in German).
Recent book publications
Climate Change and the Coast: Building Resilient Communitiesby Bruce Glavovic, Mick Kelly, Robert Kay, Ailbhe Travers (CRC Press).
The Changing Arctic Environment - The Arctic Messengerby David P. Stone. Publication planned for April 2015 (Cambridge University Press).

MILITARY / SEARCH & RESCUE
United States
Alaska Public Media interviewed Admiral Bill Gortney – Commander, NORAD and USNORTHCOM – during his visit to Fort Wainwright and JBER to discuss “the strategic importance of Alaska to the military’s mission.”
CNO Jonathan Greenert has “called for annual or biannual submarine exercises in the Arctic, citing Navy estimates that warmer conditions could lead to reduced ice levels and greater activity in the area in less than a decade” (Reuters).
Russia
Newsweek features an excellent article outlining Russia’s recent actions in the Arctic, and the growing concern over what its motives may be.
Canada
Europe
Lawmakers in Copenhagen have called for clarity from Exelis regarding its takeover of the contract to run facilities services on Thule Air Base (AJ).
MINING
Yukon’s mining investment attractiveness dips

Yukon’s appeal to mining investors has fallen slightly, according to a newly-released report from Canada’s Fraser Institute (CBC). The institute's annual survey ranks investment attractiveness in various countries and regions worldwide based on both mineral potential as well as government policies and regulations. According to the 2014 survey, Yukon was the top region in the world in terms of geologic mineral potential, though it slipped to 26 overall in investors’ perception of government policies. In terms of overall investor attractiveness, Yukon ranked ninth out of 112 countries and regions worldwide, down from eighth in 2013. Elsewhere in Canada, NWT rose from 25 to 15 and Nunavut fell from 27 to 29 in overall attractiveness. Meanwhile, Alaska ranked ninth overall while Finland earned the number one spot (Fraser Institute full report).

Canadian firms Agnico Eagle Mines and Orex Minerals will form a joint partnership to develop Orex's nascent Barsele gold project in northern Sweden (CMJ).
Wellgreen Platinum issued a cost-cutting revision of its preliminary economic assessment for Wellgreen’s platinum group metals and nickel project in southern Yukon, reducing the mine’s life from 37 years to 25 years (NM, CMJ).
Several prominent hedge fund managers are investing heavily in the next generation of Alaska gold mines (PN).
FISHERIES, SHIPPING AND OTHER BUSINESS NEWS

Store Norske and Svalbard’s development in trouble
In the past few months, falling coal prices have meant big trouble for the mining company Store Norske. With its 340 employees, it is an important economic factor on the Norwegian archipelago Svalbard, in particular in the city Longyearbyen (NRK, in Norwegian). Christin Kristoffersen, local council leader, is worried about the number of residents, which is essential for the city’s future development (NRK, in Norwegian).

Fisheries
Shipping
After detaining the Lindavia, chartered by Maersk Lines, for the past two weeks in Unalaskafor environmental crimes related to oil pollution (APM), the Coast Guard released the ship on February 26. The owner posted a $500,000 bond that will be available for any potential future penalties or criminal fines, but some of the crew still have to stay in Alaska (APM).
Aviation
Tourism
Other business and economic news
Russia
Canada and U.S.
Nordics

HEALTH, YOUTH, SOCIETY AND CULTURE
Sen. Murkowski comes out against former IHS Director’s potential reappointment

At a recent Congressional hearing, Alaska Senator Lisa Murkowski told former Director of the Indian Health Service Dr. Yvette Roubideaux that she will not support Ms. Roubideaux’s potential nomination to be reappointed as Director (ANN). While Roubideaux has not yet been nominated to resume running the IHS, Senator Murkowski cited Roubideaux’s failure to address Alaskan issues during her previous tenure as Director in her comments.

Health
Health workers in Nunavut earned over $24 million in overtime pay between 2012 and 2014, roughly half of the Nunavut government’s total overtime spending over the two year period (NN).
Iceland’s Health Minister recently stated that the country is facing a nursing home shortage and will need 480-510 new facilities by 2020, mostly in the Greater Reyk­javik area (mbl).

Youth
In the face of a budget deficit, the Alaska House Finance Subcommittee on Education & Early Development has recommended significant cuts to early education funding (APM).
Four 13-year-old Norwegians are training for an attempt to become among the youngest ever to reach the North Pole as part of a project dubbed “Mission Nansen” (NRK, in Norwegian).

Society
The Central Council of Tlingit and Haida Indian Tribes of Alaska authorized tribal courts to perform same-sex marriages, though it is yet unclear whether the state will recognize the marriage licenses (APM).

Culture
An award-winning exhibit on Arctic architecture, "Arctic Adaptations: Nunavut at 15", will be on display at the Winnipeg Art Gallery from Feb. 27 to May 3 before moving to the Yukon Arts Centre in Whitehorse, then the Museum of Vancouver, and, in 2016, to Calgary’s Illingworth Kerr Gallery (CBC).
An exhibit showcasing artwork from NWT has opened at the newly-renovated Canada House in London (NJ).


INFRASTRUCTURE
Canada
United States
Russia
Europe
Abbreviation Key
Aboriginal Peoples Television Network (APTN)
Aftenbladet (AB)
Alaska Business Monthly (ABM)
Alaska Dispatch (AD)
Alaska Journal of Commerce (AJC)
Alaska Native News (ANN)
Alaska Public Media (APM)
Anchorage Daily News (ADN)
Arctic Info (Russian) (AIR)
Arctic Institute (TAI)
Barents Nova (BN)
Barents Observer (BO)
Bristol Bay Times (BBT)
BusinessWeek (BW)
Canadian Mining Journal (CMJ)
Christian Science Monitor (CSM)
Eye on the Arctic (EOTA)
Fairbanks Daily News-Miner (FNM)
Financial Times (FT)
Globe and Mail (G&M)
Government of Canada (GOC)
Government of the Northwest Territories (GNWT)
Huffington Post (HP)
Indian Country Today Media Network (ICTMN)
Johnson’s Russia List (JRL)
Kalaallit Nunaata Radioa (KNR)
Lapin Kansa (LK)
Moscow Times (MT)
National Geographic (NG)
Natural Gas Europe (NGE)
Naval Today (NT)
New York Times (NYT)
Northern Journal (NJ)
Northern News Service Online (NNSO)
Northern Public Affairs (NPA)
Norwegian Polar Institute (NPI)
Nunatsiaq News (NN)
Oil & Gas Journal (OGJ)
Ottawa Citizen (OC)
Petroleum News (PN)
RIA Novosti (RIAN)
Russia Beyond the Headlines (RBTH)
Russia Today (RT)
Voice of Russia (VOR)




High North Dialogue 2015 - Interview with Christian Marcussen

$
0
0



High North Dialogue 2015 - Interview with Christian Marcussen
Marc Jacobsen, March 9, 2015

Screen Shot 2014-11-10 at 4.06.30 PM.png

In our 4th podcast for the High North Dialogue 2015 we talked with Christian Marcussen who is project leader of the Greenland part of the Continental Shelf Project of the Kingdom of Denmark.

Christian Marcussen was appointed to his present position when the Danish UNCLOS project started in 2003 and has worked at the Geological Survey for Denmark and Greenland for more than 25 years mainly with seismic data acquisition, processing and interpretation both onshore and offshore Greenland.
In December 2014, the Kingdom of Denmark submitted its territorial claim of almost 900,000 square kilometres in the Arctic Ocean, including most of the Lomonosov Ridge and the geographic North Pole. In order to get a more thorough understanding of the process and the thoughts behind this comprehensive project, we asked Marcussen to share his knowledge with us.

Marcussen told us how the sometimes challenging data collection could not have been done without help from fellow Arctic neighbours – Sweden, Russia and Canada in particular – and stressed that the project has been conducted with respect to international law as agreed by the five littoral states in Ilulissat in 2008. By referring to this agreement and by telling that the recent claim is based on the same concept and methodology as past successful claims, Marcussen rejected the critique by Alexander Sergunin’s stated in our 3rd. Marcussen underlined that he is, thus, quite confident that the CLCS will approve the Kingdom of Denmark’s claim.

Though the geographic North Pole is placed 4,300 metres below sea level in an inhospitable, ice covered area with no reported natural resources in the seabed, Marcussen had no doubt that the project has been worth the effort. According to Marcussen it is “inherent for all coastal states that they try to exploit the possibilities of extending their continental shelves beyond 200 nautical miles” and, as he said, “you never know what resources there might be a 100 years from now”.
Marc Jacobsen: Hello and welcome to this 4th podcast for the High North Dialogue 2015, a collaboration of the University of Nordland, the University’s High North Centre for Business and Governance, and The Arctic Institute. We are speaking with attendees and speakers about their work, the High North Dialogue and the conference’s theme of security and business in the Arctic.
Thanks for joining us. I am Marc Jacobsen.
Today we are talking with Christian Marcussen, who is project leader of the Greenland part of the Continental Shelf Project of the Kingdom of Denmark. After completing his M.Sc. in geophysics at the University of Aarhus (Denmark) he has worked at the Geological Survey for Denmark and Greenland for more than 25 years mainly with seismic data acquisition, processing and interpretation both onshore and offshore Greenland. He was appointed to his present position when the Danish UNCLOS project started in 2003.
Hi Christian. Thanks for joining us today
Christian Marcussen: Hi Marc, thanks for calling me and I look forward to our interview.
Marc Jacobsen: Could you please start by telling us about your work in connection to the Kingdom of Denmark’s continental shelf project? Why was this comprehensive project initiated and how has it been conducted - scientifically as well as practically?
Christian Marcussen: Of course the framework for our work has been UNCLOS article 76, which gives coastal state the possibility of extending its continental shelf beyond 200 nautical miles.
The project was initiated in 2003 and of course the main objectives of the project were to identify potential areas in the Kingdom of Denmark where the continental shelf can be extended beyond 200 nautical miles. We have identified five potential claim areas, two around the Faroe Islands and three around Greenland.
The next objective of the project has been to obtain the necessary database to document submission to the Commission on the Limits of the Continental Shelf, so that is the main objective of the continental shelf project. So the status right now at the end of 2014, the project has submitted five partial submissions to the Commission on the Limits of the Continental Shelf, CLCS. One in the area north of the Faroe Islands (NFM), where the CLCS made itsrecommendations public available and endorsing the entire area claimed by the government of Denmark together with the government of the Faroes. And there is an area south of the Faroe Islands (SFM) and then, as I said, three areas around Greenland:south of Greenland (SGM), north-east of Greenland (NEGM) and lastly in December a submission regarding the Arctic Ocean was send to the CLCS(NGM).
Marc Jacobsen: And how have you, in practice, collected data for the project?
Christian Marcussen: In most of the areas we have used standard methods to require the necessary data. Its mainly bathymetric and seismic data we have acquired because according to the  provisions of article 76, those are the most important to document the claim. However, in the Arctic Ocean it has been somewhat of a challenge, because this area north of Greenland is still ice covered, and this ice cover is permanent and ice thickness are up to 3-4 metres and with pressure ridges, which are up to 20 metres thick, so this is really a challenge. So in order to acquire the necessary data in that area we had to develop a concept that is based, first of all, on good cooperation with other nations – first of all Canada and Sweden – and then also we have developed some new methods to acquire the data. So the concept is, in very few words, we have worked on the ice close to the coast to acquire some data, bathymetric and seismic data, and then we have used the Swedish icebreaker Oden in the central part of the Arctic Ocean. And even one year this icebreaker was supported by a Russian nuclear icebreaker. So this has been quite a challenge, but during the three expeditions with the Swedish icebreaker Oden and other expeditions on the ice, I think we have acquired the necessary data in that area to document our submission.    

Marc Jacobsen: According to some Danish newspaper articles (e.g.:http://www.information.dk/509667), the original plan was to claim approximately 150,000 square kilometres North of Greenland. In the spring of 2014 it was extended to at least 400,000 square kilometres, but ultimately it ended up being more than the double. What happened during this process that led you to conclude that the Kingdom of Denmark can justify a claim of almost 900,000 square kilometres – including the majority of the Lomonosov Ridge and the North Pole?

Christian Marcussen: Maybe I should just add a few facts to your previous question, sorry. I would just mention that the project has a total budget of 330 million Danish Kroner, which equals 44 million Euros, from 2003 to 2014. Approximately one third was used for data acquisition in the Arctic Ocean, one third for data acquisition in the remaining four areas and one third to compile the data, to do the interpretation and of course also to finalize the submissions.
We have a website which iswww.a76.dk where a lot of information is available for the public describing both the activities within the project, but also some general information on UNCLOS.
Now to go back to your last question, I can comment that unfortunately there is some misunderstanding especially related to the first figure, the 150,000 square kilometres. This figure originates from a desktop study eight years ago, which was based on public available data and, last but not least, limited by unofficial median lines. So this is just an unofficial number, and the numbers you mentioned have never been in any way official numbers, so they don’t describe an official statement regarding the size of the submission area in the Arctic Ocean. And I would like to add that the recent submission in the Arctic Ocean by the Kingdom of Denmark is based on the same concept as used for the other four submission areas and that is to exploit the possibilities of Article 76 in UNCLOS to its full extent provided the necessary documentation is available. And I have to add that all five Partial Submissions are based on measured data – either acquired by the Project or publicly available data.

Marc Jacobsen: In the last podcast we interviewed Professor Alexander Sergunin from St. Petersburg State University who said: “I guess the chance for the approval of the Danish application is not very good, not very high. My impression is that Denmark repeats the same mistakes like Russia did in 2001, so I mean the legal experts said that the chances are not very good”. What is your reaction to Mr. Sergunin’s statement? And how do you assess the Kingdom of Denmark’s chances to get the application approved?

Christian Marcussen: Let me answer the question this way:As previously mentioned the recent submission is the latest of five submissions of the Kingdom of Denmark. Since the Continental Shelf Project was launched in 2003 a lot of experience regarding extended continental shelf issues has been gained within the project. Please also remember that the CLCS adopted recommendations regarding the Partial Submission north of the Faroe Islands in March of 2014 – last year. The Commission agreed with the determination of the fixed points establishing the outer limits of the continental shelf north of the Faroe Islands as originally listed in the submission. That means, that the Commission in general has agreed to the concept and the methodology used for this area. And I can tell you that the same concept and methodology has been applied to the other four areas and therefore also to the submission in the Arctic Ocean. We have studied the CLCS recommendations regarding the 2001 submission by the Russian Federation in the Arctic Ocean very carefully. We are furthermore fully aware of the requirements regarding a submission as stated in the Scientific and Technical Guidelines of the CLCS. And let me stress again that all points delineating the Outer Limits of the Northern Continental Shelf of Greenland as shown in the Executive Summary are based on measured data. We now have to wait for examination of this Partial Submission in the Arctic Ocean by the CLCS, which will happen in due time and according to the modus operandi of the CLCS and my best guess is that this will happen after 2020. We know from our previous experience with the partial submission regarding the area north of the Faroes, that the commission regarding our Arctic submission will scrutinize the documentation included in the Arctic submission very carefully before the CLCS will issue their recommendations.

Marc Jacobsen: So does it mean that the Kingdom of Denmark has good chances or not to get its application approved?

Christian Marcussen: I think from the context of my answer, which is based on the same concept which has proven to be successful, you can gather that we are quite confident, but in general I think we have to wait for the decisions or the recommendations from the CLCS, and then judge from their recommendation if our submission is successful or not. So I think we should give the CLCS the time to scrutinize our submission and then take it from there.

Marc Jacobsen: Another interesting fact about the territorial claim is that it reaches Russia’s Exclusive Economic Zone, 200 nautical miles from shore. While the official reaction from Kremlin has been rather diplomatic (http://www.mid.ru/brp_4.nsf/0/0F1A381933F7FCDDC3257DB1004B45CE), Professor Michael Byers, who we interviewed in our first podcast for the High North Dialogue 2015, has stated in a Danish newspaper article (http://politiken.dk/udland/ECE2486050/eksperter-dansk-krav-om-nordpolen-vil-irritere-rusland/): “there has so far been a spirit of cooperation in the Arctic, but with Denmark's claim it is possible that this atmosphere can be greatly affected. It is quite possible that Russia will punish Denmark with a significant expansion of the Russian territorial claim or even with a veto against the Danish claim” Do you agree with Mr. Byers that the Kingdom of Denmark’s claim may have negative influence on the cooperative Arctic atmosphere? And how do you think possible overlapping claims will be solved?

Christian Marcussen: Of course this question regards some issues which are not my field of expertise, however, I can just quote the Ilulissat Declaration from 2008 (http://www.oceanlaw.org/downloads/arctic/Ilulissat_Declaration.pdf) where the Arctic Coastal States have agreed to “Notably, the law of the sea provides for important rights and obligations concerning the delineation of the outer limits of the continental shelf, the protection of the marine environment, including ice-covered areas, freedom of navigation, marine scientific research, and other uses of the sea”. And then they say the important thing: “We remain committed to this legal framework and to the orderly settlement of any possible overlapping claims” (Ilulissat Declaration 2008). So I think that that is describing the sense of cooperation which is in the Arctic Ocean, and I would also like to explain that in order to define the final outer limits of the continental shelf the following three steps are involved: First of all we have to delineate the outer limits of the continental shelf, which is a scientific/technical/legal process. The next step is of course the examination of the submission by the CLCS. And then the third step is the delimitation of overlapping claims, if such overlap exists, and this is a diplomatic/political process.Unfortunately it seems that these different steps have been mixed up in the public. Furthermore, it is important to note that the CLCS is a technical body responsible for making recommendations pertaining to the outer limits of the continental shelf. It has no mandate to resolve overlapping maritime boundaries, and submissions to it “are without prejudice to the question of delimitation of the continental shelf between States with opposite or adjacent coasts”. (Article 76.10) So the responsibility for resolving such disputes rests with the states involved. Furthermore in Chapter 7 of the Executive Summary of the recent Partial Submission by the Kingdom of Denmark (http://www.un.org/depts/los/clcs_new/submissions_files/dnk76_14/dnk2014_es.pdf) it is clearly stated that there are potential overlaps of entitlement to the Northern Continental Shelf of Greenland. It is also stated that the other Artic coastal states are expected to file non-objection notes with the CLCS – Norway and Canada have already done this (http://www.un.org/depts/los/clcs_new/submissions_files/submission_dnk_76_2014.htm). So this is the framework for solving overlapping claim issues and I think that all the Arctic states have agreed to this procedure.

Marc Jacobsen: And now to the last question: According to the few existing geological estimates of the seabed in the area, which the Kingdom of Denmark is claiming, there are no significant oil or gas deposits. Harsh environment, unpredictable weather, thick sea ice and the fact that the seabed is placed approximately 4,300 meters below sea level, do, however, also make it almost impossible to exploit any resources if there was any. What is the purpose of the Kingdom of Denmark’s claim to this area? Is it merely of symbolic value or would it provide any new opportunities?

Christian Marcussen: Yes in general terms, the Article 76 provides the opportunity for all coastal states to extend their continental shelf beyond 200 nautical miles and the outer limit of the continental shelf of a coastal state is therefore one of the maritime boundaries (like the territorial sea or the Exclusive Economic Zone) a coastal state should delineated. So that’s a more principal issue of coastal states have to solve, in my opinion. Beyond 200 nautical miles the coastal state will have sovereign rights to resources on and below the seabed. And of course that also means that a coastal state can decide not to exercise these rights. Admittedly according to the well-known study from 2008 by the US Geological Survey regarding Arctic hydrocarbon resources, the chances to find oil or gas in the central part of the Arctic Ocean are very small. However, I do not want to speculate what resources could be of interest 100 years from now. Please also note that matters related to mineral resources on- and offshore Greenland since 2010 are handled by the Government of Greenland as stated in the Act on Greenland Self-Government. So it is actually a question for the government of Greenland

Marc Jacobsen: So if there aren’t any natural resources in the area, why then are Canada, Russia and the Kingdom of Denmark so keen on including the North Pole into their respective national territories? Is it merely because of the symbolic value, or is there another reason?

Christian Marcussen: I think it’s inherent for all coastal states that they try to exploit the possibilities of extending their continental shelves beyond 200 nautical miles, and of course article 76 gives the coastal states this opportunity. And as I said, you never know what resources there might be a 100 years from now, so I think it is just to secure the rights, and also to define this type of boundary.

Marc Jacobsen: Well, thank you for clarifying and thank you for taking the time to share your knowledge with us today.  It has been very inspirational and I look very much forward to see you at the coming High North Dialogue in Bodø.

Christian Marcussen: Thank you Marc, and I also look forward to attend the meeting in Bodø.

Marc Jacobsen: Thanks for joining us for this podcast. Follow along with the series on iTunes or via our websiteswww.highnorthdialogue.no andwww.thearcticinstitute.org
The music you’ve heard at the beginning and at the end comes from Hebber Zepherin and can be found atwww.ccmixture.org



























Viewing all 366 articles
Browse latest View live